Skip to content
Bilvavi

Pirkei Avos - 081 Make a “Rav” For Yourself

  • Korach
  • 5783
  • English
View printout

The word rav is related to the word ribuy, “many”, and it is also related to the word riv, argument. This hints to us that every rav is potentially a controversial rav, because a person has to go through much internal questioning about who his rav is.

Korach was only able to argue on Moshe Rabbeinu because he couldn’t come to terms with the concept of having a rav. He fought and argued with Moshe, because since Moshe was the rav, it was inevitable that there would be some riv (argument) about this.

The very concept of a rav is that he is someone who, as prominent as he is, invites riv\arguments from others. When people try to make for themselves a Rav, they go through a riv in their soul – they feel a battle going on inside. People aren’t able to clarify if a certain Rav is supposed to be their rav, and they feel a great argument going on inside their own soul as they try to clarify: “Is this person my rav…?”

The truth is that this power of the soul, riv, is rooted in the soul’s power of safek, doubt. People have the tendency to doubt things, to be skeptical about things. For example, a person might even be learning Torah a whole day, and after some time, he begins to doubt if he’s doing the right thing or not. From where does this come from? Why do people doubt themselves even when they are doing the right thing? It is because there is a nature in the soul to doubt things. It is the power of riv\safek in the soul – the tendency in people to have an inner struggle with things and be skeptical about things, unable to decide if they are doing the right thing or not.

The very concept of a Rav is that he is someone who is above the student’s level. Therefore, it is very hard to be able to choose a Rav for yourself, because if he’s beyond your understanding, how do you decide that he’s meant to be your Rav? It’s not possible for us to determine who can become our Rav. Who are we to decide this?

The Mishnah elsewhere says “Make for yourself a teacher, and remove yourself from doubt.” Once we have for ourselves a Rav, we will no longer have doubts; but how do we get to that point in the first place? What are we to if we are having trouble choosing who our Rav is – who helps us decide this? Trying to choose a Rav creates an inner turmoil in our soul, a “riv”.

Even if a person has a Rav, it’s not always because he chose the Rav; he might be simply acting in a habitual manner (melumadah). Indeed, we cannot choose our Rav.

More in this printout

View the whole printout