Skip to content
Samcheinu B'Yeshuosecho A4

A Powerful Limud from Mamrei!

  • Vayeira
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

The Parsha begins by telling us that Hashem came to visit Avrohom Ovinu in Elonei Mamrei after he had fulfilled the Mitzva of Bris Miloh. Despite having just done Bris Milah, Avrohom sat outside his tent hoping for guests to arrive so that he could fulfil the Mitzva of Hachnosas Orchim. Due to this, Hashem took the cover off the sun to dissuade anyone from travelling so that Avrohom wouldn’t have to bother himself to do Hachnosas Orchim. However, upon seeing how desperate Avrohom was to fulfil this mitzva, Hashem sent him three Malochim in the guise of wayfarers, and with great Mesiras Nefesh he served them a meal. Rashi queries why does the posuk mention that Hashem appeared to Avrohom in Elonei Mamrei? He answers because Mamrei gave Avrohom advice regarding the Bris Miloh, and so Hashem visited Avrohom in Mamrei’s portion.

He does not withhold reward

The מדרש תנחומא (ג':א') elaborates regarding this advice that Mamrei gave and says the following, “And Hashem appeared to him in the portion of Mamrei (וירא י"ח:ו) Why did Hashem appear there? “אין הקב"ה מקפח שכר כל בריה” - For He does not withhold a reward from any of His creatures. Avrohom had three friends, Oner, Eshkol, and Mamrei, and when Hashem commanded Avrohom to circumcise himself, he consulted each of them. He first went to Oner and related to him what Hashem had said. Oner replied: “Do you wish to cripple yourself so severely that when the descendants of the kings whom you have slain attack, you won’t be able to flee from them?” He left him and went to Eshkol and told him what Hashem had commanded. Eshkol responded: “You are an old man, and if you are circumcised, considerable blood will flow from you, and you will not be able to survive the loss and will perish.”

He departed from him, and went to Mamrei and said, “What do you advise?” Mamrei replied, “Do you need to seek my advice in such a matter? Did Hashem not release you from the fiery furnace, perform miracles on your behalf, and rescue you from kings? The fact is that you would have been destroyed long ago were it not for His strength and His might. He saved your two hundred and forty-eight limbs, yet you ask advice concerning one of your organs? Do as He commanded you!” Consquently, Hashem said: Blessed shall you be for having advised him to be circumcised; I shall reveal Myself to him only in your territory. And so, it is written: Hashem appeared to him in the portion of Mamrei.”

Mamrei encouraged Avrohom

The Meforshim note that the reason why Avrohom took advice here when Hashem had told him explicitly to do Bris Miloh was because Avrohom was unsure whether to do the Mitzva and publicise the fact that he had done so or to keep it private. Mamrei encouraged him not to be afraid to publicise it and so he was rewarded by Hashem appearing in his portion. It’s also written in the Torah for eternity as an everlasting tribute to Mamrei for giving this advice to Avrohom.

No simple matter

When we take note of what happened here, it seems that Avrohom just knocked on Mamrei’s door for some advice and Mamrei answered him: go ahead and do it. However, when we look beneath the surface, it’s clear that it was no simple matter for Mamrei to give Avrohom such advice. This is evident from the tremendous reward that he was granted, because to receive a reward of having Hashem appear in his portion and having his name mentioned in the Torah this would only be given to someone who had accomplished something truly significant. So, let’s understand, what was really going on here that resulted in Mamrei receiving such a phenomenal reward from Hashem?

A danger for all

In truth, Mamrei’s words to Avrohom involved tremendous Mesiras Nefesh both in a physical and spiritual sense. Why? This can be learnt from the reply that Oner gave to Avrohom mentioned in the Medrash. “Do you wish to cripple yourself so severely that when the descendants of the kings whom you have slain attack, that you will be unable to flee from them?” The ספר כרם הצבי (פ') explains this in more detail. He says that since Avrohom had such amazing success in vanquishing the four kings and their armies, they were waiting for the opportunity to take revenge against Avrohom and his camp. By Avrohom following Mamrei’s advice to do Bris Miloh for his household and to publicise it despite his weakened state, this not only placed Avrohom into great danger but also all those who were associated with him - including Oner, Eshkol and Mamrei since they were the Ba’alei Bris – friendly with Avrohom. In fact, this is one of the reasons why Avrohom asked each of them whether he should do Bris Miloh and publicise it since one mustn’t rely on a Neis, and they would all be placed into mortal danger as a result of it, with the enemies of Avrohom taking the opportunity to attack and destroy Avrohom together with Oner, Eshkol and Mamrei.

