The Calabria Esrogim originate from the homonymous region located in the southern part of Italy. These Esrogim grow on a strip of land on the coast also called "Riviera dei Cedri". They are also called Yanover Esrogim for the city of Genova, in the north, from where they were shipped in the past.
The Tradition of the Calabria Esrogim
The Alter Rebbe transmitted a tradition: When HaShem commanded the Jews in the desert to take an Esrog, he sent messengers on a cloud and they brought him the Esrogim from Calabria. Since then the Minhag of the Rabbeim, and therefore of the Chabad Chassidim, is to make a Brocha on an Esrog from Calabria.
The History of the Calabria Esrogim
Calabria is the name of the region that forms the long and narrow “toe” at the south-western end of Italy's boot-shaped peninsula. This relatively small area is comprised of mountain ranges, hilly areas, and coastal plains. The lower terrain of Calabria is extremely fertile and rich with vineyards and citrus groves.
It is the home of the variety of Esrog locally known as the Diamante citron, named for the Calabrian town of Diamante, where the mostly Mediterranean climate is best suited for its growth. It is also often called the Calabrian Esrog, but it is even more widely referred to as the Yanova Esrog, which is the Yiddish pronunciation of the trading port of Genoa in northern Italy from where the merchants exported the Esrogim northwards to Europe.
The Yanova Esrog was used since the times of the earliest Tosafists and is widely regarded as the earliest known variety of Esrogim used by Ashkenazim. In fact, until approximately the year 5545 (1785), the Yanova Esrog was the only variety known to most of Ashkenazi Jewry. They were not familiar with any other type of Esrog, including the Israeli variety.
As other Esrogim began infiltrating the European market at the turn of the eighteenth century, the Greek Corfu Esrog in particular stood out. It was symmetrical and splendid, coloured a beautiful yellow-green, free of spots and leaf-marks, and always crowned with a beautiful and sturdy Pittam. Moreover, it was available in abundance and at a much cheaper price.
The Calabria Esrogim were Considered Optimal
The Yanova Esrog remained the frontrunner in many communities for a number of reasons. For one, it was becoming increasingly common for farmers to graft the frail Esrog tree on the rootstock of other hardier and more resilient citrus trees, most often the lemon or orange tree. An overwhelming majority of Halachic decisors ruled that the fruits of such trees were completely disqualified for the Mitzvah of Lulav. Esrogim grown in all other locales were suspected of having been grafted, but the Calabrian variety was known to be pure. (For this reason, although the Diamante Esrog now grows in Puerto Rico, Sicily and Sardinia, their fruit is not used on Sukkos, since no reliable kashrus supervision was present at the time of their transplantation.)
Furthermore, the Chasam Sofer and other great Achronim ruled that an Esrog variety may only be used when there is a mesorah – a tradition – attesting to its perennial use. In fact, the Chasam Sofer asserted that the Yanova Esrog is the only kind known to be pure, on account of the long-standing Ashkenazi tradition tracing back to the times of the Tosafists, and the uninterrupted Jewish presence in Calabria since the times of the second Beis Hamikdash.
In summation, the Yanova Esrog is the only strain whose Kashrus is accepted across the entire spectrum of Ashkenazi Jewry. The same cannot be said of any other Esrog variety.
The Tradition of Chabad
The Alter Rebbe treasured the Land of Israel very much, and he maintained that an Israeli grown Esrog greatly enhanced the fulfilment of this special Mitzvah. Yet, he insisted on using the Calabrian variety even over the Israeli ones. The Alter Rebbe explained that since Esrogim were not readily available to the Jews when they travelled through the desert for forty years, Moshe Rabbenu sent messengers on a cloud to bring Esrogim from the province of Calabria. Obviously, what could be better than to make a Brocho on the very same variety that Moshe and the Jews used in the desert?
This tradition of the Alter Rebbe was repeated often by the Rebbe Rashab and the Frierdiker Rebbe. Rabbi Boruch Shneur Schneersohn, a grandson of the Tzemach Tzeddek, attributed this tradition to the Baal Shem Tov, and added in the name of the Rebbe Rashab that Calabrian Esrogim were used in the Beis Hamikdash.
All Chabad Rebbeim were steadfast in using Yanova Esrogim, even though they usually arrived from the long transcontinental journey to White Russia in very poor condition. Thus, it is related that one year the Tzemach Tzeddek made the Brocho on a basic Yanova Esrog, even though he had been sent a much nicer and larger Esrog from Israel, which he used only for Hallel. Another year, there was only one Yanova Esrog to be had in the entire city of Lubavitch, and the Tzemach Tzeddek had no choice but to buy an Israeli Esrog. Still, he sought the owner's permission and made the Brocho over the solitary Yanova Esrog instead of on his own Israeli Esrog.
For some time, the Tzemach Tzeddek himself sold Esrogim. When his customers would behold the scrawny Calabrian Esrogim speckled with so many black and dark green spots, they would ask to see the other more beautiful kinds of Esrogim. The Tzemach Tzeddek always responded that there was Halachic basis to disregard the specks and spots on the gaunt Calabrian Esrogim, and that they were ultimately superior to the other superficially beautiful varieties. In fact, one year the Tzemach Tzeddek was seen making a Brocho on a Yanova Esrog covered with cobweb-like marks, even though he had in his possession beautiful Esrogim of other varieties.
