On Sukkos, something remarkable happens: things that had been lying below are lifted above. The straw, leaves, and branches left behind after the grain and grapes have been gathered become the schach. All year long they are cast upon the ground. On Sukkos we raise them and place them over our heads.
This is not a side detail of the mitzvah. Chazal learn from the words, "when you gather from your threshing floor and your winepress," that the schach is made from the discarded remains of the threshing floor and winepress. Precisely what a person no longer needs, what remains after he has removed the valuable part, now becomes the heart of the mitzvah. Beneath that discarded material a Yid sits, eats, drinks, sleeps, and places his entire life under the shadow of the Shechinah.
All year we live with a different order. What matters is raised up; what seems lesser falls below. The grain enters the house and the straw remains outside. The grapes enter the winepress and the vines are put aside. A person takes what has flavor, value, and use, and calls the rest waste.
On Sukkos that order is overturned. The waste rises. The person sits below, while the straw and branches stand above him. What had been beneath his feet now surrounds him in the kedushah of the sukkah. Suddenly it becomes clear that something which fell has not left Hashem's world. It still has a place. It still has a purpose. A dwelling for the Shechinah can still be made from it.
The Cloud of Ketores Becomes Schach
Where did we receive the power to raise what had been cast aside? That power begins on Yom Kippur. The unique center of the avodah in the Beis Hamikdash was the Kohen Gadol's entrance into the Kodesh HaKodashim with the ketores. He entered the holiest place, placed the incense upon the fire, and the chamber filled with a cloud, as the Torah says, "The cloud of the ketores shall cover the kapores that is upon the testimony."
The seforim of Chassidus explain that the cloud of ketores on Yom Kippur is later drawn into the Clouds of Glory of Sukkos. The cloud that remained hidden within the Kodesh HaKodashim becomes the shade of the sukkah, surrounding the Yid during the Yom Tov. On Yom Kippur it is a hidden cloud, deep within the holiest place. On Sukkos it becomes an embrace that enters ordinary human life: "You shall dwell in sukkos." A person eats, drinks, and sleeps within that holy shade.
There is another depth here. The ketores itself teaches us how something low and distant can be raised. Among its ingredients was chelbenah, a spice whose scent by itself was unpleasant. Yet the ketores could not be made without it. It was placed among all the other spices, ground together with them very finely, and the entire mixture was raised upon the fire.
The chelbenah was not excluded because of its odor. It entered, joined the whole, and rose with everything else into the innermost chamber. Something unpleasant by itself became part of the fragrance rising before Hashem. From here Chazal also taught that a public fast is incomplete unless the sinners of Klal Yisrael are included. They too must enter the whole and rise together with it (Kerisus 6b).
This is the power of Yom Kippur. A Yid does not come before Hashem only with his beautiful deeds. He comes with the lesser places as well: with what he did not succeed in doing, with the thoughts that fell, with the desires that never reached action, and with the tefillos that were not what he had hoped. He places all of it into the ketores. He raises all of it lifnai velifnim.
On an ordinary day a person is ashamed of his chelbenah. He wants to display only the good part. On Yom Kippur he says vidui and brings his whole existence before Hashem. He does not leave the unwanted pieces outside. It is precisely when the chelbenah joins all the other spices that the cloud of ketores is formed.
From that cloud comes the schach. After Yom Kippur gives us the power to raise the chelbenah, Sukkos gives us the power to raise the discarded remains of the threshing floor and winepress. The ketores reveals that no Yid is pushed out of the whole. The schach reveals that no part of creation is without an aliyah. The lesser scent rises as a pleasing fragrance, and the rejected branch rises to become the shade of a mitzvah.
What Did I Gain From My Tefillah
After Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur, a Yid may ask himself: What remains from all those tefillos? I stood for hours in shul. I said the piyutim, heard the shofar, cried, begged, and accepted resolutions upon myself. What do I now hold in my hand? What can I cash in from all that avodah?
It is a very human question. A person naturally measures success by what he can see. If a yeshuah came, if his parnassah increased, if a difficulty was resolved, he feels that his tefillah produced fruit. He can say that the tefillah paid off. He invested on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur and later cashed in those tefillos through parnassah, health, or success.
It is certainly true that we ask for these things. We daven for life, parnassah, health, nachas, and yeshuos. None of them is small. Every human need comes from Hashem, and we must ask Him for all of them. Sometimes a Yid is privileged to see during the year how a tefillah from the Yamim Noraim opened a door and brought him blessing.
But there is an even happier Yid. He does not wait until he can cash in his tefillah as money or as a visible yeshuah. The very fact that he left Rosh Hashanah with a little more yiras Shamayim is already a great profit in his eyes. If one moment of emunah entered his heart, if he once felt that he was standing before the King, if one true word left his mouth, he possesses a treasure.
