Skip to content
Parsha Pages

Tefilah Zakah: History of a Controversial Prayer

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

Yom Kippur has many unique prayers many of them have been added through the centuries. Tefillah Zakah is a special prayer that many say after completing the final meal before the fast upon arriving in the shul before Kol Nidrei.

It is called the "pure prayer" because of its purifying effect on the hearts of its readers as a preparation for the Day of Atonement.

The subject of the tefillah zakah is the acceptance of the fasts five "afflictions": refraining from 1] eating 2] drinking 3] washing and anointing 4] wearing shoes of leather and 5] marital relations.

Another essential aspect of the prayer is repentance and forgiveness for sins committed by people against each other. These transgressions are not forgiven by G-d on Yom Kippur unless one asks forgiveness from the offended first. But this can't always be done. How can one find all those that he has hurt to conciliate them? And how can others find him to conciliate him over having wronged him?

Tefillah zakah places in the mouths of all those who repent, wherever they may be, words of whole-hearted mutual forgiveness which remove the barriers of atonement and open the gates of Divine Mercy. Here is an excerpt from the prayer:

"I hereby extend total forgiveness to all who have wronged me, whether personally or financially, or by slandering or defacing me; to all who have committed against me any of the wrongs that are between man and man, let no one be punished because of me. And just as I forgive all men, grant me favor in the eyes of all, that they might also extend total forgiveness to me."

There are two reasons offered for reciting this prayer. Dr. Sperber opines (Minhagei Yisrael, vol. 2, p. 37 and esp. n.10) that the purpose of this prayer is to fulfill the opinion of the Ramban who holds that is an additional viduy on directly prior to Kol Nedrei on Erev Yom Kippur. (He offers that either Tefilah Zakah or a piyyut from R. Abraham ibn Ezra, fulfills this purpose). R. Abraham Ashkenazi (Brit Abraham, Warsaw, 1884, no. 129) offers a different reason for Tefilah Zakah. The purpose according to him, is to accept Yom Kippur early. At the end of Tefilah Zakah, one voices that they are accepting "kedushas Yom Kippurim." In fact, R. Ashkenazi holds that for the purposes of fulfilling the opinion of the Ramban Tefilah Zakah would be insufficient as it differs significantly from the standard viduy. R. Ashkenazi, however, also holds that one should fulfill the Ramban's opinion and thus recite the regular viduy after Tefilah Zakkah. (Surprisingly, Dr. Sperber doesn't discuss R. Ashkenazi's concern). Tefilah Zakah has a passage where one forgives others who may have sinned against him. This is necessary, as although Yom Kippur takes care of sins between man and G-d, it can't take care of sins between man and man. Thus, it is necessary for each to receive forgiveness from their fellowman to achieve full forgiveness. Tefilah Zakah is long, and this paragraph that forgives others, appears at the end. The Chofetz Chaim attempted to alleviate this problem "and contacted the printers to change the placement of this paragraph of Tefilah Zakah. That is, to place this later paragraph earlier in prayer, to place the paragraph where one forgives others in the middle or the beginning." According to the Chofetz Chaim's son, R. Aryeh Leib, some siddurim did in fact shift around the prayer. (Michtevei Chofetz Chaim, p. 21-2 #52; quoted in Sperber, Minhagei Yisrael, vol. 4, 274). The source to popularize this prayer is the book Chaiye Adam. [1] Chaiye Adam was first published in 1809, then in 1819 (the discussion regarding Tefilah Zakah only appears in this second edition - and thus, perhaps should be called a mahdurah [2]), and the third edition in 1825 - it would be this third edition that would be used for subsequent printing. [3] And, thereafter there was a flood of reprints - by 1960, Chaiye Adam had been published at least 103 times (!) - a very popular book by any measure. While the book was reprinted on many occasions there were slight changes (some for the worse - there were many printing errors that crept in). As relevant to our discussion, in some editions, the portion discussing Tefilah Zakah changed as well. [4] The source that R. Danzig lists for Tefilah Zakah (klall 144), is the Sefer Hemdes Yamim. [5] In light of the fact that Hemdat Yamim is controversial in some editions of the Chaiye Adam they removed words "Hemdat Yamim" so as not to have that as the source for this prayer. [6]

