The Fallen Apple, the Seeds Found by the Dove, and Life Finding Its Place
Near the beis medrash where I daven stands an apple tree. Many people pass it every day. They enter the beis medrash, leave the beis medrash, and hurry onward to their work and concerns. Meanwhile beautiful apples ripen on the tree, fall to the ground, and are crushed beneath the feet of passersby. The entire street becomes dirty with them. Almost no one looks up at the tree or bends down toward the apples beneath it.
Each time I pass, I wonder anew: Why were all these apples created? The tree stood bare throughout the winter. Then it brought forth leaves and blossoms, received rain and sunlight, drew water from the earth, and slowly grew hundreds of apples. Every apple received color, flavor, sweetness, and fragrance. An entire world labored to bring it forth. Now it falls, is trampled, and becomes dirt in the street.
No one troubles himself to bend down, lift a whole apple, bring it home, wash it, and eat it. Except me. I am that one meshugener who bends toward the ground, looks among the apples for one that has not been crushed, lifts it, and takes it home. I wash it well, make a brachah, and eat it. It is fresh, heimish, and sweet. Even the peel can be eaten. It was not coated with oil or polished to shine in a store. It is a simple apple that grew here beside the beis medrash.
Had such an apple been resting in an attractive basket in a store, with a high price marked beneath it, people would lift it carefully. They would examine its color, feel it from every side, pay for it, and place it into a bag. Because they paid, it would become important in their eyes. But when Hashem gives it free of charge, no one wants it. Not because it is not good, but because no price was placed upon it.
We imagine that price grants a thing its importance. If we paid for it, it must be worthwhile. If someone else wants it, there must be something good in it. If it lies free in the street, it apparently has no value. In truth, price does not give value to a thing. At most it helps our eyes notice the value already there. When there is no price, a person needs an inner eye that can see for itself.
The Seeds the Dove Found
One day I passed and saw a dove standing inside a smashed apple. It pecked again and again. At first I wondered: What is it looking for in that repulsive pulp? To the people passing by, this was merely a trampled apple, a filthy object that should be cleared from the street. But the dove stood there with purpose, pecking and moving aside bits of apple as though it knew exactly what it wanted.
I watched and realized that it was not mainly seeking the flesh of the apple. It was searching for the seeds within. Every apple holds several small seeds arranged at its heart, and the dove pecked through the crushed apple specifically to reach them. What people regarded as a disgusting, discarded apple was, to the dove, a place containing good food.
Suddenly I was not looking only at a fallen apple. I saw an entire order of life. The tree produced an apple, and inside the apple it formed seeds. Each seed carries within itself the power of a new tree. Had it fallen in a fitting place and taken root, another tree could have begun from it, and that tree might have produced more apples and more seeds. But here the dove came and ate the seed. The life hidden within the seed did not now emerge as a tree. It entered the dove and became part of its life.
That same seed could have grown life from the earth. Now it continued life within a living creature. It became nourishment, strength, and movement for the dove. Through its power the dove could fly, seek food, and continue living. Life does not always have to emerge in the form we imagined. Sometimes the seed becomes a tree; sometimes it is eaten and sustains a living being. Either way, the life within it is not wasted.
The apple was not lost. While it hung on the tree, we thought its purpose was to be a beautiful apple. When it fell and was crushed, it appeared that its purpose had broken. Then the dove came and revealed that another purpose was still hidden inside. Outwardly it was smashed and repulsive, but at its heart were whole seeds. The dove knew how to pass through the ruined outer part and reach the living point within.
This was wondrous to me. People saw the outside and decided it was waste. The dove found the inside. It was not frightened by the filth surrounding the seed. It pecked a little more and a little more until it reached it. Where a person saw an ending and ruin, the dove found something worth eating, something that gave it life.
This is how life travels. I am not speaking here about the hidden teachings of gilgulim, which are beyond our present subject, but about the simple turning of life that we see each day. One thing becomes the food of another, and the second gives strength to a third. A leaf falls and becomes part of the soil. The soil nourishes the tree. The tree produces fruit. The fruit produces a seed. The seed may produce a tree, or it may be eaten and give strength to a dove.
