Mesiras Nefesh
Parsha Pages | July 23, 2023
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Mesiras Nefesh

Parsha Pages | December 31, 2025

ובכל נפשך (ו, ה) אפילו הוא נוטל את נפשך, מכאן אמרו, חייב אדם לברך על הרעה כשם שמברך על הטובה (ברכות נ"ד א')

It is explained that this concept extends even to the point that someone wishes to take your life, you should love HaShem. The Gemara then cites the example of Rabbi Akiva. The Romans took him out to kill him, and they combed his skin with an iron comb (to torture him first), at that time Rabbi Akiva accepted these circumstances upon himself as the yoke of Heaven. His students then asked רבנו, עד כאן? And Rabbi Akiva answered, “All my life I worried about this verse and its explanation (that one should accept the decree of Heaven even if they come to take your life) and I would say when would this happen for me. And now that event has come to me, wouldn’t I wish to fulfill it?” He then lengthened in the word אחד, until his soul left his body. A Bas Kol (Divine voice) went out and said, “Fortunate is Rabbi Akiva that you prepared a guaranteed spot in the future life.”

T.T. What is the question of the students, עד כאן since they already knew this derivation “until they want to take your life”? Thus, it appears some of the text is left out of the Bavli, and we can follow the text from the Yerushalmi. There it explains that the incident occurred at the time for one to say Krias Shema, and as Rabbi Akiva said the Shema, he “laughed”. And then his students questioned him about the “laughter” and only then, did Rabbi Akiva answered what he answered.

And now according to the Gemara that Rabbi Akiva desired his whole life to die Al Kiddush HaShem, one can understand the Gemara (ערובין כ"א ב') where Rabbi Akiva was in jail and did not have enough water to properly wash his hands. And Rabbi Akiva said better for me to die my own death (מיתת עצמי) then to transgress the words of the fellows (who made the decree to wash one’s hands). It should have been enough to say I would die rather than transgress. But according to what we explained above that Rabbi Akiva desired to die Al Kiddush HaShem, we can understand that Rabbi Akiva meant to say, the words of his fellow Rabbis were so important that he would give up his “special-desired” death and die a natural death rather than transgress their decree.

ובכל נפשך (ו, ה) אפילו הוא נוטל את נפשך, מכאן אמרו, חייב אדם לברך על הרעה כשם שמברך על הטובה (ברכות נ"ד א')

It is explained that this concept extends even to the point that someone wishes to take your life, you should love HaShem. The Gemara then cites the example of Rabbi Akiva. The Romans took him out to kill him, and they combed his skin with an iron comb (to torture him first), at that time Rabbi Akiva accepted these circumstances upon himself as the yoke of Heaven. His students then asked רבנו, עד כאן? And Rabbi Akiva answered, “All my life I worried about this verse and its explanation (that one should accept the decree of Heaven even if they come to take your life) and I would say when would this happen for me. And now that event has come to me, wouldn’t I wish to fulfill it?” He then lengthened in the word אחד, until his soul left his body. A Bas Kol (Divine voice) went out and said, “Fortunate is Rabbi Akiva that you prepared a guaranteed spot in the future life.”

T.T. What is the question of the students, עד כאן since they already knew this derivation “until they want to take your life”? Thus, it appears some of the text is left out of the Bavli, and we can follow the text from the Yerushalmi. There it explains that the incident occurred at the time for one to say Krias Shema, and as Rabbi Akiva said the Shema, he “laughed”. And then his students questioned him about the “laughter” and only then, did Rabbi Akiva answered what he answered.

And now according to the Gemara that Rabbi Akiva desired his whole life to die Al Kiddush HaShem, one can understand the Gemara (ערובין כ"א ב') where Rabbi Akiva was in jail and did not have enough water to properly wash his hands. And Rabbi Akiva said better for me to die my own death (מיתת עצמי) then to transgress the words of the fellows (who made the decree to wash one’s hands). It should have been enough to say I would die rather than transgress. But according to what we explained above that Rabbi Akiva desired to die Al Kiddush HaShem, we can understand that Rabbi Akiva meant to say, the words of his fellow Rabbis were so important that he would give up his “special-desired” death and die a natural death rather than transgress their decree.

PDF Preview