Skip to content
Hashgacha Pratis

Hashgachah Pratis in Sifrei Kodesh

  • Vayishlach
  • 5785
  • English
View printout

Yaakov Asked to Dwell in Peace

Rabi Acha said: When the tzaddikim are at ease and ask for tranquility in this world, the satan comes and counters their request, saying: Is it not enough that they will receive their reward in Olam Haba, that they ask for peace in this world [as well]?!

Yaakov Avinu suffered much because of Eisav and Lavan and the events involving his daughter Dina. Then, after all these tzaros were behind him and he finally experienced some peace – he asked for continued peace in this world, and the satan jumped in to bring more anguish upon him. Thus, immediately after it says ‘Vayeishev Yaakov,’ implying that Yaakov had a measure of peace, the Torah relates Yosef’s dreams and his subsequent sale into slavery.

(Adapted from Bereishis Rabbah 84:1)

The Good Will Come on Its Own

It seems strange that Hashem was ‘angry’ at a tzaddik for asking for peace in this world. Why shouldn’t a tzaddik enjoy some fruits of his Torah and mitzvos in this world as well? I heard it said that it would not have been wrong for Yaakov to desire peace of mind and serenity, but the problem was that he asked for it. Hashem may give a person serenity and goodness in life, but he should not ask for it and pursue it.

(Harav Alschich)

One Should Be at Peace with How He Is Being Treated from Above

This is difficult to understand. Wasn’t this world created for tzaddikim, and don’t they have a part in it? Isn’t a person obligated to say, ‘The world was created for me’?! (Sanhedrin 37a). Who more than Yaakov Avinu deserved peace in this world?

The way the midrash can be understood is not as a question but as a statement. Indeed, it is not enough for the tzaddikim that their place in the World to Come is prepared for them; this world belongs to them as well. Thus, in truth, Yaakov should have dwelled in peace and serenity in this world as well.

It was only because he asked for peace that the problems with Yosef came upon him. If he had not asked for peace, then he would have received it from Shamayim. The complaint against him was that he asked for it.

(Shemuos Yitzchak)

One Should Not Make Peace with His Tzaros

Tzaddikim ask to dwell in peace in this world – the righteous adapt to the galus and the difficulties, but Hashem tells them: No! It is not enough for the righteous that your place in the World to Come is prepared for you. In truth, this is not enough. You should try to arouse mercy so that Hashem will save you from tzaar now!

(Eish Kodesh; related in the year 1940, in the midst of the Holocaust)

More in this printout

View the whole printout