There’s a well-known song from Rebbe Meir’l of Apta in which he expresses the idea that: Even if I will exert myself with schemes and tactics, and all the inhabitants of the world will stand by to help me and support me, without Your strength and assistance, there is no help or salvation.
The definition of ותחבולות עצות, schemes and tactics, applies to when a person seeks every conceivable way—strategies from “under the earth”—to extricate himself from a situation in which he finds himself. We find this expression in Mishlei (24:6) מלחמה עמו תעשה בתחבולות, with tactics you shall wage war with him. That is, when all else fails in our battle with the yetzer hara, one must innovate and search for more ways to wage the battle—all to win the war.
Then, there is the mehalech of hishtadlus, when a person utilizes the normal mehalech... the usual trodden path to get to his destination.
The Usual Way and the Backroads
When we want to go from one neighborhood to the next, there are generally two ways to accomplish this. There’s the main road; this is called hishtadlus. Then there are the alternative roads, the backroads. Even if the police have sealed them off, this person will find a way through with his tricks. This is called ותחבולות עצות, schemes and tactics.
In the above song by Rebbe Meir’l, a Yid proclaims that no amount of scheming in the world will help him! The only path is to do hishtadlus in accordance with the dictates of the Torah. All ותחבולות עצות will get you nowhere.
Weaseling Your Way in
Imagine that an upscale מלכה מלוה is taking place in a shul, and it was determined that every attendee must pay a twenty-dollar entry fee. But one person refuses to pay. “It’s my shul,” he says. “What right do you have to prevent me from entering? What chutzpah is this!” But the people at the door insist that there’s no way he will be permitted to enter without paying.
But this man is determined. These people will not tell me what to do. “Stay right here and ensure that no one gets in without paying. But I will soon be inside...,” he says. It takes him an hour... but by jumping over a fence, crossing through the mikvah chamber, and from there into the kitchen... and he’s in! Boy, is he happy. It’s not worth twenty dollars to him... he’d pay two hundred dollars for this rush.
This is a classic example of ותחבולות: עצות deriving a rush and pleasure to the nefesh in a crooked and improper manner. This person could have done the normal hishtadlus, entering through the door and paying the requisite fee. But he chose the route of ותחבולות עצות, schemes and tactics. He worked much longer and harder... his clothing is creased and sullied—all because he can do it himself!
The Two Paths Are Not the Same
So, let’s be clear: There’s a concept of hishtadlus. This is the normal path—doing things without worries and heaviness of the heart. In this, there are various levels of how much hishtadlus we must do. Sometimes we must do more hishtadlus, and sometimes we must do less hishtadlus.
People often ask: How much hishtadlus must I do? Maybe I’m not doing enough, or maybe I’m doing too much.... But this is all in the realm of hishtadlus.
Then there’s a concept of ותחבולות עצות, which has nothing to do with hishtadlus! As in the case of the man who weasels his way in through roundabout and crooked ways because he doesn’t want to pay the few dollars: Make no mistake about it: This has no resemblance to hishtadlus. It has a very different name.
Human Nature Tries to Avoid Normal Hishtadlus
It is the nature of humans to seek a way out. This is how it is.... This may be sweet in the beginning, but it usually doesn’t end well. One may seek various ways to avoid paying taxes... he’ll put it in his wife’s name... he’ll do other schemes.... If he finds himself in traffic, he’ll take the shoulder. This is human nature—and there’s a great lack of הכנעה, submissiveness, in this. Because the person isn’t willing to accept the reality that Hashem has ordained for him.
In any case, we must understand the difference well. The usual, normal path is called hishtadlus, while the crooked path that seeks to avoid the normal order is called ותחבולות עצות, schemes and tactics. These bear no resemblance to each other.
For Every Dilemma, There’s a Normal Solution
We have previously learned that the Chovos HaLevavos warns us against traveling to distant places for parnassah. That is because the person in that story engaged in something that was never hishtadlus. It wasn’t excessive hishtadlus—it was something that doesn’t resemble hishtadlus at all.
