In the first two sections of the ma’amar the Rebbe explained the following points:
The deeper meaning of the possuk “many waters cannot extinguish the love, nor can rivers wash it away” is that a Jew’s worries about (and preoccupation with) his parnossa and other material matters cannot eliminate the love for Hashem which is hidden within him.
If a Jew is worried about and preoccupied with his parnossa, this shows that he is overly involved in earning a parnossa. A Jew should only earn a living through the “work of his hands,” which is limited to the physical and mental effort which is required to perform his necessary tasks.
When a Jew overly invests himself in his parnossa, he can become overly “into” his work, or could look for ways to “beat the system” to increase his parnossa. This problem is caused by his lack of the awareness that his parnossa comes directly from Hashem, and not from the work itself.
This is why the possuk needs to clarify that “many waters cannot extinguish the love”: Even if a Jew doesn’t (yet) have the correct perspective, and has already become overly mentally and emotionally invested in making a parnossa, these worries cannot extinguish his soul’s love for Hashem.
The reason we would think that worries about parnossa could extinguish the G-dly soul’s love for Hashem is because worries about physical things have their source the higher world of Tohu, while the source of the G-dly soul’s love for Hashem is the lower world of Tikkun. Therefore, it would seem that (once the person’s mind and emotions become invested in physical things) the force with the higher source (the worries about parnossa) could extinguish the force with the lower source (the G-dly soul’s love for Hashem).
The reason why this doesn’t happen is because the G-dly soul (and its love for Hashem) ultimately comes from an even higher source – the essence of Hashem. Since this is even higher than the world of Tohu, it cannot be extinguished by concerns about material things.
In addition to not extinguishing the G-dly soul’s love for Hashem, the worries about parnossa actually enable the soul to reach a higher level than it was capable of reaching in the spiritual world.
Before the soul comes into this world, it is on the level of a tzaddik. When the soul is put into a physical body and faces the challenges of the material world, it will experience the pain of (the Jew) being overly invested in material matters at the expense of pursuing the true purpose of its descent into creation (serving Hashem). This bitter remorse brings the soul to the level of a ba’al teshuva, who is even higher than a tzaddik.
Seemingly, the explanation of how the soul reaches a higher level through the challenges of earning a parnossa presents a contradiction:
Initially we said that the soul’s love for Hashem (and the soul itself) comes from Hashem’s essence (which is why the “great waters” cannot extinguish it). We then explained that the soul descends into this world in order to reach Hashem’s essence through teshuva. Why does the soul need to reach Hashem’s essence if the soul already comes from His essence?
The Rebbe first clarifies the basis for this question:
ה) והגם ששרש הנשמות הוא בעצמותו ית’ שלמעלה מכל הגילויים, וכדמוכח (גם) ממה שארז"ל⁴² במי נמלך בנשמותיהן של צדיקים, שענין ההמלכה הוא גם על גילויים הכי נעלים (מכיון שהם ברצון ולא בהכרח ח"ו,) הרי מובן שהנשמות שבהן נמלך הן למעלה מכל הגילויים⁴³, מ"מ שייך לומר שע"י התשובה (בירידתן למטה) נעשית בהן עלי’ גם לגבי הדרגא שהי’ בשרשן.
As explained in the previous section, the source of the G-dly soul (even before it descends into this world) is in Hashem’s essence. The fact that the soul comes from Hashem’s essence can also be proven from the following explanation of the Midrash:
The possuk says [Chronicles I, 4:23], “They (the descendants of Yehuda listed in the earlier pesukim) were the potters who dwelled in Netaim and Gederah; they resided there with the king at his work.”
The phrase “the king at his work” hints to the fact that that the King, the King of kings, the Holy One, blessed be He, sat “there” [before creation] the souls of the tzadikim with whom He consulted and then created His world [His “work”]. [The Midrash then finds a similar hint in the word “yotzrim” (potters) from the same possuk.]