The Rebbe Rashab would usually use two Esrogim, one from Calabria upon which he would make the Brocho, and another from Israel which he would shake afterwards, out of his affection for the Land. Similarly, in his notes, the Rebbe relates that in the year 5692 (1932), the Frierdiker Rebbe gave him two Esrogim for Sukkos, one from Calabria and the other from Israel. The Frierdiker Rebbe instructed him, “This is what my father would give me. The Brocho should be made over the Yanova Esrog, and afterwards, the Israeli Esrog should be held.”
The Rebbe Rashab could not bear the thought of using any other type of Esrog. In 5662 (1902), the Rebbe Rashab wrote: “One should choose specifically those Esrogim for which we have a tradition from our forefathers, and not be misled by the superficial beauty and imagined splendour of other Esrogim.” One year, when a Yanova Esrog could not be procured, the Rebbe Rashab made a Brocho over an Israeli Esrog and cried.
The Rebbeim stood firm even as a succession of European wars interrupted the supply of Yanova Esrogim. On the tenth of Teves in 5649 (1888), the Rebbe Rashab wrote in a letter: “The Alter Rebbe was meticulous about making a Brocho on a Yanova Esrog. Once, during wartime, when the transportation of merchandise between Italy and Russia was interrupted, he was prepared to send a special messenger to Italy in order to obtain a Yanova Esrog. Similarly, the Rebbeim after him were very strict about this.”
Many years later, during the First World War, when all direct passage between Italy and Russia was blockaded, the Rebbe Rashab arranged for a Yanova Esrog to be delivered to Stockholm, where another courier waited to pick it up and convey it to the Rebbe Rashab in Russia. During the Second World War, the Rebbe risked his own life to smuggle a Yanova Esrog from Italy into France.
Between 1943-1945, Yanova Esrogim were unobtainable in the United States, and the Frierdiker Rebbe had no choice but to use Israeli Esrogim. In 1944, the Frierdiker Rebbe sought to enlist the Unites States War Department in obtaining Yanova Esrogim from Calabria, which was already in Allied hands. However, the State Department denied the request on the basis that all transports were limited to essential war supplies.
On the basis of the above-mentioned teaching of the Alter Rebbe as well as out of the dual concern that other varieties may have been grafted or lack a mesorah, Chabad Chassidim are scrupulous about using a Yanova Esrog.
The Rebbe Explains the Reasoning for Esrogim from Calabria
Italia Shel Yavan does not refer to the entire Italian peninsula. It only refers to half of the region of Calabria. Although the Rebbe does not prove this fact, it is worthwhile noting that according to contemporaneous records, the name Italia originally emerged as the Greek name for southern Calabria. Greeks settled heavily along the coast of Calabria during the 8th and 7th centuries BCE, dominating it until they were conquered and displaced in the 3rd century BCE. Only during the reign of Emperor Augustus of Rome (at the end of the 1st century BCE) did the term Italia come to mean the entire Italian peninsula. This historical tidbit sheds light on the curious name that Chazal frequently used – Italia Shel Yavan, which literally means “Italy of Greece”. This name seems puzzling at first, because Italy and Greece are two distinct areas of the European continent. However, when aware of the history, it becomes clear that the name Italia Shel Yavan refers to the part of Italy that the early Greeks called Italia, as contrasted with the expanded area that the Romans called Italia.
The Rebbe goes on to explain that the entire Calabrian landmass certainly existed since creation. When the oceans rose and flooded much of the world in the third generation of mankind, parts of Calabria submerged just beneath the ocean surface, and it remained that way for centuries to come. Only the higher terrain of Calabria remained above water, and this was the area first settled and developed by the earlier inhabitants of Calabria. It was from there that Moshe Rabbenu obtained Esrogim.
When King Shlomo sinned with the daughter of Pharaoh, Hashem's archangel implanted a reed into the submerged part of the Calabrian landmass, triggering a gradual build up and reclaiming of the land. The process was slow and not necessarily that noticeable. The re-emerging parts of Calabria were extremely fertile and became a center of high-quality cultivation.
According to the Rebbe, this explains why Yitzchok blessed Esav with the region of Italia Shel Yavan, i.e. the submerged parts of Calabria. Yitzchok had already given all the lands to Yaakov and there was nothing left for Esav. But when he saw how vexed Esav was, Yitzchok hit upon a solution. Since Calabria was, for all intents and purposes, not in existence in his time, it hadn't been included in his blessing to Yaakov, so he gave it to Esav instead.
When Yitzchak gave Calabria to Esav, he described it with the words Mishmanei Haʼaretz Yihye Moshovecha; your dwelling place shall be at the fat places of the earth. The Maharal explains that when it came to Yaakov, Yitzchok did not designate a specific land, because Yaakov would be deserving of supernatural blessings regardless of whether the land was naturally fertile or not. However, when it came to Esav, Yitzchok gave him the naturally fertile and beautiful Italia Shel Yavan, because Esav would not merit any supernatural blessings from Hashem.
Indeed, to this very day, Calabria is agriculturally-rich. It boasts the second highest number of organic farmers in the world. It is the second-highest producer of olive oil in the world. Essence-oil produced from the Calabrian Bergamot orange reaches the best quality in the world.
The Rebbe explains that this this is why Moshe sought Esrogim specifically from Calabria, and not from Israel. For, when performing a Mitzvah with a physical object, we always use the best and choicest. As the Possuk says, “Kol Chelev la’Hashem” – the fattest is for Hashem. What could be better than making a Brocho over a Calabrian Esrog, a place so fertile that the Torah refers to it as the fat places of the earth? This is why Chabad Chassidim are so particular about using only Yanova Esrogim.
Sources: Calabrian Child by Rabbi Shmuel Lesches History - Esrogey Atlein (Jacobson) by Yaacov Leib Altein http://www.esrogim.info/History.pdf