A diligent talmid chacham once brought before my father and teacher, a sefer with chiddushim on Yoreh De’ah. He asked my father to examine the sefer and share his esteemed opinion.
My father leafed through its pages. Suddenly, he noticed that the author concluded a discussion by saying, “And all this is contrary to the opinion of the Shach.” Immediately, he recoiled, closing the sefer with a sense of alarm. He could not bear to look at it further. His heart and spirit were deeply shaken. How could a contemporary talmid chacham dare to dismiss and contradict the words of the Shach, one of the pillars of halachah upon whom the Jewish world has relied for generations? If he could not comprehend the Shach, he should have expressed himself with humility and reverence, admitting that he could not yet grasp their meaning rather than outright rejecting them with such audacity.
When a grandchild later visited my father, he instructed him to remove the sefer from the house immediately, declaring that he could not keep such a sefer under his roof.
Interestingly, the Shach himself exemplifies humility in his writings. In Choshen Mishpat (88:16), he states: “Even though I could not find this statement in the Yerushalmi...”