We all know the phrase, “Two Jews, three opinions.” Nowhere is this more pronounced than in the study of Torah. The more one learns, the more one feels that there are indeed 70 faces to Torah, and they do not always seem to live in harmony. The deep reason for this is that the Giver of the Torah Himself is infinite and He alone creates peace and harmony, below as Above. Every word, every letter in the Torah reflects the infinite, not just in depth, but many times, in variety of interpretation. As the sages say, “’Behold, is My word not like fire, declares God, and like a hammer that shatters a rock?’ Just this hammer breaks [a stone] into fragments, so too, each and every utterance that emerged from the mouth of the Holy Blessed One divided into languages.”
The distance between these languages of interpretation, underscored by the global dispersion of the Jewish people has led some to argue that the only way to achieve unity and coherence is through uniformity. However, HaRav Ginsburgh has taken a different approach to the problem of unifying our understanding of Torah and our distinct customs: the method of constructing a partzuf (literally, a persona) that places the competing, sometimes contradictory interpretations in context of a larger scheme or model. We could write an entire book analyzing this method and the history of its use in Torah study, however, let us begin our journey into what might be a new landscape and somewhat foreign language for many by presenting an example.
We chose to revisit a partzuf we have presented here in the past because of its beautiful and clear message of unity. The Torah lists a limited number of kosher cattle, “This is the cattle that you may eat, ox, sheep and goat,” together with a list of seven kosher animals that may also be consumed, “the gazelle, the deer, the roebuck, the ibex, the antelope, the buffalo, and the giraffe.”
Since there are 10 animals in these two lists, it behooves us to draw a one-to-one correspondence between them and the ten sefirot. The three species of kosher cattle (ox, sheep, and goat) will naturally correspond to the first three sefirot, crown, wisdom, and understanding; the seven kosher animals will correspond to the seven sefirot of the heart—loving-kindness, might, beauty, victory, thanksgiving, foundation, and kingdom. But we want to focus on the kosher species of animal. We begin by observing that the sum of the values of their names as they appear in the Torah is 1568. But this number is 7 times 224, where the value of the word “path” is 224. We can take this as inspiration to argue that the seven kosher animals represent different paths, each unique and equally desirable, in the service of God. Our first step is to draw the correspondence between the 7 kosher animals and the 7 lower sefirot of the heart (we will not elaborate on this), and then we wish to identify one of the pure paths of Divine service in our generation with each of the 7 lower sefirot.
The final product is the following partzuf, or model:
- might-gevurah: deer (צְבִי) – Masters of Revealed Torah
- loving-kindness-chessed: gazelle (אַיָּל) – Wearers of White
- beauty-tiferet: roebuck (יַחְמוּר) – Chabad
- acknowledgment-hod: antelope (דִּישֹן) – Masters of Mussar
- victory-netzach: ibex (אַקּוֹ) – Torah of the Land of Israel
- foundation-yessod: buffalo (תְּאוֹ) – General Chasidut
- kingdom-malchut: giraffe (זָמֶר) – Breslov
The beauty of the Jewish people is in our variety, not in our uniformity. When every group and path recognizes that it is part of a mosaic that together form God’s firstborn son, it becomes easier to respect and embrace the roles that other groups and paths fulfill.