Skip to content
Parsha Pages

SUKKAH AND THE FOUR SPECIES

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

Sukkah 2a:

The Gemara presents three opinions for why a Sukkah taller than 20 Amos is Pasul (not acceptable):

  1. Rabbah says that the reason for why a 20-Amah-tall Sukah is Pasul is because the Schach is not readily noticeable. The applicable verse is “So that your generations should know that I made the Children of Israel dwell in booths (sukkos) where I took you out of Egypt.” (VaYikra 23,43)
  2. Rebbi Zeira says that it is Pasul because the Schach does not provide shade to the lower part of the Sukah when it is so high, rather the shade is provided by the walls. The applicable verse is “And a sukkah will give shade from the heat of the day.” (Yeshayahu 4,6)
  3. Rava says that a Sukah taller than 20 Amos is Pasul because the Torah requires that the Sukah be a "Diras Arai," a temporary dwelling. A structure taller than 20 Amos is normally built as a "Diras Keva," a permanent dwelling. The applicable verse is “You shall dwell in booths (sukkos) for seven days." (VaYikra 23,42).

A Fourth opinion, not in the Gemara: Hidden reason alluded in the verse in between portions cited by Rabbah and Rava, “All the native-born in Israel shall dwell in booths (sukkos)” (VaYikra 23,42) The word “native-born" does include converts but excludes non-Jews. Thus, we proclaim the uniqueness of the Jews by dwelling in the Sukkah and taking the Four Species (very public commandments). The implicit explanation is that higher than 20 amos then the makif (enveloping light which hovers around the sukkah) would be great enough to include Jews and non-Jews.

LulavRabbahKnowledge of the Sukkah Conscious awarenessSpinal cord (knowledge) Connect knowledge to the rest of the bodyTorahRebbi ZeiraShade by the Schach "Shadow of Faith"Hadasim Smell (good deeds) Self-sacrifice; devotionAvodahRavaTemporary dwelling Short-lived existenceAravos Most subject to nature Basic faithPrayer4th opinionOnly for Jews Proclaim our uniquenessEsrog A Jew's essence is perfect Left handDiscrimination

Based on Rabbi Yitzchak Ginburgh “Why can't a Sukkah be more than 20 cubits high?” Tishrei 20, 5766)

More in this printout

View the whole printout