When a person finds himself in a situation where parnassah is difficult, R”l, there’s a normal and proper path—which is for a person to reflect and seek to ascertain: What am I doing incorrectly in my mission? How can I repair my actions and fulfill my tafkid, so that the shefa does come to me?
Looking for the Easy Path of Escape
But the Chovos HaLevavos tells us that the nature of humans is to seek to escape to other places. He doesn’t want to think that he needs to work on himself—because this would require the soul work of humility. He will need to admit precisely why he doesn’t have parnassah, and it isn’t because eggs became more expensive; it isn’t because his boss doesn’t want to give him a raise; it isn’t because he’s marrying off a child—but because he’s not doing enough in a specific realm.
This requires the great avodah of במעשיו יפשפש עליו באין שיסורין אדם ראה אם, if one sees that suffering comes upon him, he should make a reckoning of his ways. It’s not easy or pleasant to engage in such a reckoning, and it isn’t fun to admit that we don’t have sufficient parnassah due to our deeds.
A person would much rather scheme for ways to find things easier and cheaper. He’ll work out a plan, he’ll travel to a faraway place, he’ll find a way out... He doesn’t give any thought to the mission that the Ribbono shel Olam is trying to give him. He’s preoccupied with עצות ותחבולות—ways to outsmart the normal path. He doesn’t want to pay the twenty-dollar entry fee!
It Never Helps to Escape
And for this reason, the Chovos HaLevavos is displeased with the person who runs far for parnassah. Why are you going there? No amount of ותחבולות עצות will help you attain anything that isn’t bashert for you. You undertook this trip for nothing. You strained your relationship with your family, you exhausted yourself, you claimed you had no choice... and you told yourself that you made a few dollars from it all. You should know that if you had not gone there at all, you would have received the same amount—or even more!
We have seen this often. People ran from their situation to other places for parnassah—and after a few years they returned home and calmed down. They admitted to themselves that they can make the same money—or even more—at home, without using all these tactics.
The real reason they had traveled there in the first place was to escape their situation. It never had any connection to hishtadlus. It was עצות ותחבולות all along, trying to find an easy way out. Eventually, the person will realize that it’s actually harder that way....
The Real Reason We Exchange Normalcy for “Tactics”
Schemes and Tactics Beyond Parnassah
This sugya applies far beyond parnassah. It applies to all the needs that a person has; when he needs success in his learning; when he needs success in enjoying This World; when he needs success in having an organized and serene nefesh, and so forth.
The Chovos HaLevavos teaches us a golden rule for all these things: If you’re escaping your place in order to attain it elsewhere, it is a problem—because you’ve abandoned the Ribbono shel Olam. You felt that: “I can manage on my own...”
The Right Way Takes More Investment at First
We have learned at length in so many sefarim that a person should always feel that he can do nothing alone. Everything is done by the Ribbono shel Olam—as the song of Rebbe Meir’l teaches us: I know that if all the inhabitants of the world help me, I still can do nothing without Hashem.
If so, we must understand: If people know and understand this, why will they so often pursue ותחבולות? עצות After a week when things don’t go as he wished, the person will run to engage in all sorts of schemes and tactics. But yesterday you sang Ribbon Ha’Olamim! “Yes,” he will say. “But I didn’t see that the Ribbono shel Olam helped me! So I went back to my eitzos....”
The reason people keep going back to the ותחבולות עצות is that the other way, the normal way, costs more in the moment. Later, it is so much more pleasant. But in the moment, a person must be willing to work on himself. It’s so much easier to run around and engage in schemes and tactics.
The Easy Way Out
There’s a deeper reason for a person to make one phone call after another, thinking, “If I push just hard enough, I will get what I want.” The reason they do this is not because they think that this is what Hashem wants from them... “In Heaven, They want me to do something, and it’s probably that I should make another phone call...” (Indeed, in some instances, a person is lazy to take the required steps, and min HaShamayim, They want him to overcome his laziness and yes to make that phone call). In most cases, it is because people think the easier route is to do ותחבולות עצות, rather than doing the right thing, which will cost more in the short term.