The twin factors [7] of the use of a suspect work, Hemdat Yamim, and the creation of a new prayer, made some hesitant to adopt Tefilah Zakah. In the Tosefos Chayim, a commentary on the Chaiye Adam written by R. Meshulum Finkelstein, [8] deals with both of these issues and defends the recitation of Tefilah Zakah (klall 144 n.31). First, he alleges the prayer is not the same as that in Hemdas Yamim.[9] Second, he argues that the concern of saying a later prayer - this concern is attributed to the AriZal and is why, according to some the Yigdal prayer is not recited in some circles - is applicable to "yehidei segulah" (special people) and not to the masses. This is demonstrated by the many piyyutim we recite which are later than the cut-off date for prayers (R. Eliezer HaKalir - whenever he may have lived). Additionally, according to some, any prayer that has been accepted by the masses, this concern is not applicable.

Notes

  • The fullest discussion of this prayer can be found in Mordechai Meyer's article "On 'Tefilah Zakah" in Kenishta, vol. 2 pp. 119-138 including the language of the various editions of the Chaiye Adam.
  • [1] According to R. Barukh haLevi Epstein, (Mekor Barukh, vol. 3 p. 1260 [end of chapter 21]), R. Danzig titled the book Chaiye Adam to avoid any attempt to abridge it as it would then be titled Kitzur Chaiye Adam (Shortening the Life of Man). If this is true, it appears it did not help as in 1854 an abridged version was published although the title was Kitzur M'Sefer Chaiye Adam (An Abridgement of the Work Chaiye Adam). Interestingly, R. Y.S. Nathenson refers to the Sefer Chaiye Adam as Kitzur Chaiye Adam. Shu't Shoel u'Meshiv, vol. 2 no. 14 (it is unclear whether there should be a Hey prior to Chaiye Adam that would have R. Nathenson as merely listing the Sefer Chaiye Adam as an abridgment and the "kitzur" part would not be part of the title.)
  • [2] For the use of this term "mahdurah" and when it should be applied and more specifically should this second edition of the Chaiye Adam should be deemed a mahdurah m'Tukenet or mahdurah Sheneiah, see Y.S. Speigel, Amudim b'Toldot Sefer Halvri: Kitveah v'Hatakah, Ramat Gan, 2005, 109-60.
  • [3] Tefilah Zakah was published separately numerous times under the title Tefilah Zakah (it was here it seems the usage of Tefilah Zakah became popular - R. Danzig never refers to it as Tefilah Zakah). The first time it was published was in Minsk, 1833 (see Meir, supra, p. 122)(there is possibly one earlier print by a year or so, in Russia also around 1830 but this is not definite) and republished as a seperate prayer on numerous occasions (by 1900 it had been published close to 50 times). It was first incorporated into the Machzor in 1882 in the Romm edition of the Machzor. (Meir, p. 124) Although the title of Tefilah Zakah was well established as late as 1856 this prayer was published under the title Tefilah HaEtkah M'Sefer Chaiye Adam and not Tefilah Zakah.
  • [4] While the exact nusach of Tefilah Zakah does not appear in Hemdat Yamim, much of it does (see notes below for more). There are those who claim that since the Tefilah is not the same, thus, Tefilah Zakah doesn't really come from Hemdat Yamin. This is wrong. First, R. Danzig states it does - so he had no problem with it. Second, even if it is not word for word, and R. Danzig "improved" on the one in Hemdat Yamin, at the very least the basis for it, and much of it does in fact come from Hemdat Yamin. But, it is unsurprising that people would go to great lengths to void Hemdat Yamin as the source for this popular prayer.
