Aryeh Kaplan on Creation
Based on a post by Alan Brill
Aryeh Kaplan’s Handbook of Jewish Thought has become a classic of synthesizing the classic positions of Jewish thought into an order fashion both an introductory guide and simultaneously a reference book.
Following is a pdf of a full chapter of Aryeh Kaplan’s Handbook of Jewish Thought left out of the published work possibly because he presents evolution as part of the basic tenets of Judaism. Rabbi Kaplan is explicit in his affirmation of evolution in this piece. The already typeset chapter has an editor’s note across the top asking if the chapter is “fixable” and “true kosher”? There is also an editor’s note that dates the chapter to 1968.
The Handbook of Jewish Thought was published in two volumes, the first, containing 13 chapters, appeared in the author’s lifetime in 1979. The second volume edited by Avraham Sutton, was published posthumously in 1992. That volume has 25 chapters. While the first volume had no introduction from the author, the second volume contains the following statement:
The bulk of the present volume is from the author’s original 1967-1969 manuscript that consisted of 40 chapters. Thirteen of these chapters were prepared for publication by Rabbi Kaplan himself and published in 1979 as the Handbook of Jewish thought – Volume I. It is clear that the remaining chapters were set aside with the thought of eventually preparing them for publication. Of these remaining chapters, 25 are presented here.
Quick arithmetic – 13 (volume 1) and 25 (volume 2) indicates that 2 chapters of the original 40 not included. His chapter on Creation (and one other) were not included.
Creation - Overview
In the first three paragraphs, he states that the creation account in Genesis is not literal and not science but narrated to teach the history of Israel. He believes that new concepts in science are always being discovered beyond the limited science known in the Biblical and rabbinical era. We are, according to Rabbi Kaplan, to continuously interpret the Biblical text according to currently available knowledge.
Even though the explicit text is to narrate Israel’s history, nevertheless Rabbi Kaplan states that the scientific knowledge is hinted at in the Masoretic text through “subtle variations.” In addition, we have traditions that aid in our discovering the scientific truth in the text. Maimonides and other medieval interpreted the text based on Aristotle. Maimonides in his Guide II:29 explains how he would be willing to read texts based on current science; similarly, Ramchal in his commentary of the Aggadot.
Rabbi Kaplan consider the creation of the universe as billions of years ago when there was the initial creation as the creation of matter as well as the initial creation of time/space. The creation at the start of Genesis was billions of years ago according to Rabbi Kaplan, even if the Torah does not explicitly state it.
Rabbi Kaplan explains that G-d did not really verbalize in the creation of the world, rather G-d speaks means the impression of will upon matter thereby giving it a new property. G-d speech involves modulating creation to desired results. (There is already a sense here of Rabbi Kaplan’s later focus on mental acts – meditation). Rabbi Kaplan in his spiritualizing of the text successfully manages to be deeply Maimonidean and Nahmanidean at the same time. He can cite simultaneously Maimonides’ Guide of the Perplexed on how locutions such as “G-d spoke”, “G-d’s mouth” or “G-d spoke to Moses” are anthropomorphic and not to be taken literally. Simultaneously, Rabbi Kaplan appeals to Ramban 1:3 in that Divine will impressed upon the primordial matter of hiyuli, G-d is not literally speaking but engaged in the coming to be of the lower hypostatic element, which in turn will create the world. Rabbi Kaplan foreshadows his later thought and treats kabbalah in a non-literal manner.
Rabbi Kaplan further spiritualizes the process so the steps of creation did not happen at the stated time, just that the prerequisites for G-d’s goal was complete even though the actual goal would not manifest until later (15:8)
Rabbi Kaplan explains the phrase “it was good” to mean the completion of something essential for the evolution of the universe, destruction of prior worlds means evolution to something higher. The world is evolving to higher stages. The destruction of prior world does not mean there were prior worlds just that lower forms of this world. (15:9) (He cites Maharal Beer Hagolah 39b)
Days of Creation
What was the light created on the first day before the creation of planets? For Rabbi Kaplan the light on the first day is the electromagnetic force in matter responsible for all chemical and physical properties, without the electromagnetic force the world is chaos and void.