In this context, “creation” doesn’t only refer to the creation of the physical world; it also refers to the creation of the spiritual worlds, including the highest possible revelations of G-dliness.
The Rebbe points out why we are forced to say that Hashem “consulted” with the tzadikim even before “creating” these highest revelations:
Kabballah often uses the analogy of “light” to represent the revelation of G-dliness, as the emanation of light from its source has many parallels to the revelation of G-dliness from Hashem Himself.
However, one of the main differences between the two is that a source of light automatically gives off light, while Hashem, G-d forbid, doesn’t “automatically” do anything – He chooses what He does and does not do. Therefore, we must say that even the highest revelations of light within creation are “intentional”, and Hashem “consulted” with the souls of the tzadikim before “creating” these revelations.
We can conclude from this that the souls of the tzadikim are higher than any revelation of G-dliness, as they “existed” before any “existence” was brought into being. Since their “existence” comes before any revelation whatsoever, we must therefore say that the souls of the tzadikim “exist” within Hashem’s essence.
Nevertheless, they are still able to reach a higher level by descending into this world and doing teshuva.
The Rebbe begins to explain how this is possible:
ויובן זה ע"פ מ"ש הרב המגיד⁴⁴ בפירוש מרז"ל⁴⁵ ישראל עלו במחשבה, שהוא כמשל אדם שיש לו בן, דגם כשהבן עבר מכנגד פניו והלך מאתו, עכ"ז נחקקה הצורה של הבן במחשבה של האב. אלא שבבני אדם שייך זה דוקא במי שיש לו בן כו’. אבל אצל השי"ת שייך זה לומר אף קודם שנבראו ישראל הי’ נחקק צורתם במחשבה, כמ"ש רז"ל ישראל עלו במחשבה, כי אצלו ית’ העבר והעתיד אחד.
When relating the creation of Adam, Hashem says, “Let us make man in our image.” The Maggid explains the meaning of “our image” with the following analogy:
This can be compared to a person who has a son. Even if the son left his father long ago, the son’s image is still engraved in the father’s mind. For a human being, this is only possible for a person who has a son. Someone who never had a son, on the other hand, could never have the image of his son engraved in his mind, as he never saw him and would have no idea what he would look like. However, this is only a human limitation.
Hashem, on the other hand, was able to have the image of the Jews “engraved in His mind” – even before He created them. This is the meaning of the saying of our sages, “The Jews arose in Hashem’s thought,” which is possible because, for Hashem, the past and the future are all one.
This is the meaning of the possuk, “Let us make man in our image”:
It should be interpreted as, “Let us [now] make man in (according to) “our image” (the image we have of him) [even though he wasn’t created yet].”
The Rebbe applies this teaching of the Maggid to our topic:
ומובן מזה, דזה מה שהנשמות מושרשות בעצמותו ית’ ובהם נמלך כו’ – הו"ע הנשמות כמו שהן בבחי’ נברא (וכמו שהן יורדות למטה,) ורק ש(גם) צורה זו היא חקוקה במחשבתו ית,’ לפי שאצלו ית’ העבר והעתיד אחד. וכידוע⁴⁶ בפירוש במי נמלך כו,’ שזהו מה שעלה לפניו ית’ התענוג שיתענג כבי’ בעבודת הנשמות למטה.
Based on the fact that the Maggid explains that the “image” of the Jewish soul in Hashem’s thought (essence) is the image of the soul of the Jew who will be created in the future, we also understand that the “souls of the tzadikim” who Hashem “consulted” with before creation (in His essence) refers to the (future) souls that will be brought into creation and will accomplish their purpose in this world. However, since Hashem is above time, this image was able to exist within “Hashem’s mind” before the souls were brought into being.
In other words, the reason why the souls “exist” within Hashem’s essence (even before creation) is because of the future enjoyment which they will bring to Hashem after they are brought into this world. When we say that Hashem “consulted” with the souls before creation, this actually means that Hashem decided to create the world based on the (future) enjoyment that He would get from the work of the Jewish souls.
