By Rabbi Shmuel Neft
On the morning of September 11, 2001, a last-minute change to his schedule put Rabbi Jacob Goldstein in a Brooklyn office instead of wherever he was supposed to be.
Goldstein is a Chabad rabbi and was then a chaplain and a colonel in the New York Army National Guard.
He was standing there when the second aircraft hit the South Tower, and he watched it happen through the window.
He called military headquarters, collected his chaplain assistant and his equipment, and reported for duty. He ended up coordinating twelve chaplain teams at the site.
He would stay at Ground Zero for roughly four and a half months.
People later called him the Chief Chaplain of Ground Zero, though that title covered the military chaplains, not every clergyman working the pile.
He arrived into fires that were still burning and ash that coated everything standing.
Within days he understood what he was walking through. The dust settling on his boots at the end of each shift was not only concrete and gypsum and pulverized office furniture. Some of it was people.
So he stopped polishing his boots.
They stayed grey to the laces for the rest of the assignment, and he left them that way on purpose.
He intended to bury them when his work at the site was finished, the way you bury anything that carries human remains.
People kept coming to him with one question, asked a hundred different ways, about how G-d could allow this.
He did not pretend to have the answer, and he said so. What he offered instead was whatever the person standing in front of him needed in that moment.
His words for the work: "essentially, my job is hope."
Rosh Hashanah arrived less than a week after the attacks. The recovery site ran twenty-four hours a day, and the noise never stopped, cranes and generators and cutting torches grinding through the rubble without a pause.
Rabbi Goldstein got the machinery near him shut down long enough to blow shofar.
After that many days of continuous sound, what people noticed first was the silence.
A woman volunteering at the site walked over to hear him blow. She stood through the tekios and she cried. Then she stopped crying, collected herself, and went back to work.
Photographs from those days show him praying and sounding the shofar with the wrecked frames of the World Trade Center standing behind him.
He arranged permission for a small group from the family of Abraham Zelmanowitz, killed in the towers, to come close to the restricted site at night to pray.
As the family walked in, the responders working the pile took off their helmets and held them against their chests. The family said Kaddish, the Jewish mourners' prayer, in the ruins.
That was the night, he said, when everything he had been carrying finally came out of him.
Sukkot came four days after Yom Kippur, and a sukkah built on the ground would have sat in the way of a recovery operation that shifted every hour.
So Goldstein had Army engineers build one on the back of a two and a half ton truck. When the work moved, the sukkah moved with it.
They fed people in it, and Jewish soldiers and workers had somewhere to sit and make a bracha.
Nobody at Ground Zero was waiting for a theological explanation. They were standing inside the question, and Rabbi Goldstein knew that no answer he gave was going to hold up against what was in front of them.
So he brought a shofar. He brought a sukkah on a truck. He brought a minyan into the ruins at night so a family could say Kaddish, and he wore boots he would not clean because of what was in the dust.
That is the job. When you cannot explain the darkness, you carry in the light.