What was created on the second day? It was when G-d set the matter of the first day into Euclidean four-dimensional space-time matrix. (15:12).
On the third day, G-d created the gravitational force. The “gathering of the waters” is not about swamps and sea but the “warping of matter” and the creation of phenomena that follow non-Euclidian geometry. It was also the physio-chemical properties of matter needed for plant life, (15:13)
On the fourth day, G-d initiated the process by which matter would condense into galaxies, stars and planets,” which is the completion of inorganic matter.
On the fifth day, G-d started the process by which organic matter and life came to be.
On the important 6th day of creation, G-d created the evolutionary potential of higher mammals and primitive man. Nothing was actually created on the 6th day, rather the evolutionary potential of the development of higher mammals from lower mammals was designated. After the 6th day, G-d allows world to develop by itself – without intelligent design- solely through the natural evolution. Just as the geological evolution of crystals grow naturally over millions of years from natural processes, so too the evolution of animals is the same way. The unfolding properties for mammals and eventually man is in the natural order.
Man, known to paleontologists as later stages of homo sapiens, already had mental and physical capabilities about 25,000 years ago according to Rabbi Kaplan’s scheme. (In 1979, he extends this to 100,000 years ago). However, it was only 6,000 years ago that man was given a divine soul. This was a new level of wisdom and inventiveness to allow for cultural evolution through invention, metallurgy, animal husbandry, ship sailing (15:22). Rabbi Kaplan acknowledges that species change and that even man evolves as shown by his vestigial tail.
Hence, the six days of creation are as follows:
- Day 1: Electromagnetic force
- Day 2: 4-D space/time matrix
- Day 3: Warping of matter, beyond Euclidian space
- Day 4: Inorganic matter
- Day 5: Organic matter and life
- Day 6: Evolutionary potential of higher mammals and primitive man.
Rabbi Kaplan explains his own method of not treating the words literally, rather as allegories for scientific principles. Water, sky, and light are all allegorical terms for the unfolding of the scientific cosmos because the scientific terms were unknown in ancient times. (15:10) As he wrote earlier in the chapter, according to Ramban, these terms refer to divine unfolding of the cosmos not physical objects.
In many ways, Rabbi Kaplan approach to science is similar to Ramban’ concept of remez, in which scientific concepts are alluded to in the Torah. Both Rabbi Kaplan and Ramban read the allusions in the Torah to science, psychology, and powers of the soul.
Ramban in his introduction to the Torah wrote: “G-d informed Moses first of the manner of the creation of heaven and earth and all their hosts… together with an account of the four forces in the lower world, minerals, vegetation, animal, and the rational soul. With regard to all of these matters Moses our teacher was apprised, and all of it was written in the Torah, explicitly or by implication.”
FIFTEEN (15) CREATION
15:1 The Torah always speaks in the language of man. God worded the Torah so that it would be accessible to all people for all times.
15:2 Therefore, the account of creation and similar narratives are not written in modern scientific terminology. If God had written the Torah using current scientific terms, it would have been completely unintelligible to the shepherd thousands of years in the past, and primitive to the scientist thousands of years in the future. Furthermore, the account of creation was not written primarily as a scientific treatise, but to trace the history of Israel.
15:3 Knowing that much new knowledge would be discovered with the passing of time, God worded the Torah so that each generation would be able to interpret it according to their available knowledge. Many subtle variations in text as well as Talmudic and Midrashic traditions were provided as an aid in discovering the true meaning of the Torah. In medieval times, the Torah was interpreted in terms of Aristotelian philosophy, while in modern times it can be understood in terms of recent findings in physics, chemistry, biology, and psychology.
15:4 It is a foundation of our faith that God brought forth the universe from absolute nothingness, as the Torah states, "In the beginning God created heaven and earth" (Genesis 1:1).