Life passes onward and each time finds a new vessel in which to reveal itself. What yesterday was the tree's power of growth entered the apple. From the apple it passed into the seed. From the seed it entered the dove. The dove flies from place to place through its power. Perhaps later it will reach another place and there too become part of the order of life that Hashem directs in His world.
We see only one moment. We see the apple lying in the street, and in that moment it appears low and useless. We do not see the whole road it traveled, and we do not know where it is still going. If we could see the full circle, from the first blossom until the seed entered the dove's mouth and sustained it, we would not call it waste. We would see one stage in a long journey of life.
Perhaps that is why the dove touched me so deeply. It taught me that nothing is repulsive in itself. There is only something that has not yet found its place. To the person crossing the street, the apple is dirt. To the dove, it is a treasure containing seeds. To the soil, it is nourishing matter. Every part of the apple can come to its place. The same object may be waste to one and life to another.
The seeds were the apple's innermost part. As long as the apple was whole and beautiful, almost no one thought about them. The eye was drawn to the color, the peel, and the sweet flesh. Only after the apple fell and was crushed did its heart open and the seeds become visible. Precisely the outer breaking revealed the point of life hidden within.
The Remains of the Threshing Floor and Winepress
This is also the secret of the sukkah. The Torah says, "You shall make for yourself the festival of Sukkos for seven days, when you gather from your threshing floor and your winepress." Chazal learn that the schach is made from what remains after a person gathers the grain and wine. The valuable food enters his house; the straw, vines, and discarded parts remain outside and become schach for a mitzvah.
Throughout the year a person separates the main part from the waste. He keeps the kernels of grain and throws away the straw. He brings the grapes into the winepress and leaves the vines aside. Then Sukkos arrives and Hashem says: Take precisely what you put aside. Lift it over your head and make from it a home for the Shechinah. What was waste yesterday becomes the shade of emunah today.
The sukkah is not built from the part a person ate and enjoyed. It is built from the leftovers. Schach is neither food nor an attractive vessel, nor is it something for which people pay great sums. Nevertheless, the mitzvah is fulfilled specifically through it. A person sits beneath the discarded material, blesses his Creator there, eats there, sleeps there, and brings his entire life beneath that simple schach.
Perhaps the Torah is teaching that we still do not know what is essential and what is waste. We measure everything by the use it has for us now. Once we have removed the kernel from the stalk, we imagine that the straw has completed its task. But Hashem still has another task prepared for it. It will become schach, shelter a Yid from the sun, and surround him with the mitzvah of sukkah.
Waste is not the end of a thing. Waste is something that finished one purpose and has not yet entered the next. One who sees only the moment in between sees leftovers. One who sees the entire movement sees life traveling until it reaches its place. The straw left the threshing floor, passed through human hands, and finally became a Yid's dwelling on Yom Tov. The apple fell from the tree, was crushed in the street, and finally revealed seeds that sustained a dove.
In one sense straw and seed are opposites. Straw is what remains after the kernels have been removed, and therefore a person calls it waste. The seed inside the apple is precisely the point from which a new tree can begin. Yet to the person walking down the street, both lie at the side. He sees no further task in the straw and no life in the seed. Sukkos and the dove teach him not to measure anything by his first glance.
One Generation Goes and Another Comes
On Sukkos we read Koheles. At first glance, Koheles speaks of a world in which everything passes: "One generation goes and another generation comes." The sun rises and sets, the wind travels and returns, the rivers flow into the sea, yet the sea is not filled. A person labors, builds, gathers, and buys, and in the end everything slips from his hands. Everything that seemed permanent is revealed as passing and changing.
Yet within Koheles there is a wider vision. Life does not merely disappear; it returns in new forms. "It goes toward the south and turns toward the north; round and round goes the wind, and upon its circuits the wind returns." What disappears from our sight in one place reappears elsewhere. We do not hold life in our hands, because life is not our possession. It is a movement that Hashem carries through His world.
