Skip to content
Me'oros Hatzaddikim

THE MACHLOKES BETWEEN THE ARIZAL AND THE BAAL SHEM TOV

  • Korach
  • 5782
  • English
View printout

The Ba’al Shem Tov was once sitting together with his chevraya kaddisha, studying the mystical kavonos of the mikve. When the Ba’al Shem taught certain kavonos some of the talmidim present were surprised and they pointed out an apparent issue with the Ba’al Shem’s teaching: “Rebbe, how can this be? Doesn’t the holy Arizal explain and teach these kavonos differently?”

When the Ba’al Shem heard their question, he leaned his head back and sank into a deep state of rapture and dveikus; his face blazed like a torch, his eyes bulged and his soul soared heavenward to the higher lofty realms. The chevraya were all seized with trembling and awe, all of them except Rav Nachman Horodenka who was greatly annoyed with himself; he felt more and more drowsy. “How can this be? The Ba’al Shem’s neshoma rises to spiritual heights and all the talmidim sit here in awe and fear, and I am tired and sleepy?!” He fought to remain awake, he tried to pry his eyes open – but to no avail, and as he battled the sleep and fatigue that overtook him he simply lost consciousness and drifted off into a doze. He slept, and he dreamed, and he saw a vision:

A great commotion was going on and a large mass of people were running and making their way somewhere and he ran after them. “Where are you all running to?” he asked, out of breath. “Our holy Rav is about to speak and teach us,” they replied as they ran. “Who is your Rav?” he asked, but they were all in such a rush that no one answered Rav Nachman.

Rav Nachman followed them and they reached a large building that was very handsome, beautiful and stately, filled with people from one end to the other. They all appeared important and sagely and among them suddenly was none other than the holy Ba’al Shem Tov, who made his way to the front and began to teach, the same derosha on kavonos hamikve that Rav Nachman had just heard. Just then a young Tzaddik stood by the Ba’al Shem and began to counter and contradict the Ba’al Shem Tov’s teachings. “Who is this Rav?” asked Rav Nachman and he was told that he was the Arizal. The argument between the holy Arizal and the holy Ba’al Shem Tov continued and they debated back and forth until finally at the conclusion the Arizal agreed to the interpretation and explanation of the Ba’al Shem Tov.

Suddenly, Rav Nachman awoke; he was back among the talmidim, sitting among them as they discussed the Ba’al Shem’s apparent contradiction to the Arizal’s kavonos hamikve. As Rav Nachman awoke, the Ba’al Shem turned to him and said, “Nu, I took you along so you could testify as to who is right. Now tell them all whose kavonos are correct and testify before them what you saw and who won the argument.” Needless to say on whose behalf Rav Nachman testified, and the Ba’al Shem concluded his derosha and left. (Shivchei HaBa’al Shem)

More in this printout

View the whole printout