15:5 The initial act described in the Torah refers to the creation of all matter along with space and time. Though the Torah does not state when this took place, there is overwhelming evidence from astronomy, geology, radioactive dating, and fossils, that this initial creation took place billions of years ago. There are some who would dismiss this scientific evidence, but it is inconceivable that God should mislead mankind by making His creation appear older than it truly is. Accordingly, the Torah states, "The deeds of the Mighty One are perfect, for all His ways are just. He is a faithful God, never unfair; righteous and moral is He" (Deuteronomy 32:4).
15:6 There are several rules which must be remembered if we are to understand the account of creation. The Torah uses three different words in describing creation: Bara, "to create," indicating the creation of something that previously had no existence; Yatzar, "to form," where something is formed from a previously existing material or concept; and Asah, "to make," indicating the completion of a concept. These three concepts are also alluded to when we speak of God's thought, speech, and action respectively, as well in the three parts of the soul.
15:7 Therefore, whenever the Torah uses the expression "God said," in the account of creation, it means that He impressed His will upon the matter He created, giving it some new property. Just as human speech modulates the air with sound waves, so does God's speech modulate all creation. Such expressions are usually given in terms of the ultimately desired result of the command.
15:8 Whenever the Torah uses the expression, "It was so," it means that all the prerequisites for God's desired goal were complete, although the goal itself would not manifest itself until a much later time.
15:9 Whenever the Torah states, "God saw that it was good," it refers to the completion of something essential for the evolution of the universe. Accordingly, we are taught that this expression means that God created worlds and destroyed them. Since it is inconceivable that an omniscient God would create something only to destroy it, this destruction of worlds refers to their being the basis for the next higher stage of creation.
15:10 Whenever the Torah states that God gave one of His creations a name, it indicates that the name was originally used allegorically and is borrowed from a more familiar term. In every case, the reference is to concepts that were completely unknown in ancient times.
15:11 The light created on the first day refers to the electromagnetic force in matter. It is this force that is responsible for all the chemical and gross physical properties of matter. Prior to its creation, therefore, matter is called "chaos and void" (Genesis 1:2). The Torah states that "Light came into existence," (Genesis 1:3) rather than "It was so," since the main effects of the electromagnetic force were immediately evident. Furthermore, since the electromagnetic properties of matter are the most important in implying the evolution of life, the Torah states, "God saw that the light was good" (Genesis 1:4). However, because there was no word for a pure electromagnetic field in ancient times, the Torah continues, "God named the light 'Day'" (Genesis 1:5), indicating that the word light is actually used for a broader concept. The division of light and creation of darkness refers to the interaction between matter and electromagnetism, which implies the absorption of light.
15:12 On the second day, God set the matter that He had created in a four-dimensional Euclidian space-time matrix, defined by matter itself. Since this completed the space-time continuum, the Torah states "God made the sky" (Genesis 1:7). This caused a sharp demarcation between the physical world and the spiritual, and accordingly, it is written, "It separated the water below the sky from the water above the sky" (ibid.) – "water" referring to all matter. Since the geometric properties of the universe were to develop with the distribution of matter, the Torah now says, "It was so" (ibid.). Still, because the interaction between space and matter was not completed until the creation of the gravitational force, the expression "It was good" is omitted on the second day. The word rakiyah ("sky" or "firmament") is used since there was no word for an abstract space-time continuum in ancient times. The Torah thus states that, "God named the sky 'Heaven'" (Genesis 1:8).
15:13 On the third day, God created the gravitational force which would result in the condensation of matter, and accordingly it is referred to in the Torah as the gathering of waters. Thus, we are taught that this involved a warping of space-time in a non-Euclidian geometry necessary for gravity to exist. Since "water" as used in this and previous passages refers to all matter, which was then in a fluid state, rather than water alone, the Torah tells us that, "He named... the gatherings of water 'Seas'" (Genesis 1:10).
15:14 Also completed on the third day, were the physio-chemical properties of matter necessary for the existence of plant life. Since the stars and planets had not yet been formed, plant life itself was not to come into existence until a much later period.
15:15 On the fourth day, God initiated the process by which matter would condense into galaxies, stars and planets. Since this marks the completion of the inorganic universe, the Torah states, "God made... the stars" (Genesis 1:16).
