But if the level of Adam was so great, and the Creator of the world was revealed to him, what choice did he have? Can one who physically sees the reality of the Creator choose a path other than holiness?
The answer is straightforward, and will be expounded on further: Adam certainly had a choice, even before the sin. It was only that the choice he had was fundamentally different from the power of choice that we are familiar with.
Conquering the Inner Self
The Michtav M'Eliyahu continues and explains:
When G-d created the world, He created two separate camps, one camp of the forces of holiness, and the other camp of the forces of impurity.
Each camp had its own territory, and they did not enter into each other's domain.
When G-d created Adam, He created him entirely righteous, composed only of the forces of holiness alone, and all his actions were straight, holy, and purified, completely good without any mixture or inclination towards the opposite at all.
However, surrounding him, stood forces of impurity, casting their eyes towards him and thinking: we must subdue him.
The choice Adam had was either to continue and fortify himself within his inner, exalted, and holy world or to exit his inner world and 'visit' the camps of impurity.
When the time came, and the signal was given, the war began.
The forces of impurity enclothed themselves in the serpent, and approached Adam whispering enticements: you must eat from the tree, you are compelled to taste, hey, it's worth listening to me.
The echo reverberated within his heart: I don't want to sin, I don't want to eat, but the war was terribly fierce. The forces of impurity threw fireballs, burning coals, boiling lava and liquid fire.
Impurity continued to circle around, drawing forth thick ropes, red hot blazing threads, and a hellfire.
The air was squeezed from his lungs, his vision blurred, and the utter confusion of senses was just a short time away.
Adam lost the battle and ate from the Tree of Knowledge.
At that moment, irreversible damage occurred; the forces of impurity managed to penetrate into his heart and the hearts of his descendants and settle there.
From that point and on, the entire battle changed.
From then on, when the evil inclination wants to tempt a person to sin, it immediately surfaces within their heart, saying: I want to sin. I want to speak lashon hara (evil speech), I want to defile my eyes with impure sights.
An echo is then heard within their heart: You're starting to lose, and if you do actually sin, you will lose all your holiness.
In the words of the Michtav M'Eliyahu:
"Ever since the sin of the tree of knowledge, the voice of the evil inclination is heard within the person saying in the first person tense: 'I' want, and 'I' desire.
Whereas the good inclination speaks to us in the tense of second person: 'You' are obligated, it is forbidden 'for you'.
Meaning, the intellect and moral compass (the good inclination) demand from us the good and the right, while initially, our desire identifies with the temptation.
This was not so with Adam, for "G-d made man upright" (Ecclesiastes 7:29), he naturally did what was proper to do.
His desire and will were directed only towards doing good and the right.
The evil was outside of him, hence the serpent had to come 'from outside' to tempt him."