One should ask himself: have I already fulfilled all of my obligations in my daily life, that I’m engaging in pushing hard with all sorts of schemes and tactics (which may not even be effective, practically speaking)? Why shouldn’t I first try the normal path?
Running After the Shadchan Instead of Reflecting
Let’s take an example. A father awaits a shidduch for his son. He already did everything he could (according to what he considers “doing”). One day, at three o’clock in the afternoon, he sits and meditates on his situation: Last year, I went to Lizensk for the yahrzeit to daven for a yeshuah. I cannot believe that a year has passed since that time, and I have yet to see a yeshuah!
This awakens in him a strong feeling of angst. What does he do now? Instead of fulfilling the dictum of Chazal that if one sees suffering coming upon him, he should take account of his actions, he picks up the phone and calls the shadchan again! I will try again.... Why does he do this? Because the other course of action will cost him more energy and kochos. It’s simply easier for him to pursue the ותחבולות עצות.
Perhaps the Ribbono shel Olam Wants Your Bitachon
Of course, the proper course of hishtadlus may very well be to pick up the phone and call the shadchan, but we must know that it sometimes falls under ותחבולות עצות, because the Ribbono shel Olam wants something else from you in that moment. When a person runs to the phone when he’s feeling tight—simply to make himself feel that he’s doing something...like something is happening... he wants to calm himself through these actions instead of doing what he really needs to be doing: strengthening his emunah and bitachon.
This person would rather pursue all these actions because he doesn’t want to sit down and make the simple reflection that maybe the cause of this problem is because the Ribbono shel Olam wants something from me. And maybe it is this very thing that the Ribbono shel Olam wants from me: not to become nervous or anxious that a whole year has passed and nothing moved. Not to turn leftward—toward ותחבולות עצות and exaggerated hishtadlus—simply because things haven’t happened in my desired timeframe. But to comfort myself with thoughts of emunah and bitachon, not with actions of ותחבולות עצות.
And to the contrary, in most cases, we can see clearly in hindsight how these exaggerated measures and actions had no effect on the outcome—they didn’t bring the yeshuah. Salvation came from a completely different direction and source. The shidduch that was suggested two years ago came to be... because the kappitel Tehillim brought it back!
Why Am I Doing This?
One must reflect strongly upon their motives for taking any given action: Am I doing this in order to carry out the will of my Creator, and thus fulfill my mission on earth? Or am I engaging in ותחבולות עצות—because I feel like I must do something tachlisdig.... Since nothing is moving, I will begin doing things to calm myself down.
[We must make very clear that the mashal of calling the shadchan is just that, a mashal. There are many cases where it is important and warranted. The problem is that sometimes the motive for taking these actions is only because it’s the easier way out. It’s much more difficult to do the right thing: engaging in self-reflection, davening, and strengthening our emunah and bitachon.]
Leaving Our Place Can Often Be the Wrong Move
Leaving a Kehillah
In Klal Yisrael, there are many holy and beautiful kehillos, and it happens that sometimes a person doesn’t find his place in the kehillah into which he was born, and he searches for a new place. He seeks to leave a chassidus or a kehillah in favor of a new location.
Here, our aforementioned rule applies as well. Sometimes, it can be the right move. We know the rule of מזל משנה מקום משנה, one who changes his place may change his fortune. But in most cases, it is rooted in עצות ותחבולות. In most cases, the person is simply looking to escape.... And if we were to follow them, we would see that they didn’t remain in their second choice, but they left to go to a third and fourth place, and so forth.
Be Honest: Why Did You Leave?
Obviously, if a person didn’t find his place at all, and he left in search of a place to grow in his avodas Hashem, then it is laudable and wonderful. He found the derech that speaks to his neshamah.... Wonderful.