15:16 On the fifth day, God initiated the process that would eventually result in animal life. Accordingly, we are taught that God made a "picture" in the water with the ability to reproduce itself. The Torah states, "God created the great sea monsters..." (Genesis 1:21), since this was an entirely new concept, not necessarily implied by the readiness of inorganic matter to produce plant life. However, since this act was not completed until the sixth day, the expression "It was so" is omitted here.
15:17 On the sixth day, God refined the evolutionary potential so as to include higher mammals, and eventually primitive man. Since this completed the evolutionary potential, the Torah states, "God made particular species of beasts of the earth" (Genesis 1:25).
15:18 On the fifth and sixth days respectively, the Torah states, "God said, 'The water shall teem with swarms of living creatures,'" (Genesis 1:20), and "God said, 'The earth shall bring forth particular species of living creatures'" (Genesis 1:24). This indicates that God did not actually create life at this time, but merely imparted in matter the unique properties that would make the evolution of lower, and eventually higher, forms of animal life inevitable.
15:19 On the sixth day, God also created the principle in matter whereby when a degree of complexity such as is found in the human brain is reached, it should be able to act as a receptacle for the soul which makes man unique among all other creatures. Since this principle exists in all matter, we are taught that the creation of man filled the entire universe. Since such a synthesis of the material and spiritual was an entirely new concept, the Torah states, "God created man" (Genesis 1:27).
15:20 After the six days of creation, God allowed the universe to develop by itself, as the Torah states, "He ceased on the seventh day from all the work He had been doing" (Genesis 2:2). All the laws of nature and properties of matter were fixed for all times, as we find, "He has established them forever; He made a decree which shall not be transgressed" (Psalms 148:6). It is similarly written, "Whatever God decrees shall be forever; nothing shall be added to it, and nothing shall be taken away" (Ecclesiastes 3:14).
15:21 However, God created the initial matter of the universe with such properties that would assure its development according to His plans, as the Torah states, "God ceased from all the work which He had created – to complete" (Genesis 2:3). Accordingly, each thing came forth in its time as planned, and the universe developed, evolving stars and planets, geological formations, and eventually life itself. Just as the properties of matter cause a symmetric crystal to grow, so the laws of nature that God had implanted in His world made the evolution of lower animals, and eventually man inevitable in the course of time.
15:22 About twenty-five thousand years ago, man had developed all the physical and mental capacities that we possess today. Man had been formed out of "the dust of the earth" (Genesis 2:7), but he still lacked the divine soul that would make him a spiritual being. God then created Adam, the first true human being, "and He blew into his nostrils a soul of life" (ibid.). This Adam was destined to be the father of all human civilization.
15:23 According to tradition, the creation of Adam took place almost six thousand years ago on Rosh HaShanah, September 9, 3761 b.c.e.
15:24 God gave Adam and his descendants the gifts of great wisdom and inventiveness. Accordingly, historians find an almost miraculous flowering following the creation of Adam, with the conditions of human existence changing more radically then they had over the preceding quarter of a million years. During Adam's lifetime, we find some of the most creative periods in history, marking the invention of weaving, metallurgy, draft animals and the plow, the wheel, both for transportation and pottery, bricks, sail craft, as well as the concept of private property. These initial developments may have been rudimentary, but they were the foundation stones upon which the structure of civilization would rise.
Notes to Chapter 15
- See Volume 1, 7:77, notes 186 and 187.
- Bereshith Rabbah 1:3; Yalkut Shimoni 2:809; Zohar 2:39b; Rashi, Ramban, on Genesis 1:1.
- Cf. Moreh Nevukhim 2:29; Zohar 2:15b.
- Ramban ad. loc.; Thirteen Principles of Faith 1; Yad, Teshuvah 3:7; Raavad ad. loc.; Emunoth VeDeyoth 1:1 (28b), 5:8 (74a); Kuzari 1:67 (41a). Cf. Bereshith Rabbah 1:12.
- Bereshith Rabbah 1:19, 12:10; Yalkut Shimoni 1:3; Rashi on Genesis 1:14, 1:24, 2:4; Moreh Nevukhim 2:30; Ramban on Genesis 1:1, 1:8, 1:24.
