Skip to content
Parsha Pages Youth

Excitement in Halacha: Easy Prey

  • Balak
  • 5784
  • English
View printout

The Berger family decided to spend Sukkos in Eretz Yisroel, at the farm of their cousins, the Mizrachi's. In the morning, after Shacharis, the Mizrachis showed their cousins the new things in their home.

"What are these strange creatures in your fish tank?" Baruch asked curiously. "They look like huge bugs! I never saw such pets before!"

"They are praying mantises," replied Uncle Avraham Mizrachi. "I am breeding them, because they eat all sorts of bugs that destroy my crops. I also have a tank of ladybugs, which feed on the specific crop pest of aphids."

"Breakfast is ready!" announced Mrs. Mizrachi.

"When did you feed the bugs last?" asked Yehoshua.

"Why, what is the difference?" questioned Uncle Avraham Mizrachi.

"One is prohibited to eat until he feeds his animal," wondered Yehoshua.

"Are you prohibited to eat breakfast before feeding the praying mantises?"

"The general responsibility to feed your animal is because of tzaar baalei chaim. Perhaps the prohibition of tzaar baalei chaim applies to all animals, including these bugs?" added Yossi.

"Where do we learn tzaar baalei chaim from?" pondered Shmuli.

"The prohibition to pain an animal is learned from the Torah rule that one is to unload an animal that collapsed under its burden," explained Baruch.

"Beasts used to carry a load are those that are capable to work for man," expanded Rabbi Mizrachi. "Therefore only animals that are able to work for people is there a prohibition of tzaar baalei chaim. Even so, one should not be cruel to other animals out of midas chasidus. However, feeding your animal first seems not to be a Torah prohibition unless it is starving. Maybe we don't have to feed these bugs before we eat?"

"These bugs get rid of the bugs that destroy the crops," concluded Rabbi Berger. "They do work for Uncle Avraham as an insecticide, like a cat has a job to exterminate mice. Since they are capable of work, tzaar baalei chaim would apply to them."

"Also, feeding an animal because of tzaar baalei chaim applies to a domesticated animal that depends on the owner," added Yossi. "Since these creatures are caged, all agree we have to feed them."

"Okay, great!" decided Avraham Mizrachi. "I will feed my mantises some ladybugs."

"Wouldn't it be tzaar baalei chaim for the ladybugs to be given to the praying mantises for food?" questioned Binyamin.

"Since the ladybugs are being used as food for a bigger creature, it seems that there wouldn't be a prohibition of tzaar baalei chaim," replied Rabbi Berger. "Also you need your praying mantises more than the ladybugs, it therefore becomes a need of man, which overrides tzaar baalei chaim."

"Does a mantis make a bracha before it eats, just as it prays?" asked Goldy.

More in this printout

View the whole printout