Skip to content
Parsha Pages Youth

Damaging Animals

  • Mishpatim
  • 5784
  • English
View printout

DAMAGING ANIMALS

שמות כא, לה: כִּי-יִגֹּף שׁוֹר-אִישׁ אֶת-שׁוֹר רֵעֵהוּ וָמֵת וּמָכְרוּ אֶת-הַשּׁוֹר הַחַי וְחָצוּ אֶת-כַּסְפּוֹ וְגַם אֶת-הַמֵּת יֶחֱצוּן:

(Rashi based on Bama Kama 34a) When one’s owned animal strikes and causes death to an animal owned by another (for example, kicking, goring with its horns, pushing with its body, or biting with its teeth), then the owner of the attacking “live” (the damager) animal must be half the damages (since the damager animal is still considered a “Tam”) to the owner of the second “dead” (the damaged) animal, up to the value of the damaged animal.

The verse directs that the “live” animal and the “dead” animal are sold for their current value and the two parties share in the value.

The verse says the two parties each lose half the value of their investment.

Example 1

Both animals were worth the same prior to the damage. The value of the carcass, whether a little or a lot, would not matter. Each party would share equally in the sold, current value of the animals. The Gemara says this is the case of this verse.

QUESTION #1: An Ox worth $200 gores for the first time an Ox worth $200, and the carcass is now worth $50. Each party would end up with $125. Please explain how each party ended up with $125.

However, this cannot be the proper law if both animals were not of the same value at the time of the damage. If the law of splitting the values were applied, then sometimes the owner of the “damager” could actually be making a profit.

Example 2

The carcass of the “dead” animal is worth more than the value of the “live” animal. In this example the owner of the “damager” animal, would make a profit.

QUESTION #2: An Ox, worth $40, gores for the first time an ox whose carcass is worth $120. Please explain the amount of “profit” the owner of the “damager” would make.

Similarly, the owner of the “dead” animal could make an unjustified profit.

Example 3

In this example the first “live” animal is worth more than twice the value of the second. Thus, half the value of the “live” animal is worth more than the original value of the “dead” animal. The owner of the “damager” animal is guilty of no more than negligence (since no idea his animal was a killer) and thus, should not be made to pay more than the original value of the “dead” animal.

QUESTION #3: An Ox worth $100 gores for the first time an Ox worth $20, and the carcass is now worth $4. Please explain the amount of “profit” the owner of the “damaged” could make.

Therefore, the final law places maximums on both parties:

  • The owner of the “damaged” animal cannot collect more than the value of half of his loss.
  • The owner of the “damager” animal cannot receive more than the value of his “live” animal.

What would be the payment received by the owner of the “damaged” animal in the following cases:

QUESTION #4: An Ox worth $150 gores for the first item an Ox worth $100, and the carcass is worth $20.

QUESTION #5: An Ox worth $100 gores for the first time an Ox worth $250, and the carcass is worth $125.

QUESTION #6: An Ox worth $200 gores for the first time an Ox worth $100, and the carcass is worth $50.

More in this printout

View the whole printout