- See Volume 1, 2:1-2.
- The traditional date of creation as 3761 b.c.e. refers to the creation of Adam rather than that of the universe (see below 15:23). Since it is usually assumed that the creation of man on the sixth day is identical to that of Adam in Genesis 2:7 (cf. Thirty Two Middoth of R. Eliezer ben R. Yosi HaGelili no. 13; Rashi on Genesis 1:27), this date is also accepted as the birth of all creation. However, in Berakhoth 61b; Eruvin 18a, we find that R. Avahu counts the creation of Adam on the sixth day as a creation in thought alone. Bereshith Rabbah 12:14, that creation in thought was by day and night, an entire creation in thought (see below...). Since this refers to the establishment of the properties of matter (see below...), we can interpret the entire six days of creation accordingly. This may also be the opinion of R. Shimon, Bereshith Rabbah 12:14, that creation in thought was by day and night, with the actual deed taking place much later. According to this we can also understand Rashi on Genesis 1:1, that God thought to create the universe with the attribute of justice, although the name Elokim is used throughout the seven days of creation. Similarly, we find in Bereshith Rabbah 12:2; Shemoth Rabbah 30:2, that all events prior to Genesis 2:4 are considered chaos and void. See also Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer 5 (12b), that God prepared a table for His creation in thought. See also Radal ad. loc. 23. See also Moreh Nevukhim 2:25; Kuzari 1:67 (42a), that the interpretation regarding the time of creation is not essential to our faith, but see Kuzari 1:61 (38a).
- Which we observe billions of light years away.
- See below...
- And since we believe that nature does not change (see below...), we must accept this as a reliable method.
- Although fossils have been traditionally ascribed to the flood; cf. Radal (on Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer) 23:10 (note 5), 23:26; Zohar 1:62a; Rash, Zevachim 113a s.v. Retzoni Lomar. In Bereshith Rabbah 28:3, we find that no remains were left of those killed in the flood. Furthermore, radioactive dating proves many fossils to be millions of years old.
- In Sanhedrin 97a we find a tradition that the world will last for 6000 years. From Psalms 90:4 we see that each of God's days is 1000 years. From Isaiah 63:4 we see that we can count years made out of God's days; cf. Rashi, Sanhedrin 99a s.v. Rabbi. Accordingly, each of God's years is 365,242 of ours, and the 6000 year period, counted from the beginning of life, is 2,191,440,000 of our years, in remarkable agreement with the scientifically accepted figure. Of course, a simpler explanation would be to count these 6000 years from the creation of Adam (see below...).
- Tana DeBei Eliahu Zuta 3 (6a); Yalkut Shimoni 1:942; Moreh Nevukhim 2:28 (end).
- Radak on Isaiah 43:7; Nefesh HaChaim 1:13 in Hagah s.v. U'LeFi.
- Moreh Nevukhim 1:65.
- Rashi, Ramban, on Genesis 1:7.
- Tikuney Zohar (22) 67b, quoted in Reshith Chokhmah 133c.
- Ibid.; Nefesh HaChaim 1:14. See below...
- Targum Onkelos on the account of creation; cf. Avoth 6:1; Avoth DeRabbi Nathan 31:2; Rosh HaShanah 32a; Megillah 21b; Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer 3 (8b); Radal ad. loc. 3:73; Bereshith Rabbah 17:1; Zohar 3:11a.
- See previous paragraph that speech corresponds to something forming from a previously existing concept. For other interpretations, see Ibn Ezra, Ramban, on Genesis 1:3; Moreh Nevukhim 1:66; Kuzari 4:25 (44a).
- Genesis 1:7, 1:9, 1:11, 1:15, 1:24, 1:30.
- Ramban on Genesis 1:3. This may be related to the discussion between R. Yehudah and R. Nehemiah in Yalkut Shimoni 1:6 (end).
- Genesis 1:4, 1:10, 1:12, 1:18, 1:21, 1:25, 1:31.
- Bereshith Rabbah 4:8; Rashi on Genesis 1:7.
- See below...
