Skip to content
Parsha Pages Youth

Excitement in Halacha: Snaking the Problem

  • Mishpatim
  • 5784
  • English
View printout

Snaking the Problem

Damage of One's Snake in a Public Area

Ding dong...

"Velvel the vet," received Rabbi Berger. "Why are you panting, what is the matter?"

"Refoel, I have a big problem right now please help me!" explained Velvel. "I was transferring my 35-foot constricting anaconda snake in an aquarium to bring it to a zoo. I was bringing it with my hand truck across the street, and a car jumped the red light, crashed into my aquarium and drove away. I immediately contacted my men for help with the snake. In meanwhile, the snake encircled a car waiting at the red light several times and started constricting. The man jumped out of his car from the other door before the snake broke through the window. My men came, wrestled the snake and secured the creature in a proper cage. By then, the snake had constricted and crushed the car. Do I have to pay for the car?"

"Maybe Velvel is only responsible if a snake bites, and not responsible for what happened to the car, since it is unusual for a snake to do," suggested Yossi.

"But I learned that an owner is responsible for all the damage that a snake does," argued Yehoshua. "The snake is unique that it normally damages purposely."

"Are you always responsible for a snake wherever it damages?" asked Shmuli.

"The gemara says that the wild animals asked the snake why you bite and kill people without benefit," answered Baruch. "We see the snake doesn't have pleasure from killing. Maybe, it is still considered pleasure for the animal, because it enjoys biting, and is the toldah of shein — eating, which is patur in a public area."

"Perhaps, since a snake normally damages purposely, it is a toldah of keren, and is considered a muad right away," disputed Binyamin. "And Velvel has to pay full even in the public area."

"It seems that when a snake damages it is considered a toldah of regel, since it is grouped with other animals that damage that are considered regel," concluded Rabbi Berger. "An ox needs to be worked up to pull it out of its normal docile nature to get it angry enough to gore. Therefore, it is considered keren, since it is abnormal. This is in contrast with a snake, which bites even when it is calm and is considered its normal nature. It is therefore considered regel, which is patur in rishus harabim. Reshus harabim means any public area that all have permission to go. Since the snake damaged in the street which is the public area, therefore, it seems that Velvel would not have to pay according Torah law."

"The reason by other animals it is patur in reshus harbim is because you have permission to bring your animals there and people shouldn't leave food or things that would get trampled by animals walking there," probed Yehoshua. "Why should it be allowed to bring a snake in the public area? Does somebody have to worry that he can't bring his animal to reshus harabim because it may be killed by your snake?"

"It is rare that wild animals are owned privately, therefore chazal did not differentiate in their laws and still considered it patur in rishus harabim." Alternatively, people steer clear of wild animals to avoid getting hurt; therefore it is permitted to have them in public.

"There is probably a legal requirement to pay, but the car insurance covers it," commented Binyamin.

More in this printout

View the whole printout