Skip to content
BET Journal

Does a Shul or Beis Medrash Need a Mezuzah?

  • Korach
  • 5783
  • English
View printout

The Shulchan Aruch states clearly that, just as the Beis Hamikdash was exempt from mezuzah, a shul – a miniature Beis Hamikdash – is also exempt from mezuzah.

However, when it comes to a beis medrash, there is a machlokes. The Rambam and Tosfos are of the opinion that the same exemption applies to a beis medrash. However, the Mordechai argues and maintains that a beis medrash is required to have a mezuzah. The Shulchan Aruch quotes both opinions and rules that, since it is a machlokes, one should put on a mezuzah, albeit without a brocha.

REASONS TO REQUIRE MEZUZAH IN A BEIS MEDRASH

Why should the exemption apply to a beis medrash? There are two reasons given by the Rishonim. The Rambam writes that a beis medrash is the halachic equivalent of a shul, which is exempt because it is not considered a house that is used for ordinary matters. This is learned from the word beis’echah – which means that a mezuzah is only required on your house, and not on ‘Hashem’s’ house. Both a shul and a beis medrash are considered Hashem’s house, and are exempt. In fact, since Torah has more kedusha than tefllah, a beis Medrash designated for Torah study may be more holy than a shul.

Tosfos explains the exemption of a shul in a different way. Tosfos writes that, in order to be required in mezuzah, it must be one’s own personal home. But a shul or a beis medrash are not privately owned and are not required to have a mezuzah.

The nafka mina (halachic difference) between the Rambam’s understanding – that any place of learning or davening is exempt – and the understanding of Tosfos – that it has to be privately owned – would be in a case of a private shteibel. Although it is used for learning and davening, it is still privately owned. Therefore, according to the Rambam it will be exempt, since it is a place of learning or davening, but according to Tosfos it will require a mezuzah, since it is privately owned.

As mentioned, the Mordechai and other Rishonim argue. They rule that a beis medrash is required to have a mezuzua. The poskim explain that a beis medrash is different than a shul. A shul is used for davening (and sometimes a short shiur between mincha and maariv) and is therefore subject to the aforementioned principles. But a beis medrash is used throughout the day and is therefore similar to a house, and is required to have a mezuzah.

It would be nice to end this discussion with a fascinating account of the Tur about the Maharam Rottenberg, rebbi of his father, the Rosh. In his early years, the Maharam maintained that it was unnecessary to put a mezuzah on a beis medrash, and he did not have one in his beis medrash. However, after being disturbed by ‘evil spirits’ while taking an afternoon nap, he put on mezuzos.

IN SUMMARY

A shul is definitely exempt from mezuzah. However, when it comes to a beis medrash, there is a machlokes. The Shulchan Aruch quotes both opinions and rules that one should put on a mezuzah, without a brocha.

More in this printout

View the whole printout