The apple comes from the tree and returns to the order of life. Sometimes it returns to the soil. Sometimes its seed produces another tree. Sometimes a dove eats the seed and its life-force passes into the dove. The apple does not remain an apple, the seed does not remain a seed, and life does not stand still. One form passes, and from it another form continues.
A person wants to hold on. He wants the fruit to remain beautiful, the garment to remain new, the house to stand forever, and the tefillah to remain within him as a clear feeling. But life does not stay in our hands in one form. The apple ripens, falls, opens, and becomes food. A garment passes from one person to another. The words spoken in tefillah rise to a place his eyes cannot see. A person's task is not to stop the movement, but to place brachah and honor within it.
Giving Importance on My Own
Some people cannot value anything unless others value it. They need to see an attractive store, a high price, and a crowd of buyers. They need to know that the object is accepted, desired, and famous. But a person has another power: to give importance by himself. He can see something lying aside, bend down toward it, raise it, and draw out its good.
I know this power from clothing as well. Sometimes people bring bags and boxes of clothing they no longer want. Many pass without seeing anything. I can search inside and find one good, complete, beautiful garment. Once it is taken out, cleaned, and worn properly, it may be more beautiful than a new garment sold in a store.
The garment did not change at the moment I lifted it. What changed was the way it was regarded. One moment it lay in a bag among unwanted objects; the next it became someone's garment. I gave it a place, and its value became visible. Sometimes a thing does not ask to be created anew. It asks only that someone see it, lift it, and say: You still have a place in the world.
Perhaps this is a large part of a person's avodah. Hashem does not always give us things arranged in a display window. Often He places fallen things before us: a tefillah that did not feel beautiful, a day that did not succeed, an idea that impressed no one, a person not accepted by others, a power within the nefesh that has not yet found a place. We quickly decide they are waste.
But one can bend down. One can peck a little through the crushed outside and find the seed. One can lift a tefillah from the ground and recognize that it too is a fruit that grew. A Yid stood before his Creator, said Malchiyos, Zichronos, and Shofros, fasted on Yom Kippur, confessed, and asked for mercy. Perhaps he did not feel a great fire, perhaps no one danced with him, but something living was created here.
On Motzaei Yom Kippur there are places where people dance with great joy and sing "Hamavdil bein kodesh lechol." It is a beautiful and holy joy. But a person does not have to wait for the whole tzibbur to dance with him before knowing that he had a good Yom Kippur. He can rejoice alone with his Creator. He can say: Baruch Hashem, I davened. Baruch Hashem, I stood in the beis medrash. Baruch Hashem, I said a few true words. Something precious happened here.
If others do not see my tefillah, that does not mean it has no life. If it has no market price, that does not mean it has no value in Heaven. If it fell and was trampled in my own eyes, a living seed may still lie within it. Perhaps one word I said will sustain me later. Perhaps it will give strength to someone else. Perhaps it will bring nachas ruach before Hashem in a place I cannot see.
The dove does not need the whole apple. A few small seeds are enough. A person also does not know which tiny point in his tefillah is truly alive. He looks at the entire tefillah and says: It was crushed. I had foreign thoughts. I did not feel properly. I did not daven as I wanted. Yet perhaps within that whole tefillah there was one seed of truth: one word, one sigh, one moment in which he truly stood before his Creator.
From the outside one sees a crushed tefillah. Hashem finds the seed. People measure the entire tefillah by its beauty, fire, and order. But sometimes the entire tefillah came into the world for one point hidden inside. It was wrapped in weakness and confusion, yet it contained a living point capable of nourishing the soul.
Even the Creator Is Given Free of Charge
There is an even deeper thought here. Kevayachol, even Hashem is treated as lowly in this world. He gives light, air, water, life, fruit, and strength, and everything is given free of charge. Therefore people do not always feel its value. If they had to pay each morning for breath, they would know how precious it is. If every ray of sunlight had to be purchased, they would marvel at it. But Hashem gives without a price, and a person becomes accustomed and walks on.
