Skip to content
Parsha Pages

KOL NIDRE

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

KOL NIDRE

BY RABBI JOSHUA FLUG

I. Intro- The tradition of reciting Kol Nidre dates back at least to the time of R. Amram Gaon (d. 875). (Siddur Rav Amram Gaon). Throughout the time of the Geonim and the Rishonim, it was considered a controversial tradition and only recited in certain places. In this shiur outline, we will present two basic approaches to understand the goal of Kol Nidre. Additionally, we will discuss why Kol Nidre was chosen to kick-off the Yom Kippur service. We will also provide some scholarly articles regarding Kol Nidre.

II. The Classic Understanding of Kol Nidre

a. The text presented by R. Amram Gaon seems to be a form of hataras nedarim.

i. R. Amram Gaon himself notes that the yeshivas of the time objected to the practice claiming it was a minhag shtus.

ii. Rabbeinu Asher (c. 1250-1327) notes that R. Natronai Gaon (9th century) also objected to the practice. (Yoma 8:28)

b. Rabbeinu Tam (c.1100-1171) presents four objections to the practice:

i. The Gemara states that hataras nedarim requires either three people or one expert to function as a beis din. (Becoros 36b) At Kol Nidrei, there is no beis din set up.

ii. In order to perform hataras nedarim, the individual must present regret for the neder. Nedarim 77b) Kol Nidrei makes no mention of regret. [The current version of Kol Nidrei does mention regret, but earlier versions did not.]

iii. According to R. Huna, which is the normative opinion, one must specify the nedarim in order for hataras nedarim to be effective. (Gittin 35b)

iv. The Mishna (Negaim 2:8) states that you can't annul your own vows. How then can does kol nidrei work for the chazzan? [In Tosafos, Nedarim 23b, this objection is slightly different. How does kol nidrei work for anyone if this is merely each person performing hataras nedarim for himself?]

c. There are two ways to defend these objections:

i. Rabbeinu Asher Yoma 8:28) defends these objections directly:

1. When hataras nedarim is recited, the rest of the congregation serves as the beis din for the individual reciting it.

2. It is clear that at the beginning of Yom Kippur there is regret for nedarim that if not annulled will lead to punishment.

3. The requirement to specify vows only applies in a situation where the beis din may discourage the petitioner from annulling his vow. However, on Yom Kippur, we are trying to undo any vows that were already violated and therefore, there is no reason to discourage annulment.

4. Since there is a beis din, one is not annulling his own vows.

ii. R. Yosef ibn Chabib (Nimmukei Yosef 14th-15th century) notes that Kol Nidrei may not be a halachic annulment of vows.

1. Ramban (1194-1270) writes that Kol Nidre only works for vows that were violated accidentally. (Mishpat haCherem)

2. Nimmukei Yosef, without quoting Ramban, expands on this idea and explains that Kol Nidre is a tefillah that one should not violate nedarim that one has already taken and one should not receive punishment for nedarim that were violated. (Nedarim 7b)

3. This idea explains some of the peculiar language in the text of Kol Nidre as presented by R. Amram Gaon:

a. בכולם חזרנו ובאנו לפני אבינו שבשמים- This line does not appear in our Kol Nidre, but it highlights the idea that the purpose is to appear before G-d in dealing with one's nedarim. If this were the classic hataras nedarim, this idea would not be relevant.

b. The quotation of the verse "ונסלח לכל עדת בני ישראל כי לכל העם בשגגה" seems to highlight the fact that the purpose is to deal with accidental violations.

III. Rabbeinu Tam's interpretation

a. Based on Rabbeinu Tam's objections, he suggests a new interpretation of Kol Nidre:

i. The Gemara quotes a version of the Mishna that if one wants to preempt any nedarim from taking effect that year, he should make a declaration at the beginning of the year that any vow that I take over the course of this coming year should be null and void. The Gemara then quotes a dispute between Abaye and Rava regarding how to interpret the line in the Mishna that states that the condition only works if one remembers at the time of the neder: (Nedarim 23b)

1. Abaye is of the opinion that the stipulation is only valid if the stipulation was forgotten at the time of the vow. If the person is aware of the stipulation and vows anyway, it is assumed that his intent is to uproot the original stipulation.

2. Rava understands the limitation in a different manner. Most Rishonim understand (see Ran) that Rava does not disagree fundamentally with Abaye, but rather interprets the Mishna differently. Accordingly, if one does not remember the condition at all at the time of the neder, the condition will uproot the neder. The Mishna's case is one where one remembers the condition but not the terms of the condition.

ii. Rabbeinu Tam suggests that Kol Nidre's purpose is to set a stipulation that any vows taken in the coming year should not take effect unless one remembers the condition at the time of the vow.

