Skip to content
Parsha Pages

THE TEN MARTYRS

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

The stories of the Ten Martyrs have moved the hearts of Jews for generations. These stories of Jewish heroism have inspired Jews throughout the ages. During the Crusades, the Inquisition, the Holocaust and through the birth of modern Israel whenever Jewish dedication to G-d was challenged and threatened, the memory of the Ten Martyrs served as an example of selflessness, devotion and service to our people.

The Talmud taught that the Roman Empire were the genetic and idealistic heirs to the biblical Esav. The Romans were obsessed with Esav's hate and need to take revenge against his brother Yaacov and they did everything in their power to eradicate Jews and Judaism from the face of the Earth.

Although hundreds of thousands of Jews were murdered by the hands of the evil Roman Empire, our Midrash focuses on ten great Tannaic leaders and luminaries. Although most of these sages lived during the Hadrian era, it is well known that the ten martyrs discussed in this Midrash spanned a period of at least one hundred and fifty years. There is also controversy as to who amongst the hundreds of leaders that were brutally tortured and killed were the “ten” martyrs. Nevertheless, the Midrash and Zohar see these killings as outstanding and united parts of one particular decree on our people.

The Midrash Eleh Ezkera - "These I will Remember" - is a Midrash which describes the murder of the 'Ten Martyrs' at the hands of the Roman Empire. The Midrash seeks to find some purpose and reason for the suffering of the people and the Ten Martyrs. It finds three ‘sins' which caused the deaths of these martyrs:

  • There were those among the Jewish people who did not mourn the destruction of the Beis HaMikdash. They said "What have we really lost with the destruction of the Beis HaMikdash? We still have wise scholars to guide the world with God's Torah and His mitzvos";
  • The Rabbis themselves were held accountable for teaching Torah to Caesar; and
  • The deaths of the Ten Martyrs atoned for the sins of Yosef and his brothers.

As the leaders of Israel, the Rabbis were held responsible for the sins of their entire generation. They should have shown the people the enormity of the loss of the Beis HaMikdash. Although Judaism has adapted and survived for almost two thousand years, the loss of the Beis HaMikdash is irreplaceable. The Rabbis themselves were punished for allowing people to think that they could be an alternative to the Beis HaMikdash. Ironically, because these Rabbis were so great, it made it more difficult for people to mourn the destruction. However, as great leaders, they were responsible to ensure that the nation did not view them as an alternative.

While the Midrash Eleh Ezkera does not seem to indicate that the Ten Martyrs were reincarnations of Yosef and the brothers, the Arizal does make such a claim. According to Kabbalistic tradition the souls of Yosef and the brothers were reborn into these rabbis, and thus their deaths literally atoned for the sin of the sale of Yosef. The Kabbalistic book Sefer Hatziuni, in the name of Sefer Heichalos explains the connection between each brother and each martyr. He explains that Reuven was not part of the sin, because he went to serve his father while the sale of Yosef was taking place. Binyamin was also not party to the sale, being the youngest son he stayed at home with his father. However, Yosef is also considered responsible and guilty for his own sale, and therefore required atonement through the death of one of the Ten Martyrs. The brothers and the martyrs can be matched as follows:

  • Rabbi Elazar ben Shamua = Shimon (Shimon contains the letters Shamua; in addition, he may have been from the tribe of Shimon)
  • Rabbi Yishmael = Levi (as High Priest, Rabbi Yishmael was a descendant of Levi)
  • Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel = Yehuda (He was the prince of the Sanhedrin, and a descendant of Yehuda)
  • Rabbi Chutzpis the Interpreter= Yissachar (the blessing of the tribe of Yissachar was “chamor garam” – “a crouching donkey”, the letters of which are contained within the name Chutzpis HaMeturgeman)
  • Rabbi Akiva ben Yosef = Yosef
  • Rabbi Chanina ben Teradion = Dan
  • Rabbi Yehuda ben Teima = Zevulun
  • Rabbi Yeshavav = Gad
  • Rabbi Yehuda ben Bava = Naftali
  • Rabbi Chanina ben Chachinai = Asher

More in this printout

View the whole printout