A great level of Mesiras Nefesh

Despite this, Mamrei told Avrohom that since he was used to great Nissim being done for him, he needn’t do it in private; but rather publicise it and rely on Hashem to protect him from any harm. By making that suggestion to Avrohom, Mamrei was putting his own life into danger too. This clarifies why he was so rewarded by Hashem because he displayed such a great level of Mesiras Nefesh by giving Avrohom this advice.

In fact, the tremendous potential for danger in doing the Bris Miloh can be seen from רש"י (י"ז:כ"ג) which brings the following: “On that very day that he was commanded – by day – and not by night; he was not afraid of the gentiles nor the scoffers. Another reason he did it by day was so that his enemies and contemporaries should not say, “Had we seen him, we would not have allowed him to perform Bris Miloh and to fulfil the commandments of Hashem.” The enormous physical danger that Avrohom could have faced on the day he did Bris Miloh is clear from Rashi, and this gives us a deeper understanding into the Mesiras Nefesh that was required from Mamrei to give such advice to Avrohom, knowing that there was real danger present for Avrohom and his Ba’alei Bris if he did so.

The impact on Klal Yisroel

The פניני דעת (ל"ו) makes another point which gives us a further insight into why Mamrei was so rewarded. He asks, Klal Yisroel throughout the ages do this Mitzva of Bris Miloh with great Mesiras Nefesh, where do they get the strength from to do so? The answer is, that this Mesiras Nefesh has its roots in the Mesiras Nefesh that was put into this Mitzva the first time when it was performed by Avrohom. And so, throughout history, Klal Yisroel have been Moser Nefesh for this Mitzva. This provides us with another reason why Mamrei was so rewarded for giving such advice – because he was instrumental in Klal Yisroel also doing Bris Miloh in future generations with Mesiras Nefesh too!

A question

We have discussed the physical Mesiras Nefesh that was required from Mamrei. However, spiritually too, giving such advice involved great Mesiras Nefesh from him. Why?

The פתחי אברהם (ע"א) explains, Rashi (י"ד:י"ג) mentioned that Avrohom made a covenant together with Oner, Eshkol and Mamrei that they would support and help each other. The question is, Oner, Eshkol and Mamrei were from the seven nations that occupied Eretz Cana’an, and the posuk in דברים )'ז':ב( explicitly states that it’s forbidden to make a covenant with any of these seven nations. If so, how was Avrohom permitted to make a Bris of friendship with them?

Losing a connection with Avrohom

He answers, that the reason why Avrohom could make a Bris together with them was because it was done prior to him making a Bris with Hashem. However, once Avrohom made a Bris with Hashem, it then became forbidden to make a Bris with any of the nations. Therefore, by Avrohom doing Bris Miloh, the Bris between Avrohom and Oner, Eshkol and Mamrei would be dissolved.

Mamrei knew that by encouraging Avrohom to do Bris Miloh he would lose this opportunity to have a connection to Avrohom. Remarkably, he still advised Avrohom to go ahead and do Bris Miloh and publicise it in order so that everyone would know that Avrohom now had a Bris only with Hashem! This demonstrates further the incredible Mesiras Nefesh on Mamrei’s part to give Avrohom such advice even though it meant that he lost the opportunity of having a Bris with Avrohom.

Why Oner and Eshkol discouraged Avrohom

The שפת אמת (תרל"ד) elaborates further on this point. He says that Mamrei also understood that as a result of Avrohom doing Bris Miloh, it meant that for eternity, all of Avrohom’s children would share this special connection to Hashem - something which the nations of the world wouldn’t have any part in. Due to this, Oner and Eshkol discouraged Avrohom from fulfilling the Mitzva since they would lose their connection to Avrohom forever. However, Mamrei was different. He understood that this was the way it had to be, even though he would personally lose so much from giving such advice.

