There is a major debate amongst the Rishonim and Achronim if one should stand for the reading of Aseres Hadibros or not. In fact, the discussion begins even earlier in Shulchan Aruch siman 1:5 regarding the reading of Aseres Hadibros in shul publicly, and even individually. Rav Elyashiv z‑l felt very strongly that standing for Aseres Hadibros reading is wrong, and therefore, even if everyone is standing, one can sit. Rav Shlomo Zalman z‑l felt the opposite, that even the Rambam, who was very against standing, would agree today that it's not a problem, since it’s clear that one is simply reminding himself of the great experience of Matan Torah. It’s clear that contemplating the event of Matan Torah, and specifically focusing on Aseres Hadibros, is very important. This needs explanation.
The Gemara in Maseches Baba Kama 54b has a very interesting discussion about the differences between the Aseres Hadibros (the Ten Commandments or statements) mentioned in Parshas Yisro, which is my bar mitzva parsha, versus the Aseres Hadibros which are repeated again in Parshas Vaeschanan.
The Gemara relates a conversation that took place between Rav Chanina ben Agil and Rav Chiya bar Abba. Rav Chanina asked Rav Chiya why is it that the first set of dibros it doesn’t say tov – good and in the second set it does. Rashi explains that tov is referring here to the words in the pasuk למען ייטב לך – so that it should be good for you. The response of Rav Chiya was “Instead of asking why it doesn’t say it in the first dibros, ask me if it even says it at all.” After Rav Chiya’s quite humble response (many mefarshim – see the Ben Ish Chai – express their shock at the simple reading of the Gemara; how is it possible that a great Amora like Rav Chiya didn’t remember a pasuk in Aseres Hadibros?) he suggests that Rav Chanina go to Rav Tanchum who was by Rav Yehoshua ben Levi, who was an expert on aggadic passages. When Rav Chanina went to Rav Tanchum, Rav Tanchum told him that he did not hear anything on the subject from Rav Yehoshua ben Levi, but he did hear something from Rav Shmuel bar Nachum, who explained that since the first set of tablets was destined to be broken it would chas veshalom imply that “good” will stop from the Jewish people, therefore the word good was omitted in the first dibros.
This passage of Gemara seems to be a peleh – a true wonder. It must be that the word tov is integral to the giving of the Torah and therefore worthy of such in-depth research and discussion.
I humbly want to suggest the following explanation (this thought came to me as I helped our dear bar mitzva boy Shaya Scheiner).
As the early Achronim, such as the Ramchal explain, the purpose of creation was for Hashem to give and do good for mankind – מדרכו של הטוב להטיב. This means that the essence of Hashem is to do good, and this is why He created the world. As the Ramchal explains, the ultimate good is in the next world.
The Ben Ish Chai and other mefarshim assume that both Amoraim knew that the first set of dibros didn’t mentioned the word ייטב and the second did. The question was more philosophical: why was it so important to mention it in the second dibros? Even more difficult is the fact that we are taught, in Maseches Avos, that one should not do things for a reward, so why would this be a goal? In truth, a similar question is asked by the Maharsha in maseches Sota regarding the Gemara 13a that discusses Moshe Rabbeinu’s great desire to enter Eretz Yisrael. The Maharsha there also asks why is Moshe so focused on getting a reward?
The answer is a very fundamental one that is found in Rav Chaim Volozhiner in his peirush on Pirkei Avos. He says that when Chazal say don’t do mitzvos for a reward, that isn’t exact. It means that if the only reason why you’re doing mitzvos is for a reward then it’s indeed not so great, but in truth Hashem wants to give us a reward, so really we’re the mitzva because Hashem wants us to do it, in order than He can reward us. So although we are doing something for a reward, the real reason is that that’s what Hashem wants us to do.
There are a few things that are called tov, and they are in very good company, since Hashem is called Tov. A woman is called tov (see Gemara Brachos 8a) and the Torah is called tov (Pirkei Avos 6:3).
Since tov is the essence of Hashem and his Torah, it now makes sense why this was such an integral point for the Amoraim to discuss in regard to Aseres Hadibros.
As we mentioned, there is an inyan to recite Aseres Hadibros each day, and in truth some siddurim have the Aseres Hadibros hinted at in the verses of Kriaas Shma (this is based on the Yerushalmi in Brachos). It’s equally important to review the concepts and essence of why we received the Aseres Hadibros.
May we be zoche to see and feel the tov in everything we do, and merit the ultimate good with the coming of Mashiach, bimhera bayamineu.