But a person who had a place, a derech, a Rebbe, and he left the place he was born into—in many cases, this may be the pitfall that the Chovos HaLevavos alludes to. Look at yourself without biases; why did you go to another place?
This question often can’t be asked in the first six months. But after two years, when a person has calmed down, he should ask himself: Did I leave out of hishtadlus or because of ותחבולות? עצות
Actions That Are the Polar Opposite of Hishtadlus
A person says, “They didn’t accept my child into the yeshivah. You know what? Don’t accept me. I am not about to agree to your requirements. I will figure it out on my own. I don’t need you... I will go elsewhere where it will be cheaper.”
Why did this person leave? Because it was hard to pay the price? This is called ותחבולות עצות, and it’s the direct opposite of hishtadlus. When a person escapes, it’s the opposite of hishtadlus. He says, “I will get what I want in an easier way. I will get it ‘under the table.’ I will manage on my own....”
One of Two Mistakes
Usually, people engage in these tactics and schemes because they make the mistake of thinking that there are two entities here: There is “me” and there is “the situation.” He forgets that there is Someone Else here: The Ribbono shel Olam!
When a person escapes a situation, it means that he forgot one of two things: Either he thinks that there are only humans involved, and for this reason he says to them that they can’t tell him what to do, and so forth. He forgot that they’re not in charge; the Ribbono shel Olam is.
If he does remember that the Ribbono shel Olam is behind it all, then it’s even worse. Although he may not realize it, what he is essentially saying is to the Ribbono shel Olam is, “I can get this in easier ways. You think I need to learn with intensity or daven with a minyan in order to get my parnassah? I’ll show You. I can manage on my own. I know plenty of people who don’t daven with minyan and they do very well.” When this person gets carried away with his ותחבולות עצות he is essentially declaring: I’m not willing to pay the high price in order to attain the shefa.
The Proper Approach to Changing a Yeshivah
The same applies to a bachur considering changing from his yeshivah in favor of a new yeshivah. So often, we see that the reason he didn’t succeed in the first yeshivah was due to a certain problem. Says the Chovos HaLevavos: Why did you switch yeshivos? Because you insist that the problem is in the people around you....
The truth, however, is that this has to do with “you” and the “Ribbono shel Olam.” And if so, what is your message by changing yeshivos? Essentially, that you’re unwilling to go through the process and the toil in order to succeed, and you’re looking for the easy way out by engaging in ותחבולות עצות.
It’s Our Natural Recourse
Of course, people are often pushed from above to change places, and changing yeshivos isn’t necessarily considered “schemes and tactics.” But the Chovos HaLevavos tells us the facts: You should know that the nefesh of the person naturally seeks to turn to ותחבולות עצות. This is his first recourse, because he wants to avoid the normal hishtadlus and to get on board with the plan of the Ribbono shel Olam. It seems to him to be too long and too difficult. Therefore, reflect. Are you’re doing this move because you honestly feel that this is what you’re being pushed to do from Above, or is it because it’s easier to escape rather than to do the difficult work of honest self-reflection.
Leaving When It Is the Ratzon Hashem
We must once again make clear that, of course, there are times when it is good and proper for a person to leave—and this is the ratzon Hashem! And we have seen this in regard to tzaddikim—the Chidushei Harim’s departure from Koznitz to Peshischa is one example.
But the tzaddik didn’t make this change because it was the easy way out. To the contrary, he understood that from Above, They wanted him to do the more difficult work in a new place even though it would have easier for him to remain in place. The tzaddikim accepted the nisayon of לך לך, with all the difficulties that it entailed—they were ready for mesirus nefesh mamash for their mission and calling.
The bottom line is that we must be honest and ensure that we aren’t departing from our original place because we’re seeking to escape. Since this is the natural first recourse, the Chovos HaLevavos asks us to make a reckoning and think about our motives in seeking to leave our place.