His own honour increases

As a result of Mamrei’s Mesiras Nefesh, an incredible thing happened. Rather than Mamrei losing out on having a connection to Avrohom by giving such advice, he gained from doing so. How? Because Avrohom did Bris Miloh in his portion and Hashem personally decided to visit Avrohom there, and as a result, Mamrei’s connection to Hashem was strengthened.

The אילת השחר writes how this brought Mamrei tremendous spiritual pleasure and granted him the awesome zechus that his name is mentioned forever in the Torah. The Sfas Emes brings that this is a true fulfilment of the מדרש רבה במדבר (ד':כ') which says that Eliyahu said תנא דבי אליהו רבה (י"ג): "Anyone who increases Kovod Shomayim and diminishes his own honour, Kovod Shomayim increases and his own honour increases." Here, since Mamrei was prepared to diminish his own honour by encouraging Avrohom to do Bris Miloh, even though this would result in him becoming distanced from Avrohom by giving such advice, he was rewarded immensely. And so, he was granted a tremendous connection with Hashem through Avrohom doing Bris Miloh in his portion, and is mentioned in the Torah forever.

The two requests by a Bris Miloh

The ספר תורת בריסק (פ"א) asks, what was the Middah K’neged Middah in the particular reward that Mamrei received here?” He explains it based on the Rambam. The Nusach of the Brocha that we say at a Bris incorporates two requests that we ask from Hashem. The first is that as a result of Mitzvas Miloh, there should be Hashro’as Ha’Shechina amongst us and we should merit a connection to Hashem. The second is that due to the fulfilment of Mitzvas Miloh, the child should be protected from all harm. This teaches us that Mitzvas Miloh increases Hashro’as HaShechina in Klal Yisroel. Therefore, as a result of his advice he was rewarded that the Shechina came down to Avrohom in his portion.

To bring Shechina down to earth

The greatness of bringing down Shechina to the world cannot be underestimated and can be seen from the following Medrash Raboh in שיר השירים (ה':א') which highlights its importance. ”Odom, the first man, sinned and as a result the Shechina ascended to the first Rokia – sky. Cain sinned and it ascended to the second sky. Enosh sinned and it ascended to the third sky. The Generation of the Flood sinned and it ascended to the fourth sky. The Generation of the Tower sinned and it ascended to the fifth sky. The residents of Sodom sinned and it ascended to the sixth sky. The Mitzriyim sinned during the days of Avrohom and it ascended to the seventh sky.

Corresponding to them were seven Tzadikim who brought the Shechina back to earth. Avrohom lowered it from the seventh sky to the sixth. Yitzchok lowered it from the sixth to the fifth. Yaakov lowered it from the fifth to the fourth. Levi lowered it from the fourth to the third. Kehos lowered it from the third to the second. Amrom lowered it from the second to the first. Moshe lowered it to earth. Reb Yitzchok said: That is what is written: " צדיקים יירשו ארץ וישכנו לעד עליה" - “The righteous will inherit the earth and dwell upon it forever” (תהלים ל"ז:כ"ט).

Why Mamrei was so rewarded

Mamrei encouraged Avrohom to do Bris Miloh and publicise it, this helped Avrohom in his Avoda of bringing the Shechina down to this world. It therefore comes as no surprise that Mamrei was so rewarded by Hashem that Hashem appeared in his portion, since this is the greatest thing that a person can do - to bring the Shechina back into this world.

The impact you can have

It’s clear from our Parsha how we can never know the tremendous impact that even a single word of encouragement can have on another person. Mamrei teaches us about its importance and the great reward given to those who offer good advice and encourage those who are working to increase Kovod Shomayim and bring Shechina into the world. We also learn from him how a little bit of advice given to Avrohom influenced not only what happened then but indeed had a lasting impact for generations to come that Klal Yisroel also fulfil this Mitzva with Mesiras Nefesh.

The message we can take from this is how we too can have a tremendous impact. This can be achieved in so many different ways. On an individual level, we can advise and encourage others to reach greater heights in their Mitzvos and Avodas Hashem, and offer them support and assistance. On a communal level, we can help those who initiate new projects in our communities to increase Kovod Shomayim, by sharing the responsibility with them and helping ensure their success. If we do so we will also gain the tremendous merit of bringing Hashro’as HaShechina into Klal Yisroel!