Skip to content
Lamplighter

Are We in a Simulation

  • Terumah
  • 5785
  • English
View printout

by Aron Moss

Question: How does Judaism view the theory that we live in a simulation? Some of my school friends believe that we are not real, but just figments of G-d's imagination. How could we know whether we are real?

Response: Great question! I will answer you, assuming that you do really exist.

The great mystics of Judaism grapple with this very question. They were adamant that life is real and we are not simulations. But how can we prove it?

The only way is by looking into the Torah. All other sciences are from within our reality, and if we are an illusion, so are they. But Torah is absolute truth from beyond our reality. If the Torah says we are real, that is G-d saying we are real, and He has the final word.

The Torah provides proof of our existence in its very first verse: "In the beginning, G-d created heaven and earth." It doesn't say He imagined or pretended to create. The word "create" means making something from nothing. So there is a something, an existence, and we are real.

Yet perhaps you could argue that yes, G-d created something, but the something G-d created was an illusion. We need further proof. And we find it in a curious teaching of the Mishna.

There is a Torah prohibition of performing acts of sorcery and black magic. This means using dark spiritual powers to make things happen. These impure powers may work, but they are not to be used.

The Mishna states: "If someone gathers cucumbers using sorcery, it is a punishable offence. But if they make it look like they are gathering cucumbers by merely creating an illusion, they are exempt from punishment."

The Torah prohibits witchcraft, not sleight of hand. You need to magically move the cucumbers to transgress the biblical prohibition. But if you just make it seem like the cucumbers are magically moving when no magic is actually happening, you are exempt. Now, if the whole world is just a simulation, then there is essentially no difference between an illusion and reality. Nothing is real. So how can we differentiate between black magic and sleight of hand? Both are just illusions. By the fact that the Mishna does make this distinction, it must be that real is real, and illusion is illusion.

Bottom line, we are really here and we really do exist. Life is real and what you do with it matters. So start gathering your cucumbers. No hocus pocus!

More in this printout

View the whole printout