Skip to content
Parsha Pages Youth

Excitement in Halacha: Scary Encounter

  • Balak
  • 5784
  • English
View printout

Every morning Gedalia Gorilla needed to be taken for a morning stroll.

"Mommy, I will take Gedalia for his daily walk," offered five year old Goldy, before school on a Wednesday morning.

She strutted down the street with the beast on his regular routine. Suddenly, when passing one neighbor's house, what looked like a life-sized lion jumped out of a gadget that was hanging from a tree. This scared the daylights out of Gedalia, and he started running. Goldy pressed the button on the on his leash which locked his feet and hands to his neck. Goldy left Gedalia, running home to call for help.

"Someone set up a trap to scare Gedalia!" Goldy yelled. "I need help."

The whole Berger family ran to the place of the crime.

"I see a string 8 feet high that must have triggered the trap," noticed Baruch. "This trap was intended purposely for Gedalia. I see the neighbors laughing from their window."

"Is it permitted to set up such a gadget that will automatically be triggered by the animal to be scared away?" pondered Yehoshua.

"Isn't emotional pain to an animal considered tzaar baalei chaim?"

"One is prohibited to hurt a fellow Jew's feelings, but this does not apply to animals," suggested Yossi.

"Hurting a fellow Jew's feelings is only with words of pain, but emotional pain we see is prohibited from the mitzvah of sheluach hakein, and from that one is not permitted to slaughter an animal and it's young on the same day," argued Baruch. "Animals have feelings, and we are to recognize that in order to train ourselves to have compassion on our fellow Jew."

"One cannot slaughter one animal in front of another, because they get frightened," added Binyamin. "One is not even allowed to do sheluach hakein by a treif bird to scare away the mother bird, because of tzaar ba'alei chaim."

"If emotional torture of an animal is needed to benefit man, then tzaar baalei chaim is permitted," suggested Binyamin. "Maybe the neighbors need their fun, and it would be permitted to use the machine to scare Gedalia."

"It seems that it is not considered the normal need of man to scare an animal just for fun," answered Yehoshua. "Yet the prohibition is mid'Rabbanon since this action does not danger the animal's life at all."

"Is only the action of scaring the animal away prohibited because of tzaar ba'alei chaim and Gedalia is just causing himself to get scared and is permitted, or the pain to the animal is what is prohibited and therefore the trap is prohibited to be set up altogether?" asked Baruch.

"According to those who learn that tzaar baalei chaim is learned from the rule of unloading an animal, you are to unload it even though you didn't cause the animal to be in pain," concluded Rabbi Berger. "Therefore, we see one is to elevate the animal's pain, even though he did not cause it. It seems the trap is prohibited to be set up to cause Gedalia to be scared."

Rabbi Berger took out his phone and called the parents of the boys who set up the gadget, and requested that they don't do any more such pranks because of tzaar baalei chaim.

More in this printout

View the whole printout