עוד יוסף חי - 37:20 “ועתה לכו ונהרגהו ונשלכהו באחד הבורות ואמרנו חיה רעה אכלתהו, ונראה מה יהיו חלומותיו” – “And now, come and let us kill him, and throw him into one of the pits; and we will say, ‘A wild beast devoured him.’ Then we will see what will become of his dreams.” Why did the Torah write, “רעה” that it was a “bad” animal that devoured Yosef, instead of just saying, “חיה אכלתהו” – that an animal devoured Yosef? The brothers wanted Yaakov to lose complete hope that Yosef was still alive, so that he would not send people to look for him. Had they just said, “חיה אכלתהו” – that an animal devoured Yosef, Yaakov would have said that it is impossible, for Chazal tell us that no harm comes to Shluchei Mitzvah (One who is in the process of performing a Mitzvah); and Yosef was doing the Mitzvah of Kibbud Av, of going to see how the brothers were. Therefore, they said, “חיה רעה אכלתהו” – that it was a wild beast, which for a wild beast it is common for it to devour people. There is a caveat to the rule that Shluchei Mitzvah are not harmed, and that is that if they are in a situation where being harmed is usual and common, from that type of harm they are not protected. As the Gemara in Kiddushin 39b says that if one goes on a weak rickety ladder, then even if he is performing a Mitzvah, he may be harmed, for when one goes on a ladder like that it is regular and common for him to get hurt. By saying that it was a “חיה רעה” they were telling Yaakov that Yosef would not have been saved from harm for it was a wild beast, and thus Yaakov was to give up complete hope in ever finding Yosef alive.
More in this printout
- Maharsha on Yaakov's Refusal to Be ConsoledAn analysis of the Maharsha and Rashi on why Yaakov Avinu could not be consoled for Yosef, exploring the connection between mourning and the promise of Olam Hab
- Tiferes Yehonasan on Yosef's Leadership and Wild BeastsThe Tiferes Yehonasan explains the brothers' plan to test Yosef's leadership dreams by seeing if he could survive a wild beast, a trait of Jewish leaders.
- Ben Ish Chai on Yosef's Name and ProphecyThe Ben Ish Chai explains how the brothers' words contained a prophecy about the Angel Gabriel adding the letter Hei to Yosef's name as mentioned in Tehillim.
- Ben Ish Chai on the Miracle of Seeing Yosef from AfarThe Ben Ish Chai explains that the brothers seeing Yosef from afar was a miracle intended to allow their anger to dissipate before his arrival, saving his life.
- Bereishis Rabbah on the Valley of ChevronAn analysis of Bereishis Rabbah 84:13 explaining why the Torah describes Chevron as a valley and its connection to the covenant with Avraham Avinu.
- Malbim on Yaakov Sending YosefAn analysis of the Malbim on Parshat Vayeshev, exploring how Yaakov could send Yosef to his brothers and the divine providence behind the sale of Yosef.
- Mahar"i Shteif on the Brocha of Lighting Chanukah LampsMahar"i Shteif explains why the Chanukah blessing uses the word Ner, symbolizing how performing mitzvos through the light of Torah grants them eternal impact.
- Tosfos Brocha on Reuven, Chanukah, and Publicizing MiraclesAn exploration of the Midrashic connection between Reuven's rescue of Yosef and the Mitzvah of publicizing the miracle of Chanukah candles.
- Bereishis Rabbah and Etz Yosef on the Sin of the ShevatimAn analysis of Midrashic commentary on the brothers' rebuke of Binyamin, exploring the sin of the Shevatim, divine providence, and the power of admitting one's