- Bereshith Rabbah 3:9, 9:2; Koheleth Rabbah 3:13; Midrash Tehillim 34:1; Zohar 1:24b, 1:154b, 1:252b, 1:261a, 3:292b; Tikuney Zohar 2:12b.
- Zohar 1:24b.
- Maharal, Beer HaGolah 39b; cf. Shabbath 89b; Shemoth Rabbah 2:6.
- Genesis 1:5, 1:8, 1:10.
- Cf. Ramban ad. loc.; Moreh Nevukhim 2:30.
- Cf. Ramban ad. loc.; Isaiah 34:11; Chagigah 12a.
- Ramban ad. loc.
- Genesis 1:3.
- Genesis 1:4; Rashi ad. loc.
- Genesis 1:5; Ramban ad. loc.; Bereshith Rabbah 1:12; Chagigah 12a; Maharatz Chajes ad. loc.; Moreh Nevukhim 2:30; Ramban, Abarbanel, on Genesis 1:2.
- Bereshith Rabbah 4:1; Ramban on Genesis 1:8, that the "water" spread, forming the sky.
- Genesis 1:7. Cf. Bereshith Rabbah 4:7.
- Cf. Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer 4 (9a), from Ezekiel 1:22; Ramban loc. cit., that the sky demarcates the spiritual world.
- See below...
- See above, note 24.
- Genesis 1:8; cf. Chagigah 12a; Bereshith Rabbah 4:9. Also see Moreh Nevukhim 2:30.
- Genesis 1:9.
- Where a small space can hold much; Bereshith Rabbah 5:6; VaYikra Rabbah 10:9; Tanchuma 5; cf. Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer 5 (11b).
- According to general relativity.
- Cf. Bereshith Rabbah 4:1, 5:2; Shemoth Rabbah 15:22; Midrash Tehillim 19:1; Yalkut Shimoni 5:1; Shir HaShirim Rabbah 2:1 (8b); Mekhilta to Exodus 15:11 (41b).
- Genesis 1:16; Chagigah 2:1 (10b); Bereshith Rabbah 10:5, 12:4.
- Ibn Ezra on Genesis 1:11.
- Chullin 60b; Bereshith Rabbah 13:1; Rashi, Ramban, on Genesis 2:5. Cf. Sifri to Deuteronomy 11:14.
- See note 46.
- Rashi, Ramban, on Genesis 1:14, from Chagigah 12a. According to our interpretation, the statement in Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer 5 (12a) that the luminaries were not created until the fourth day now becomes intelligible, and we do not need the correction of Radal ad. loc. 5:14.
- Genesis 1:21.
- Bereshith Rabbah 7:1; Mekhilta to Exodus 15:11 (42a); Yalkut Shimoni 2:835.
- Genesis 1:22; Tehillim 86:3; Yalkut Shimoni loc. cit.
- Cf. Ramban, Sforno, on HaChaim ad. loc.
- Genesis 1:24, 1:25.
- Cf. Bereshith Rabbah 7:7; Tanchuma, Tazria 1; Midrash Tehillim 139:5.
- Cf. Or HaChaim ad. loc. However, Rashi ad. loc. interprets this to mean that they were created in their adult state; cf. Rosh HaShanah 11a. See below...
- Cf. Rashi ad. loc.
- See Volume 1, 1:4.
- Bereshith Rabbah 8:1; VaYikra Rabbah 14:1; Midrash Tehillim 139:5; Yalkut Shimoni 2:887, from Psalms 139:5; cf. Chagigah 12a; Sefer Chasidim 500. From the Midrash, it appears that those who follow this opinion disagree with Genesis 2:7 (cf. Thirty Two Middoth of R. Eliezer ben R. Yosi HaGelili no. 13). Others say that this was known to the ancient Greeks. R. Avahu, who also disputes R. Yeremiyahu ibid., maintains that this creation was in thought alone. In Bereshith Rabbah 8:1, we find that Adam was created with a tail, cf. Bereshith Rabbah 14:12, which might indicate that he had a tradition regarding man's evolution from primates. See also Bereshith Rabbah 8:3, that God took counsel with the souls of the righteous.