  • [4] The removal of the mention of Hemdat Yamim both here and in other cases (including the discussion below regarding R. Suesskind's work) is discussed by R. S. Divlitsky, "HaShmotot Mahdirim," in Taggim, 1 (1969), 76-77 [Ya'ari, in Talmuot Sefer, also mentions the change to the Chaiye Adam see under index under Chaiye Adam]. For other examples of removal or changes to various editions of the Chaiye Adam see R. A.I. Goldroth, "Al HaSefer 'Chaiye Adam' U'Mechbro," in Sefer Margoliyos, Jerusalem, 1973, pp. 262-67 esp. n.1. For a discussion about Tefilah Zakah, as well as the Chaiye Adam see R. E. Levin & M. I. Blau, "Tefilah Zakah," in Mishpacha, Kulmus, Tishrei, 2008, 16-19; and Blau's earlier article, "Al Sefer Hemdat Yamim," in Kovetz Bet Ahron v'Yisrael, Nissan, 2004 (112), pp. 161-164.
  • [5] In the Zolikav, 1838, Vilna, 1849; Tchernowitz, 1864; editions the words Hemdat Yamim are cut out and instead, the line reads, "in the works of the AriZal" and then has Tefilah Zakah. This is not the only mention of Hemdat Yamim in Chaiye Adam. When discussing (klall 145) what happens if one has a nocturnal emission on Yom Kippur the Chaiye Adam again cites to the Hemdat Yamim. In some editions the words "Hemdat Yamim" are missing, in others, it is abbreviated ("ח"ה") so only those "in the know" will be able to understand.
  • [6] There is a third concern raised by the former Pupa Rebbi, who notes that as Tefilah Zakah discusses inappropriate sexual behavior, one should avoid saying it as it may lead to improper thoughts about the possible improper behavior. See R. G. Zinner, Neta Gavreil, Hilchot Yom HaKippurim, Jerusalem, 2001, p. 185 n.4. For a list of those who did not say Tefilah Zakah, see Y. Mondshein, Otzar Minhagei Chabad, [Jerusalem], 1995, pp. 200-01. Among other reasons, a similar reason to the Pupa Rebbi is offered by the wife of the Tzemach Tzedek. Additionally, a entirely new reason is given - that Tefilah Zakah is actually a deficient or inadequate prayer. As it is so bad is why, perversly, it has become so popular because, it seems, people like junk. See id. at n.1 in the name of the Sefer Areyeh Sha'ag. See also, R. T. Ohrenreich, Katseh haMateh, in Mateh Efrahim, no. 619:17 who offers other methods to fulfill the opinions who hold one must do a viduy prior to the onset of Yom Kippur in lieu of Tefilah Zakah.
  • [7] It was first published in the Warsaw, 1888 edition of the Chaiye Adam. R. Finkelstein wrote not only a commentary on Chaiye Adam but also on the Matteh Efrahim, Elef HaMogan, first published in Mateh Efrahim HaShalem, Pitrokov, 1908. He also published a collection of commentaries on the Mishna under the title Tosefot Hakhomim, Warsaw, 1916.
  • [8] See note 4 above. This justification is bizarre. First, as noted above, the Chaiye Adam says he is using the Hemdat Yamim - so at the very least he had no problem if it was there. Second, there are entire passages that do appear in Hemdat Yamim. For instance, the Hemdat Yamim has using kissing the sefer Torah to fix various sins (p. 291 of Tzuriel ed. - all citations are to this edition). Or there is an extensive discussion about the inability to fix something that someone stole from someone else (p. 229-36). There is another list of sins that mimic that in Tefilah Zakah (p. 252-57).
  • [9] This reasoning appears somewhat circular in that how did the prayer get started if one is prohibited from saying it to begin with? Even if one assumes this is merely extending the concept of "im ain neviem, beni neviem hamah," it doesn't excuse the R. Danzig from advocating for something that is prohibited.

More in this printout

View the whole printout