Wild Side
Your Domesticated Wild Animal Damaging
“Shmuli, can I show you my new remote control car in your house?” asked Yosef Grockner to his friend.
“Sure!” exclaimed Shmuli. “I am so excited.”
Yosef came, and he and Shmuli had fun playing with his new toy.
“Can I have a turn too?” asked Goldy.
“Sure,” replied Yosef.
“Grunt oomph,” said Gedalya.
“I think Gedalya also wants a turn to play with your new toy,” noted Goldy.
“He might break it,” responded Yosef. “I don't want him to play with my toy.”
Shmuli motioned to Gedalya that he can't play with Shmuli's toy.
Suddenly, Gedalya got angry and bashed his toy.
“Gedalya is being destructive!” said Shmuli.
“Can we own such a wild animal?”
“Any kind of animal must be chained if it is a danger for society,” explained Yehoshua. “It seems to be permitted to own even the wildest animals if they are caged. However, Velvel the Vet got Gedalya as a baby and trained the gorilla to live amongst people. Since it domesticated we can have it out even if it is unchained.”
“Would it be considered a tame animal and we would be charged for half the damage, or is a gorilla considered prone to damaging and we would be charged fully for it?” asked Yossi.
“It seems that a gorilla can be tamed in such a way that the owner can control it,” replied Rabbi Berger. “It is not listed among the animals that instinctively damage; therefore, it seems that when trained, it would be considered a tame animal. Since it is not normal for a tame animal to damage, we would be responsible only for half the cost. However, paying half is considered a fine, and we don't have a beis din that can charge fines nowadays, so we would be completely patur. However, some say that there is still a Heavenly responsibility to pay half.”
“Here give this money to Yosef towards buying a new toy,” Rabbi Berger said as he handed Shmuli the money.
“How do get Gedalya to stop acting like an animal?” asked Goldy.