- Cf. Bereshith Rabbah 8:11; Rashi on Genesis 2:7.
- Man is therefore called creation in thought; see above 15:6, note 17.
- Moreh Nevukhim 2:28. Cf. Midrash Ne'elam, Zohar 1:138b; Avodah Zarah 54b; Berakhoth 60a.
- Ibn Ezra on Ecclesiastes, ad. loc.; Moreh Nevukhim 2:28; Iggereth Techiyath HaMethim, p. 15. Regarding conservation of matter, see Emunoth VeDeyoth 7:1 (86a).
- Or, "which He had created so that it would continue to function"; cf. Rashi ad. loc. (from Bereshith Rabbah 11:9). Ramban ad. loc., "which He had made," refers to the completion of creation that was now to take place; see also note 22.
- Cf. Bereshith Rabbah 12:3; Moreh Nevukhim 2:30. See also Bereshith Rabbah 12:7.
- Cf. Yerushalmi, Niddah 3:2 (10a), that mountains were not included in the initial creation; Maharatz Chajes, Niddah 23a. Although we find mountains mentioned in the account of creation, cf. Yalkut Shimoni 1:3; Rashi on Genesis 1:9; Chagigah 12a; Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer 3 (7a); Bereshith Rabbah 11:10. See also Moreh Nevukhim 2:30.
- On the basis of the statement that all creatures were created fully developed (Rosh HaShanah 11a; Chullin 60a; Moreh Nevukhim 2:30), many reject the possibility of evolution. However, this clearly disagrees with the opinion of Rashi, Chullin 60b (see above 15:14), that the plants did not grow immediately; cf. Iyun Yaakov (on Eruvin) 26 ad. loc. Therefore, in his commentary to Genesis 2:5, Rashi utilizes this concept only for animals, deriving it from a different passage than the Talmud. However, see note 57 that this is not a universal opinion.
- Some reject this concept, asserting that all species created by God cannot be changed. However, we find numerous opinions that environment can change species; cf. Kilayim 1:6; Sifra on Leviticus 26:6; Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer 23:10; and according to traditional interpretations, such a concept is necessary if we are to explain the different races of man; cf. note 70.
- This may be the source of the traditions that man originally had a tail; cf. Berakhoth 61b; Eruvin 18a; Bereshith Rabbah 14:12.
- Regarding the existence of creatures that were worthy of having human souls; cf. Chagigah 13b (end), from Psalm 105:8; Tosa-foth ad. loc. s.v. Zo; Sefer Chasidim 500; Radal on Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer 28:4; Koheleth Rabbah 1:37, 4:4; Tanchuma, Yithro 9; Midrash Tehillim 105:3; Tana DeBei Eliahu Rabbah 13 (70a), 72a, 26 (103a); Tana DeBei Eliahu Zuta 10 (17a); Yalkut Shimoni 2:863; Sefer Chasidim 1137. Counting approximately twenty years for a generation, we find this happening approximately 20,000 years before Adam, or 25,000 years ago.
- Formed from the dust; cf. Bereshith Rabbah 14:3, 4, 10; Ramban on Genesis 1:20. See below...
- Moreh Nevukhim 3:50; Kuzari 1:43 (32a).
- Pesikta 23 (150b); Yalkut Shimoni 1:782; Rosh HaShanah 10b; Maharsha, Rashash, ad. loc.; Yerushalmi, Avodah Zarah 1:23 (3a); VaYikra Rabbah 29:1; Pirkey Rabbi Eliezer 8 (18a); Tosafoth, Rosh HaShanah 8a s.v. LeTekufoth; Ran, Rosh HaShanah (Rif 3a) s.v. BeRosh; Tosefoth Yom Tov, Rosh HaShanah 1:2 s.v. Berosh; Rokeach 200.
- Cf. Rashi, Sanhedrin 97a s.v. BeAlephim; Yad, Kiddush HaChodesh 11:16; Avodah Zarah 8a.
- Bereshith Rabbah 24:7; Kuzari 1:95 (59b).
- Cf. Genesis 3:7.
- Cf. Genesis 4:22.
- Cf. Genesis 4:20.