Asking a Gorilla to do a Melacha for you on Shabbos
"Why don't you come visit us down here? The weather is lovely this time of year and I can't wait to show off these accommodations we've moved into," requested Mrs. Berger's parents, Mr. and Mrs. Frank. They had recently retired to a villa in Florida but, apparently, they were just a bit lonely.
"Sure, we'd love to come. By the way, let me warn you that we'll be bringing along a surprise for you," said Mrs. (Frank) Berger cryptically.
"Why are you warning us about a surprise?" questioned Mrs. Frank.
The Berger family drove up the long driveway toward the luxurious villa. It was set on a sprawling estate filled with coconut palms, orange trees and other native varieties of fruit. Everyone packed out of the cab and Zeidy and Bubby Frank gave them all a hug and kiss as they exited. The last one out was a bit on the hairy side.
"Hi, Mom! This is the surprise I was telling you about. His name is Gedalia Gorilla," exclaimed Mrs. Berger. Mrs. Frank had come to expect some shockers over the years that her daughter had been married to Rabbi Berger, but she was still not quite sure what to make of this new addition to the family. For his part, Gedalia felt right at home and started picking oranges from the orchard.
On Thursday night the Franks and Bergers celebrated their family reunion with a delicious barbeque of hot dogs and meat patties – a.k.a. Franks and Bergers.
The family settled in for Shabbos on the second floor of the Frank manor with a beautiful view of swaying palm trees. The coconuts were within hands reach.
On Shabbos morning, after the men and older boys had set off for shul, the little children awoke. Still in their pajamas, they ran to their mother.
"Mommy, can we please have Shabbos cereal?"
"Of course! Shmuli, get the milk from the fridge, please."
"Oof! Mommy, I think the milk is spoiled."
"I have a terrific idea," suggested Shmuli. "We can point out the palm tree outside the window to Gedalia and he'll pick a coconut for himself. Once it's off the tree, we can collect the coconut milk."
On Shabbos, is it permissible to coax Gedalia to pull a coconut for himself when the intention is to use the milk for the cereal?
Points to Ponder: If an animal belongs to you, there is an issur d'orayso of shvisas b'hemto. An animal may not do a melacha for its owner. However, if the owner is mafkir (makes ownerless) his animal, he will be saved from this issur (Shulchon Aruch 246:3).
Even if an animal does not belong to you, there is an issur of mechamer. A human may not partner with an animal to do a melacha by leading with a rope or even with a loud voice command – i.e. "giddy up!" (Mishnah Berurah 266:7-8). Therefore, yelling or frightening Gedalia into picking the coconut is forbidden due to mechamer.
If you coax an animal it to do a melachah with a soft voice, it would no longer be an issur d'orayso of mechamer. However, it would still be assur m'drabbonon because of amirah l'akum (Ohr L'tziyon Tshuvah 23; Melachim Omnayich 1:11).
If the animal did the melacha on its own volition for its own pleasure, there is no issur of shvisas b'hemto, mechamer or amira l'akum (Melachim Omnayich 1:11).
Conclusion: It seems that it would be permitted to point out the palm tree to Gedalia, even though we know that he will obviously be curious and pick a coconut for himself. This can be compared to when a Jew invites a goy into his house to eat something, knowing that the goy will turn on a light. Since he is turning on the light for himself, there is no issue of amira l'akum (Melachim Omnayich end of 9:1).
Gedalia reached his long arms out the second floor window and picked a coconut for himself.
Is the coconut milk permitted for human consumption on Shabbos or is it muktzah?
Points to Ponder: Since Gedalia had been seen picking fruits off the trees immediately upon their arrival, the possibility existed that he would pick fruit on Shabbos, too. Regarding muktzah the rule is that that which is attainable for an animal to eat is not considered muktzah for a human, either (Beitza 6b). Therefore, the coconut and its milk are not muktzah.
Conclusion: Nevertheless, we are not out of the orchard yet. The coconut is still prohibited because Chazal made a decree that any fruit or vegetable that was attached before the onset of Shabbos may not be eaten on Shabbos. They were afraid that a person may come to pick another one on Shabbos. This is so even if the fruit fell off by itself, certainly if Gedalia picks it off the tree (Tosfos Beitza 3a s.v. gezairah shema yaaleh v'yitloh; Shaar Hatziyun 325:26).
Just then Mrs. Frank came into the kitchen holding a cardboard carton.
"Would anyone prefer some rice milk? I bought a container just in case any of the kids have a hard time digesting regular milk," she said, ever so frankly.
"Thank you, Bubby," responded the young children.
Shmos 23:12 is the source of Shevitas Behemto (letting one’s animal “rest” on Shabbos). Rambam (Shabbos 20:1) brings it as halacha as does Yalkut Yosef Shabbat (vol 1: pg. 33)