Question 1
How do we know if someone is a Gadol or a tzaddik? Is it only if other Gedolim or tzaddikim recognize this person’s greatness and they testify that he is a Gadol?
Answer
Usually we cannot know for sure, because a person only sees another with his eyes, but Hashem sees into the heart of another. There are certain external credentials that we first need to research in order to know if someone is a Gadol/tzaddik: How great he is in Torah, in his deeds, in his middos, in his devotion to Hashem, and other areas. One needs an inner sense in the heart, as well as davening to Hashem, to merit understanding the truth [in order to know if the other is a gadol/tzaddik].
Question 2
What about if a person feels strongly in his heart that a certain person is a Gadol/tzaddik? Can a person rely on what he’s feeling? We know that Reb Yisrael Salanter figured out that Rav Zundel of Salant was a Gadol even though he never heard from anyone about Rav Zundel being a Gadol, because he trusted his feeling about him. But maybe only Reb Yisrael Salanter was able to figure out who was a Gadol because he had a very pure heart? Are there any signs by which we can recognize that a certain person is a gadol/tzaddik or someone we may follow and trust?
Answer
Same answer as above.
Question 3
There are two kinds of Gedolim: Those who are great in nigleh (the revealed dimension of Torah) and those who are great in nistar (the hidden dimension of Torah). Do the Gedolim in nigleh come from the souls of the revealed dimension (alma d’isgalya) and do the Gedolim in nistar come from the souls of the hidden dimension (alma d’iskasya)?
Answer
Usually, yes.
Question 4
Today we act according to the Gedolim in nigleh, and only in the future after Mashiach will we act according to the Gedolim in nistar. Is this connected with Yeravam ben Nevat’s refusal to acknowledge Dovid as walking in front of him with Hashem in Gan Eden?
Answer
Yes.
Question 5
Are there Gedolim today in nistar who are able to argue on Gedolim in nigleh?
Answer
Certainly.
Question 6
With regards to the revealed and concealed dimensions, where do the Leah-souls come from and where do the Rachel-souls come from?
Answer
Leah-souls are from the hidden dimension, and Rachel-souls are from the revealed dimension.
Question 7
There are some tzaddikim who are radiant, whose faces shine, they have a becoming appearance, they are always smiling at others, in a manner that goes beyond human nature. Other tzaddikim barely smile, or their faces don’t shine, and they are not becoming in their appearance. Is this related to the two different soul-roots, the hidden dimension and the revealed dimension?
Answer
That is a factor here, but it also depends on the tzaddik’s personal soul root, as well as the state of the generation [and what the generation needs].
Question 8
There is a statement from Rav Shach that there is no such thing as a hidden tzaddik, because if a person just learns Torah in his own little space and he doesn’t deal with other people and he isn’t sharing in others’ pain, he can’t be a real tzaddik. But how can this be true, if there are 36 hidden tzaddikim who greet the Shechinah each day?
Answer
He [Rav Shach] was a revealed tzaddik, and that is why he said that there can’t be such a thing as a hidden tzaddik. There is a different response I gave on this topic which elaborates more on this.
Question 9
How can it be that certain tzaddikim taught a certain way of serving Hashem and led and established communities based on their approach, and later when these tzaddikim were niftar, there was no one to replace them and the communities got very messed up with no one to guide them? For example, Chabad was being led by the Lubavitcher Rebbe, and Rav Kook was leading his students, and when they were niftar, the communities they established were devastated and left in the dark, with no one to guide them, and the results for them were disastrous, leading to so many problems for them. How could these great “lights” become broken? And how are we to understand the great embarrassment to these tzaddikim after they were niftar, since their communities couldn’t go on properly without them, and it seems as if all of their hard efforts went lost?
Answer
There are great spiritual lights that can come for a temporary amount of time, whereas other great spiritual lights disappear and then return at a later time. This is a very long discussion.
Question 10
Lakewood today isn’t what it used to be. It was established by HaGaon R’ Aharon Kotler who made a community of bnei Torah who would be moser nefesh for Torah, living a life of Torah and living simply with no pursuit of materialism. But today Lakewood isn’t like that anymore, and in fact many people make fun of Lakewood in a cynical way that it is no longer the “town of Torah” that it is so called. And quite frankly, many families in Lakewood today are simply not interested in continuing the way that Rav Aharon envisioned. They want to live very comfortably and have very high materialistic standards. And because there are so many problems in families trying to raise their children according to Rav Aharon’s vision of bnei Torah, there are actually many kids in Lakewood who went off the derech because they can’t live such a life of mesirus nefesh for Torah and avoiding materialism. It seems as if the high standards in Torah of the community have led to so many problems in many families, who can’t handle the way of living of mesirus nefesh for Torah that Rav Aharon wanted Lakewood to be, and all of this seems to be an embarrassment to Rav Aharon, as if he was wrong in establishing such high standards of Torah living. What is the proper attitude to have about this?
Answer
There is never a path of serving Hashem that will work for everyone. Every path will always help some people and harm others at the same time. This is all the mysterious ways of Hashem, Who created the world and runs it.