The Creator is present everywhere, and precisely for that reason it is easy for a person not to see Him. There is no display window around Him and no price tag. No one forces a person to stop and be amazed. The whole world receives life from Him at every moment, yet one can pass an entire day without giving Him honor. He gives everything free, and what is free becomes, in human eyes, something that requires no attention.
But a Yid can bend down and lift. He can take an apple given freely, wash it, make the brachah Borei pri ha’eitz, and give honor to the One Who created it. With one brachah he returns the apple to its root. Until now people passed and stepped upon it. Now one person comes and recognizes: There is a creation here. There is sweetness that Hashem prepared. There is life here.
At that moment the apple's entire journey receives meaning. The tree that stood through winter, the blossom that opened in spring, the rain that fell, the sunlight that warmed, and the soil that nourished all enter the brachah. A person is not blessing merely a piece of fruit. He recognizes the entire journey of life that has now reached his hand and says: Blessed are You, Hashem, Who creates the fruit of the tree.
This may be the special joy of Sukkos. We leave the permanent house and sit beneath things that have little importance in the eyes of the world. There is no stone ceiling, no strong building, and no outward grandeur. There are a few walls and schach made from the remains of the threshing floor and winepress. There we say: Zman simchaseinu.
This joy does not depend upon the price of the house. It comes from recognizing that Hashem is with us within the temporary, the leftovers, and the things the world does not value. One can sit beneath simple branches and be surrounded by a mitzvah. One can take waste and transform it into a dwelling. One can find within a crushed apple seeds that continue the life of a dove.
Koheles teaches that the world passes. The sukkah teaches how to rejoice within a passing world. We do not need to hold everything forever. We must receive it when it comes, make a brachah, give it honor, and allow life to continue on its road. What comes to me now does not have to remain mine. But while it is in my hand, I can place kedushah within it.
Since seeing the dove pecking inside the crushed apple, I see the street differently. The apples still fall. People still pass without noticing. The street still becomes dirty. But within the dirt I see movement. I see a fruit that was once a blossom. I see seeds that formed inside it. I see a dove finding them and receiving strength to live.
I also see my own life. Not everything in it stands neatly in a store. It contains fallen tefillos, rejected thoughts, powers that never received a place, and days that seemed unnecessary. But if Hashem gave me the strength to bend down toward an apple in the street, perhaps He also gave me the strength to bend toward those places inside myself, peck through the crushed outer surface, and find within them a seed of life.
I do not have to wait for others to give them a price. I do not have to wait for someone to tell me that my tefillah mattered, that my joy was proper, or that my life is beautiful. I can take what was given to me, bless it, and rejoice with it. I can give honor even to something no one else honors.
If one can honor a fallen apple, one can honor a fallen person. If one can find a good garment inside a discarded bag, one can find a good strength within a nefesh pushed to the side. If the discarded remains of the threshing floor and winepress can become schach for a mitzvah, then parts of a person's life that appeared to be waste can also become the place upon which the Shechinah rests.
For with Hashem there is no unnecessary life. There is life that has not yet reached its place. It travels and changes from one form to another until its moment comes. Sometimes the seed enters the earth and produces a tree. Sometimes a dove eats it and it becomes strength within its body. Sometimes Sukkos arrives, and what had been lying below rises to become schach above our heads.
Then it becomes clear that joy is not found only in what we managed to bring into the house. There is joy in what remained from the threshing floor and the winepress. There is joy in the simple thing, the free thing, the thing no one asks for. When a person recognizes that everything comes from the Creator and can return to Him, he can sit inside a temporary sukkah and rejoice with complete joy.
He knows that life is not lost. It only passes onward. The apple passes from the tree to the earth. The seed passes from the apple to the dove. The discarded material passes from the threshing floor to the sukkah. The thought passes from the heart into tefillah. And the tefillah rises from the person to his Creator.
Perhaps all those beautiful apples that no one lifts were created for this: so that one day a Yid would pass, bend toward the ground, lift an apple, see a dove pecking specifically for the seeds, and learn anew how much life Hashem has hidden even within what the world had already called waste.