Skip to content
Parsha Pages

THE RINGS!

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

THE RINGS!

"לולב מצוה לאגדו" "It is a mitzvah to bundle the lulav with the hadassim and aravos." (Sukkah 33a)

QUESTION:

How many rings ("kneplach") should be placed on the lulav and why?

ANSWER:

The Shulchan Aruch Harav (O.Ch. 651:11) writes “It is customary to make three bindings (rings) on the lulav, corresponding to the three Patriarchs; i.e., in addition to the binding (ring) which holds the three species together, because the Torah (Shemos 15:2) states ‘This is my G-d and I shall beautify him. Two additional bindings (rings) are made to bind the lulav leaves to the spine."

QUESTION:

Is it necessary to use lulav leaves to make the rings? Are other items (string, rubber band, etc) considered a Chaltzizta (separation)?

ANSWER:

According to halacha, other materials used to bind the lulav are not considered a chatzitza, since it is done for the beauty of the mitzva. Nevertheless, the custom is to use lulav leaves.

QUESTION:

But don't we make three rings just for binding the species together (plus another two on the lulav — a total of 5 bindings)?

ANSWER:

The three rings for binding the species are all made within a tefach handbreadth. Thus, we apply the rule of lavud attached — so the three rings are considered as one. The two inside rings that support the Lulav are usually hidden from view by the Hadassim and Arovos.

QUESTION:

But why do we make what appears as five rings but which halachically is counted as three?

ANSWER:

It says in Pirkei Avos (3:6) “From where do we learn that the Divine Presence rests among five that occupy themselves with Torah? For it is said ‘vaʼagudato al eretz yesadah — He has founded His band upon the earth' ” (Amos 5:6). According to another version, this pasuk is proof that the Divine Presence is with three who are occupied in Torah. Because three is considered agudah – banding together (see Bartenura).

In deference to the opinions whether an agudah – binding together – is three or five, we make five rings which are considered as three, corresponding to the three Avos.

(שו"ע סי' תרנ"א סעי' א' ט"ז, חיים וברכה לבעמ"ח ספר משמרת שלום על פמ"ג סי' רפ"ח)

QUESTION:

Why is it a custom to remove the two inside rings on Hoshana Rabbah?

ANSWER:

Shulchan Aruch (O.Ch.664:1) writes that it is the custom to "untie the binding of the lulav". Bach writes, in the name of Mordechai (quoted in Be'er Hagolah, Ibid), that the source for this custom is the fact that this day is the time that the final seal is placed on the year's judgment. Shaking the lulav in all directions is intended to "stop bad dew and bad winds". This need intensifies as the final sealing approaches. We need to shake with greater intensity. Removing the rings facilitates enhanced shaking. According to the Levush, unfettered shaking is a greater sign of simcha, enabling us to show our joy on this special day.

QUESTION:

When should the lulav rings be removed?

ANSWER:

This should certainly take place before shaking during hallel. Chazon Ish (and others) used to remove the rings after making the brocho over the arba minim. Chasam Sofer already took them off the previous night. Chabad custom is to remove prior to Hallel.

QUESTION:

Does a wedding ring constitute a chatzitza when waiving the Lulav?

ANSWER:

The Gemara (Sukkos 37a) discusses large barriers that fully block the Netila, such as a Lulav encased in a container or a person wearing gloves while taking the Lulav. The Rama and the Vilna Gaon debate the question of small barriers such as rings, Tefillin and Band-Aids. The Rama (O.Ch. 551:7) records that although the practice is to remove Tefillin and rings before taking the Lulav, this is not necessary because the Tefillin and rings cover only a small portion of the hand. The Vilna Gaon and the Aruch haShulchan (O.Ch. 551:20) rule that the removal of Tefillin and rings before Netilat Lulav is not merely a custom, but a required act.

Interestingly, the Rama indicates that it was common for men to wear rings. Indeed, Rav Chaim David Halevi, z"l, (the Chief Rabbi of Tel Aviv who recently passed away) cites other sources that demonstrate that it was common for men to wear rings. Rav Halevi thus concludes (Teshuvos Aseh Lecha Rav 5:94) that there is no Halachic objection to a man wearing a wedding band. However, Rav Moshe Feinstein (Teshuvos Igros Moshe Even Haezer 4:32:2) writes that although it is not forbidden, it might be inappropriate for a G-d-fearing individual to wear a wedding ring. Presumably, this is because it mimics the practice of married women to wear a wedding ring.

More in this printout

View the whole printout