Bzzz bzzz bzzz ... "Hello, Paul Petason! What can I do for you?" offered Rabbi Berger, as his fellow scientist called his cellphone.
"I have created a new invention which you might appreciate. Perhaps you would want to purchase it for your famous gorilla," responded Paul. "It is an electronic control system, which will wirelessly keep your gorilla in check. You will be able to program a path for your big pet. The machine makes the animal imagine that there are walls where there are none, and it will contain itself within them. The controls also have a feature that by the mere pressing of a button he will imagine that he is totally boxed in and will be completely restrained. Also, you can give your animal electronic treats which will cause him to imagine that he is eating food. Yet another button can be used to reprimand him. However, surgery would be needed to install it into the gorilla's brain. He would need to be under full body anesthesia for the initial installation, and would need 6 weeks to recover from the brain surgery. Get back to me if you are interested in my product."
During supper that night, Rabbi Berger shared the information about this new invention with his family.
"Can we do this surgery on Gedalya, maybe is it considered tzaar baalei chaim to have the animal in pain so long from its recovery?" asked Shmuli.
Points to Ponder
"Maybe it is regarded as pain that happens by itself, and is permitted," suggested Yossi.
"One is required to take away pain of his animal, even it happens by itself, either according to the Torah or mid'Rabbanan," replied Yehoshua. "Furthermore, when we would give Gedalya the surgery, we would be activating the pain."
"It is a small convenience for us and a large pain to the animal; maybe it is assur?" probed Baruch.
"Even though it is considered tzaar baalei chaim from the Torah, since it benefits humans it seems to be permitted," concluded Rabbi Berger.
"Why is that so?" asked Shmuli.
"An animal's purpose is to serve man," explained Rabbi Berger. "Gedalya becomes uplifted when he enables us to do mitzvos. This machine can control him, freeing us up to focus on more important things, like our learning."
Conclusion
"Hello Paul, I am seriously considering your product," Rabbi Berger called back.
"I'm glad to hear that," responded Mr. Petason. "By the way, we worked on it in a very humane way. It was experimented on people before it was tried on animals!"
1 The halachic concept in which we consider there to be invisible walls to be created - עי' סוכה ד: - עיין ספר צער בעלי חיים פרק יא חלק א סעיף ה' ו' ה' לסיכום 2 תרומת הדשן חלק ב סימן קה; שו"ת נודע ביהודה מהדורא תנינא 3 סימן י; ספר צער בעלי חיים פרק יב סעיף יב וזו 4 ספר צער בעלי חיים פרק יב סעיף א