A little yiras Shamayim is also something. A little emunah is also something. One moment in which the heart opened is a treasure that cannot be measured. A person does not have to display it to others, nor must he feel it at every moment. He knows that something good entered him on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. Even if it is small and delicate, it is exceedingly precious.
Some people cannot value a thing until it can be converted into something tangible. If tefillah brings money, they understand. If it produces visible success, they rejoice. But yiras Shamayim is not always a coin that can be placed upon the table. A new mind, a new feeling, and a new understanding make very little noise. Sometimes they rest deep within a person and guide his entire year without his knowing where they came from.
On Sukkos a Yid learns to value something that has no market price. Schach is not an expensive food displayed in a shop. It is the discarded remnant of the threshing floor and the winepress. Yet when it is placed where it belongs, it becomes a mitzvah. So it is with one small moment of yirah. A person may not be able to cash it in immediately, but it remains above his head, guarding him and surrounding his life.
The Head Gives Life to the Entire Body
Rosh Hashanah is called the head of the year, not merely its beginning. The head is not only the first limb of the body. It is the place from which vitality, feeling, and direction extend to the entire body. The mind thinks, decides, and leads; afterward its strength reaches the eyes, heart, hands, and feet.
So it is with Rosh Hashanah. The mochin of the entire year are drawn down then. A person cannot yet see what will happen in Cheshvan, Teves, Nissan, or Tammuz. But the head already contains the vitality that will later be distributed to every limb. Rosh Hashanah is the root from which each day of the year will receive its portion.
This exists, to a degree, in every tefillah. In the morning a person davens and draws daas and life into the day ahead. He rises a little higher, puts his thoughts in order, remembers before Whom he lives and what his purpose is, and then descends into his affairs. Tefillah is the head of the day. From it the hands at work, the feet in the street, and the mouth speaking with people must receive their vitality.
If the day later passes amid distraction, that does not mean the tefillah disappeared. Perhaps the tefillah gave him the strength to pause once, guard his mouth, remember Hashem, or do a kindness. The mochin of the tefillah entered one small deed. He may not recognize the connection, but the life has already traveled from the head to the limb.
On Rosh Hashanah this avodah is done for the entire year. We stand for hours and daven. We search and dig above, drawing mochin into all the coming days. Every tekiah, every verse of Malchiyos, every remembrance, and every tefillah plants a root. Throughout the year that root is divided into another day and another day, another test and another choice.
When a Yid asks immediately after Yom Kippur what he gained, he resembles a person looking at the head and asking where the hands and feet are. They are still receiving from it. The entire year is yet to emerge from this head. The winter and summer ahead will continue to unfold what was drawn down on Rosh Hashanah.
There are, indeed, those who cash in their tefillah through parnassah. That too is part of the vitality descending from head to body. The body needs food, a home, and clothing, and those are also determined on Rosh Hashanah. Yet the mochin of Rosh Hashanah are not merely a road toward physical needs. They are the inner life that will accompany a person within everything he receives.
Two people may receive the same parnassah. One lives with it in constant fear, while the other lives with it in emunah. Not only the money is determined on Rosh Hashanah; the mind with which a person will receive that money is also drawn down on Rosh Hashanah. Not only the events of the year, but the daas with which he will pass through them.
Sukkos Is the Time of Gathering
The Torah calls Sukkos Chag HaAsif, the Festival of Gathering. Things grew in the field throughout the year, and now a person gathers them. He does not create them on Sukkos; they have already been growing for months. Now he brings them home and discovers what truly grew in his field.
The avodah of Tishrei also contains planting, growth, and gathering. On Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur a person planted tefillos. He drew down mochin, awakened desires, raised the chelbenah, and did teshuvah. Often he still does not know what grew from all of this. Sukkos arrives and the gathering begins.
This does not mean that every yeshuah is already visible. The first gathering takes place within the nefesh. A person begins to recognize that he holds something. He gathers the moments of emunah, the small measure of yirah, the good desires, and the true words he spoke. He does not leave them scattered in the shul of Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. He carries them with him into the sukkah.
This is the joy of Sukkos. On Rosh Hashanah a person stands in awe. On Yom Kippur he fasts, confesses, and raises everything above. On Sukkos he begins to feel that this avodah belongs to him. It does not remain only in Heaven. It descends and becomes schach, walls, eating, drinking, and dwelling. Kedushah enters ordinary life.
We can now understand why the time of gathering is zman simchaseinu. Joy comes when a person recognizes what he has. As long as he believes he accomplished nothing, his heart remains closed. The moment he gathers his good points and recognizes that every small amount is a treasure, he becomes joyful.
