Skip to content
BET Journal

Why Children Rebel

  • Korach
  • 5783
  • English
View printout

The Argument Between Moses and G-d Part II of III

This is not enough. For the law to be applied, the Talmud states, both parents need to have identical voices, a similar appearance and profess equal height [4]. Since it is virtually impossible to have all of these conditions in place (unless the father and mother were twin siblings, which would prohibit them from marrying each other anyhow[5]), this particular Torah law could never be applied in the real word.

Why then was it written? The sages answer (3), ‘So that we should expound the law and receive reward.’ What the Talmud seems to be suggesting is that expounding this law in depth will be rewarding for parents; it would enrich parenting and educational skills.

Indeed, when we focus on these verses, we can deduce extensive psychological, emotional and practical guidance on the goals and methods of a moral education. Today, I wish to focus on one aspect.

How many voices in your home?

As usual in biblical study, a discrepancy in the text intimates deeper meanings. This text too, contains such a discrepancy.

‘If a man has a stubborn and rebellious son who does not obey the voice of his father and the voice of his mother,’ is how the case is introduced in the Bible. His parents are described as having two distinct voices: ‘the voice of his father and the voice of his mother.’ Yet later on, when the parents bring their son to court to mete out the penalty, we encounter a slight, but meaningful, variance: ‘They shall say to the elders, ‘This son of ours is stubborn and rebellious. He does not obey our voice.’ No more ‘the voice of his father and the voice of his mother.’ Now it has become ‘our voice.’ Their distinct voices merged into one.

What is the meaning behind this subtle textual change? The message, it has been suggested[6], is critical in education. The phrase ‘If a man has a stubborn and rebellious son who does not obey the voice of his father and the voice of his mother,’ hints to one possible reason for this son becoming stubborn and rebellious. In his home there was not one voice, but two distinct and dichotomized voices. The voice of the father was not the voice of the mother. Each of them went his or her own way. The parents never managed to merge their distinct ‘voices’ to create a unified and integrated vision for themselves and their children. Each of the parents was pulling the home in a different direction, and the poor children were left stuck in the middle, torn by the discord of people they love so dearly.

And if this were indeed the case, this child is not rebellious and stubborn at all. He is a victim of his parents’ stubborn refusal to work on their emotions and discover peace in their fragmented home. The child need not suffer the consequences for his parents unreadiness to confront their egos and their demons, and build an ambiance of mutual respect and harmony. They may or may not have good reasons for their strife, but the child ought not to be blamed for responding to their wars with stubbornness and rebelliousness. What else do you expect of him?

Concludes next week

More in this printout

View the whole printout