1. Although the Gemara states that this should be done at the beginning of the year, Yom Kippur can still be considered the beginning of the year.

a. In the hataras nedarim service of Erev Rosh HaShanah, we recite this condition.

2. Based on Rabbeinu Tam, all references to nedarim should refer to future nedarim and not past nedarim.

3. The word "איחרטנא" refers to regret for nedarim that one will perform and not ones that were already taken.

b. Can Kol Nidre really preempt all vows of the coming year?

i. As we noted earlier, most Rishonim are of the opinion that Abaye and Rava agree in a case where one does not remember the condition at the time of the neder.

1. Rambam (1135-1204) quotes one opinion that according to Rava, the condition only works if one remembers the condition within toch k'dai dibbur of taking the neder. Ra'avad (c. 1125-1198) concurs with this opinion. (Hilchos Nedarim 2:4)

ii. Shulchan Aruch quotes both opinion and writes that one should be concerned for the opinion of Ra'avad. (Y.D. 111:2)

1. Rama (1520-1572) writes that one should not rely on Kol Nidre to preempt one's vows without first consulting with a halachic authority.

iii. A number of poskim are lenient to rely on a preemptive condition for nidrei mitzvah:

1. The Gemara states that one can take a neder to fulfill a mitzvah. (Nedarim 8a)

2. Shulchan Aruch (based on the comments of a number of Rishonim) rules that if one accepts upon himself a stringency, it is binding like a neder unless he stipulates at the time of the practice that he is not accepting it as a neder.

3. The poskim present two reasons why a condition at the beginning of the year will preempt such a neder:

a. R. Shlomo Zalman Auerbach (1910-1995) suggests that the stringency of Ra'avad only applies to cases where one explicitly accepts a neder upon himself. However, regarding nidrei mitzvah that one does not accept as a neder, the explicit condition to preempt the neder should take precedence. (Minchas Shlomo 1:91)

i. He does admit that one must explain that Shulchan Aruch is only referring to a case where one did make a stipulation at the beginning of the year. He notes that it is easier to make that assumption if one assumes that Kol Nidre is not enough and one must explicitly make a stipulation for nidrei mitzvah as we do on Erev Rosh HaShanah.

b. R. Ovadia Yosef (b. 1920) suggests that since in principle, we follow the opinion of most Rishonim that a condition is effective if one does not remember it at the time of the neder, one may be lenient regarding nidrei mitzvah which are only rabbinic in nature. (O.Ch. 2:30)

IV. Why do we recite Kol Nidre specifically on Yom Kippur?

a. Following the classical approach, R. Yeshaya de Trani (the Elder c. 1180-1250) is cited by Shibollei HaLeket (317) as explaining that one cannot achieve atonement for transgressions unless all components of the atonement process are complete. If one is supposed to bring a korban for a transgression, teshuva is not sufficient for atonement if he has the possibility to bring that korban. Therefore, nedarim that were violated cannot be atoned for unless one performs teshuva and hataras nedarim on those transgressions.

b. According to Nimmukei Yosef, Kol Nidre is simply a form of vidui/selichos for nedarim that were violated.

c. According to Rabbeinu Tam, the reason to perform the condition on Yom Kippur is that the night of Yom Kippur is the biggest gathering of people around this time of year.

i. Maharam MiRutenberg (1215-1293) adds that this is the appropriate time of year to make this condition because Sukkos is a time when people make a lot of nedarim.

d. Other reasons for reciting Kol Nidre on Yom Kippur:

i. The The Vilna Gaon (1720-1797) writes that we recite hataras nedarim on Yom Kippur because the Torah states in the context of hafaras nedarim "VaHaShem yislach lah," and Yom Kippur is the day of selicha. (O.Ch. 619:1)

ii. R. Moshe Chaim Luzzatto (1707-1746) writes that the concept of teshuva is similar to the concept of hataras nedarim. (Mesilas Yesharim Chaprter 4) As such, R. Ya'akov M. Schechter suggests that this is the reason why we open Yom Kippur with Kol Nidre- to provide a model for the concept of teshuva.

iii. R. Moshe Feinstein (1895-1986) suggests that the reason why we recite Kol Nidre is that the message of nedarim is the value of one's words and how that translates to using one's words productively. This message is the key to observance of mitzvos. (Derush Moshe 31)

V. Other interesting points

a. Before Kol Nidre, we recite "על דעת המקום ועל דעת הקהל אנו מתירים להתפלל עם העבריינים." There are those that claim that this line was instituted for the marranos who would come to pray on Yom Kippur. However, we find this line in the Sefer Minhagim of Maharam MiRutenberg who lived 200 years before the Spanish Inquisition. (page 53)

More in this printout

View the whole printout