He tells himself: I davened on Rosh Hashanah. I stood before my Creator on Yom Kippur. I said vidui. I asked forgiveness. At least one good thought was present within me. I wanted a good and holy year. Perhaps I cannot yet see the fruit, but the root is already here. I did not leave empty-handed.
The Four Minim Rise in Waving
After entering the sukkah, we take the four minim: lulav, esrog, hadassim, and aravos, all things that grew from the earth. We bring them together, bind them in one hand, and raise and wave them.
Chazal say that we move them outward and inward toward the One to Whom the four directions belong, and upward and downward toward the One to Whom Heaven and earth belong (Sukkah 37b). A person takes what grew below and waves it toward every direction and above. He declares that all growth, all fruit, and the whole world belong to the One Who spoke and brought the world into being.
This continues the avodah of schach. With schach we raise the discarded material and place it above our heads. With the four minim we lift the growth itself. After gathering the year's produce, we do not hold it only for ourselves. We raise it back to Hashem.
The lulav stands straight, its head reaching high. The hadassim and aravos surround it, while the esrog rests in the other hand. Different things, with different tastes and fragrances, gather into one bundle. Each brings what it has, and all rise together.
This is not only an ascent of what already seems important. The aravah, which has neither taste nor fragrance, stands within the bundle. It is not left aside. It too rises. Like the chelbenah within the ketores, and like the discarded material within the schach, the aravah is gathered and raised.
The ketores gathers different scents, including the chelbenah. The sukkah gathers the remains of the threshing floor and winepress. The four minim gather different species, including the aravah. All three reveal the same foundation: kedushah does not take only what already appears whole and important. It knows how to gather the lesser part, join it to the whole, and raise it.
On Yom Kippur the cloud of ketores rises. On Sukkos that cloud becomes schach above our heads. Then a person takes the four minim in his own hands and raises them as well. First Hashem surrounds him from above; afterward he gathers what is in the world with his own hands and lifts it back upward.
He waves the minim up and down, east, west, north, and south. It is as though he gathers every part of his life: what was above and what was below, what went to the right and what was pushed left, the successes and the falls. He brings everything close to his heart and raises it all to Hashem.
Cashing In the Tefillos of the Yamim Noraim
We may say that taking the four minim is the moment when a Yid cashes in the tefillos of Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur. He does not cash them in only as money. He draws from them the daas, yirah, emunah, and joy that had been hidden within them.
Every waving is a hamshachah. We raise the minim and then bring them back toward the heart. The purpose of rising is not to remain above. A person raises the lulav toward Heaven and then draws it back to himself. He takes what he reached in tefillah and brings it within.
This is the true way to cash in a tefillah. Tefillah is not a coin placed above while one waits to see how much money will come out. Tefillah draws mochin. Those mochin must then be brought into the heart, the home, one's parnassah, and every act of the day.
When a person gains a little patience from his tefillah, he has cashed in part of it. When he remembers Hashem in the middle of business, he has cashed it in. When he can see something small and recognize it as a treasure, he has already brought the mochin of Rosh Hashanah down into his life.
Now the entire Yom Tov can be understood as one movement. On Rosh Hashanah we draw down the head and mochin for the whole year. On Yom Kippur we raise every part of the person within the cloud of ketores, and even the chelbenah rises as a pleasing fragrance. From that cloud comes the schach of the sukkah. Therefore Sukkos gives us the power to raise the discarded remains of the threshing floor and winepress and place them above our heads.
Then we take the four minim. We gather everything that grew from the earth, bind together what is different and distant, and lift it all upward. Afterward we draw the minim back to the heart, so that the mochin of Rosh Hashanah and the purity of Yom Kippur will enter our lives.
This is Chag HaAsif. We gather every tefillah. We gather the good thoughts. We gather the moments of yirah scattered through many hours of davening. We gather the chelbenah, the discarded material, and the aravah. Nothing has to remain outside.
A Yid stands after the Yamim Noraim and says: Perhaps I did not achieve what I wanted. Perhaps my tefillah was not pure. Perhaps among all those hours I had only one true moment. Sukkos tells him: Take that moment and raise it. Do not trample upon it. Do not call it waste. Every small measure of yiras Shamayim is a treasure.
On Sukkos the discarded rises. The chelbenah rises. The aravah rises. Tefillos that seemed poor rise. The fallen parts of a person are gathered. What was scattered becomes one bundle, and what lay below becomes shade above the head.
A person sits beneath the schach and says: Even what I discarded can rise. He takes the lulav and says: Even my scattered pieces can be gathered. He draws the minim toward his heart and says: Everything I raised on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur can now descend within me and become life.