Skip to content
Brooklyn Torah Gazette

Rav Avigdor Miller On Being Glad to be Alive

  • Vayeitzei
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

QUESTION: Before I came into the world I was perfectly content and now I’m not content. I had no problems before I was born and now I have problems. So why is it good that I’m here? It’s better I wasn’t.

ANSWER: This gentleman is dissatisfied that he was brought into the world. Now suppose somebody will do you a favor as you walk out of here on the dark side street; suppose a kind-hearted goy will say to you, “Your time is up.” Are you going to say, “Oh, I was just waiting for you. Thank you”? No. You’ll do your best to continue to remain here.

The answer is you understand how good it is. You understand how good it is. So, it’s just talk that you’re not happy. You’re happy in this world.

Now there’s a statement, על כרחך אתה נולד – against your will you were created. You were born against your will but once you come into this world and you see the glories of this world you want to stay as long as you can. Only that before you were born you weren’t yet given all the senses that make you fall in love with the world and you have other senses that make you fall in love with the other world. But once you get these senses, you discover that Olam Hazeh iz a gutte zach.

And it’s so good, this world, that the Mesillas Yesharim has to spend time in the beginning of his sefer, in the first perek he spends a lot of time explaining that this world is not the ikar. He has to argue with us and explain that this world is not the main thing.

Now it seems queer to us. We’re ma’aminim. Why do you have to tell us that? The Mesillas Yesharim is just a recent sefer, 200 years ago. He didn’t give it to us on Har Sinai. We know about Olam Haba. And still, he spends time and effort convincing us that this world is not the ikar. So, we see that this world is so delightful that it’s possible to think, yes there is an Olam Haba, but this world is also very good, very important.

So maybe this world is like the main course only that after that they’ll serve a Viennese table let’s say and give you some more delicacies afterwards. So, you have to prove that this world is not the main world. We see from that that there is a lot to say on behalf of this world. So, it’s just talk — talk and an attitude of unthinking that makes you say such things.

Reprinted from a recent email of Toras Avigdor based on a transcription of a classic Rav Avigdor Miller Thursday night hashkafah class delivered on October 25, 1979.

More in this printout

View the whole printout