Skip to content
Parsha Pages Youth

Excitement in Halacha – Olive Alive

  • Tetzaveh
  • 5784
  • English
View printout

Chanukah was fast approaching and Rabbi Berger was all fired up. He had come up with a way to add a real spark to the mitzva of lighting the menorah.

"I just ordered olives from Oliver's Olive Orchard," mentioned Rabbi Berger to his eldest son Yehoshua.

"Why not just get olives from the regular grocery store?" asked Yehoshua.

"I was inspired by the Rambam who says that when you do a mitzvah you are supposed to use the best quality product possible. He explicitly describes how to make oil for the menorah in the Beis Hamikdash. I wanted to try making the oil myself the same way for our Chanukah menorah," explained Rabbi Berger.

"Oil is oil. What could be so special that the Rambam had to provide a recipe?" asked Yehoshua.

"Well as you know, the Torah says that the oil for the Menorah had to be 'shemen zayis zuch' – pure olive oil (Shmos 28:20). The Rambam explains the process of producing the oil in a way that will render it pure enough to qualify optimally for the Menorah.

  1. Pick only the first ripened olives from the top of the tree.
  2. Select the best olives from that batch.
  3. Pound them and place the smashed olives into a wicker basket.

The oil that leaks out of the holes of the basket is the purest oil, because the olives are not being crushed nor is there a weight being placed on them to extract their contents (Rambam: Isurei Hamizbei'ach: 7:8-11 and Mahari Kurkus ad loc s.v. chazar). Needless to say, the olive oil you find in the grocery is not processed this way, even if the label does say 100% pure extra virgin olive oil," responded Rabbi Berger.

Interesting packages were a common sight in the Berger home. One day two parcels arrived from a place called Curious Creatures of the Deep. And just a few days later a huge box bearing a distinctive triple olive shaped logo arrived from Oliver's Olive Orchard.

"Yay! This must be the package of olives we've all been waiting for," squealed Shmuli with delight. "Tatty, please can I open the box? Maybe there's bubble wrap inside that I can pop?"

"Please bring the whole box to my study together with your brothers. Then you can open the box and throw all the olives into the funnel of the gadget I recently invented," requested Rabbi Berger of his children.

In the study, the Berger boys noticed a queer new addition to their father's already unique collection of gizmos and gadgets. They got to work putting the olives through the funny funnel. Baruch tracked the path of the olives as they wound their way through the mysterious maze.

"Yossi, look at Tatty's latest invention. I wonder why we need to pour the olives through this large funnel. The olives pass through this grate but you'll notice that the biggest ones don't make it through the holes, while the smaller olives go through a chute and land into this stone bowl," observed Baruch.

"What's this over here?" asked Yossi. It's the strangest looking basket I've ever seen. It has such bright colors, and its texture is so unusual. Even with Tatty being such a creative inventor, I've never seen such an odd looking thing before!"

"If I'm not mistaken these baskets are made of coral from the ocean!" commented Binyamin incredulously.

Rabbi Berger walked through the door of his study speaking softly but carrying a big stick.

"Let's start pounding the olives," he said ever so calmly.

"Hey, that stick is from the tree in our very own backyard," whispered the ever astute Baruch to Yossi.

Rabbi Berger made his way to the large funnel, and removed the grate holding the large olives. He put them aside. Then he raised the large stick and started pounding the olives that had gathered in the stone bowl. With the aid of a stone scooper he removed the smashed olives and put it into the coral baskets.

Is there an ideal way to make oil for the Mitzvah of Hadlokas Ner Chanukah?

The Berger boys gathered around their father's desk, eagerly waiting for an explanation of the weird scene they were witnessing.

"Aside for being pure in quality, the oil in the Beis Hamikdash needed to be tahor as well. I was motivated to reenact the exact way they would have gone about making oil for the Menorah in the times of the Beis Hamikdash. I had the bright idea that if the olive oil we use is both zuch and tahor, it would really enhance our Chanukah, like we say in the brachah 'bayumin haheim bazman hazeh."

"If an olive is the size of an egg, it is considered a food that can become tamei. If a liquid then touches, the food becomes susceptible to tumah. Therefore, if the olives are still the size of an egg even after being pounded, being that the oil is a liquid, it would make the olives susceptible to tumah (Rashi Shabbos 145a s. v. kibei'ah michuvenes tahor, Rash Taharos 3:3, Rambam Tumas Ochlin 9:2)."

"Now we solved the mystery of why the machine was equipped with a grate. It filtered out the olives that were larger than an egg so they shouldn't be able to become tamei even while being pounded," deduced Baruch the sleuth.

"What about the branch you used to pound the olives, Tatty. That seems like a funny tool to use," piped up Shmuli.

"An unformed stick is not considered a utensil and therefore cannot become tamei. The olives were pounded with an unformed stick to keep the olive oil from becoming tamei. Additionally great care must be taken not to touch the oil during or after squeezing the olives (Rash and Raav on Taharos 3:3, Aruch Hashulchon Ha'asid Tumas Ochlin 172:9)," explained Rabbi Berger to his attentive audience. "Stone or things that are from the ocean don't become tamei. Therefore I used only stone utensils and coral baskets throughout the process (Rambam Taharah: Keilim: 1:3, 6)."

"Now I know what was in the box from Curious Creatures of the Sea," said Baruch in a flash of inspiration. "It must have been coral."

"But what was in the second box from Curious Creatures of the Sea?" asked Boruch.

"Tatty, one last question please. When you put the precious pure oil into your menorah, won't that make the oil susceptible to tumah? What will have been the point of all your hard work?" noted a concerned Yehoshua.

"Indeed you make an excellent point. But I'm afraid you'll all have to wait for Chanukah to solve the riddle," answered Rabbi Berger, leaving everyone in suspense.

On Chanukah the whole family was astounded when Rabbi Berger solved the puzzle as he went about setting up his brand new whalebone menorah, which cannot become tamei, because it comes from the ocean (Rambam Taharah: Keilim: 1:3).

More in this printout

View the whole printout