Rabbi Shlomo and Rabbi Levi Yitzchak's Silent Meeting
Inspired by a Story | July 10, 2025
Print This Article
View Original PDF

Rabbi Shlomo and Rabbi Levi Yitzchak's Silent Meeting

Inspired by a Story | December 10, 2025

During the period that Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev was Rav of Pinsk and the surrounding regions (before he moved to Berditchev), there lived in the neighboring town Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin.

One day Rabbi Levi Yitzchak sent a messenger to request that Rabbi Shlomo visit him in Pinsk on a certain day at a specified time. Rabbi Shlomo duly arrived, and for a few hours they sat together, their faces ablaze with holy fire. But they did not exchange a single word. After a long time they both broke out in uproarious laughter. Soon thereafter, Rabbi Shlomo returned to his home in Karlin.

This whole strange scene was witnessed by Rabbi Levi Yitzchak's attendant, who was so puzzled by it that he asked the Rebbe to explain.

"All the Jews of our entire region," said the Tzaddik, "were under the threat of a fearful verdict that was being considered in the Heavenly Court. The local gentile governor had been consulting on the imminent expulsion of the Jews. They had therefore decided to call a meeting at which they would all sign a proclamation which would bring this into effect. I prayed with all my might that the evil decree be rescinded. But I received no answer.

"One day I implored with all my heart and soul and might, and I was told from Above that 'Shlomo the son of Yuta' would be able to help out in this case, because Eliyahu Hanavi visits him frequently. I therefore asked to have him come here at the exact hour for which that fateful meeting had been called.

"Rabbi Shlomo arrived, and it was then that we saw that every single nobleman there was giving his assent to the proposed decree! We were so seized by terror that we could not utter a word. At that moment, we saw Eliyahu Hanavi walk in and join their meeting in the guise of an elderly squire.

"It turns out that according to their procedures, any single one of them can veto a proposal. Eliyahu took his seat among them, and when the document reached him for his signature, he insisted loudly that he would never agree to such an edict. In fact, he would withhold his signature.

"This shattered their plans, and in the arguments that followed between them the document itself was torn to shreds.

"This was such a hilarious sight that we broke out in laughter. Imagine: a whole assemblage of fools allowing an utter stranger to upset their plans!"

During the period that Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev was Rav of Pinsk and the surrounding regions (before he moved to Berditchev), there lived in the neighboring town Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin.

One day Rabbi Levi Yitzchak sent a messenger to request that Rabbi Shlomo visit him in Pinsk on a certain day at a specified time. Rabbi Shlomo duly arrived, and for a few hours they sat together, their faces ablaze with holy fire. But they did not exchange a single word. After a long time they both broke out in uproarious laughter. Soon thereafter, Rabbi Shlomo returned to his home in Karlin.

This whole strange scene was witnessed by Rabbi Levi Yitzchak's attendant, who was so puzzled by it that he asked the Rebbe to explain.

"All the Jews of our entire region," said the Tzaddik, "were under the threat of a fearful verdict that was being considered in the Heavenly Court. The local gentile governor had been consulting on the imminent expulsion of the Jews. They had therefore decided to call a meeting at which they would all sign a proclamation which would bring this into effect. I prayed with all my might that the evil decree be rescinded. But I received no answer.

"One day I implored with all my heart and soul and might, and I was told from Above that 'Shlomo the son of Yuta' would be able to help out in this case, because Eliyahu Hanavi visits him frequently. I therefore asked to have him come here at the exact hour for which that fateful meeting had been called.

"Rabbi Shlomo arrived, and it was then that we saw that every single nobleman there was giving his assent to the proposed decree! We were so seized by terror that we could not utter a word. At that moment, we saw Eliyahu Hanavi walk in and join their meeting in the guise of an elderly squire.

"It turns out that according to their procedures, any single one of them can veto a proposal. Eliyahu took his seat among them, and when the document reached him for his signature, he insisted loudly that he would never agree to such an edict. In fact, he would withhold his signature.

"This shattered their plans, and in the arguments that followed between them the document itself was torn to shreds.

"This was such a hilarious sight that we broke out in laughter. Imagine: a whole assemblage of fools allowing an utter stranger to upset their plans!"

PDF Preview