Based on this, we can understand how the souls are able to reach a higher level by descending into this world, even though they already come from Hashem’s essence:
ועפ"ז יובן ענין העלי’ שנעשה בהנשמות ע"י ירידתן למטה, הגם שגם לפני ירידתן הן מושרשות בעצמותו ית,’ כי זה מה שהן מושרשות בעצמותו ית’ (ובהם נמלך כו)’ הוא מצד ידיעתו ית’ שתהי’ אח"כ ירידתן למטה כו’ וישלימו הכוונה⁴⁷.
When the soul descends into this world, it can complete the mission that had “earned” it a place in Hashem’s essence to begin with.
Based on this, we see that the premise of our earlier question was incorrect. At the beginning of this section, we asked why the soul needs to come into this world in order to reach Hashem’s essence if it already has its source in Hashem’s essence.
We now understand that the entire reason why the soul has a source in Hashem’s essence is because of what it will accomplish in this world. Therefore, it must come into this world in order to “earn” the fact that it “already” came from Hashem’s essence!
However, we can still ask why it is necessary for the soul to actually descend into this world:
Seemingly, the difference between “future” and “actual” achievement is only relevant to someone who is unable to see the future. Since Hashem is above time, and therefore knows with absolute certainty that this goal will be achieved, why does the “actual” achievement have any more significance than the (certain) “future” achievement?
The Rebbe addresses this question:
והגם שגם בתחלה יודעים בודאות גמורה שישלימו הכוונה, הרי זהו בכח, ותכלית העילוי (והכוונה) הוא⁴⁸ הפועל.
In Eitz Chaim, it states that the purpose of creation is for “the completeness of Hashem’s abilities and activities to be revealed.” From this we see that Hashem’s desire in the creation of the world is that the potential abilities that exist within Him should be revealed within creation. Therefore, the actual achievement of a potential goal has significance. Similarly, the soul actually needs to complete its mission in this world (and face the challenges of earning a parnossa) – even though it is guaranteed to (eventually) succeed.
Parenthetically, the Rebbe notes that we can see this point in the precise wording of the Midrash:
[וזהו גם דיוק הלשון במי נמלך בנשמותיהן של צדיקים, שבהיותן בבחינת ההמלכה [שאז העילוי שלהן הוא בכח, שיודעים שישלימו הכוונה] הן בבחינת צדיקים, ולאחרי ירידתן למטה [שאז הם משלימים את הכוונה בפועל] נעשים בבחי’ בעלי תשובה.]
When the Midrash refers to the Jewish souls as they exist in Hashem’s essence because of their (guaranteed) future potential, the Midrash calls them “the souls of tzadikim.” Only after they descend to the physical world and actually complete their mission do they become ba’alei teshuva (who are incomparably higher than tzadikim).
The Rebbe connects this to the overall theme of “and Ya’akov went on his way”, which represents the transition from the holiness of Tishrei back into everyday life:
ו) ויש לקשר זה עם ענין ד"ויעקב הלך לדרכו" (שבמוצאי שבת פרשת נח⁴⁹,) דהגם שלאחרי חודש תשרי הוא הולך לדרכו (גם) בעניני הרשות ובעובדין דחול, ועד לבחינת מים רבים הנ"ל, מ"מ עי"ז גופא הוא מתעלה יותר, שנעשה בבחינת מהלך⁵⁰, וכלשון הכתוב⁵¹ ויעקב הלך לדרכו.
This ma’amar was said on motzei Shabbos parshas Noach, which is the conclusion of the first full week without any holidays after Simchas Torah. This represents the “complete” return to “his (Ya’akov’s) way”, representing a Jew’s daily activities (including his mundane activities and worries about parnossa), after being immersed in holiness during the month of Tishrei.
Seemingly, a Jew’s return to his mundane activities would represent a descent from his involvement in holiness during the yomim tovim. To clarify that this is not the case, the possuk says that Ya’akov “went” on his way, using the word halach (went). Whereas angels are referred to as “omdim” (“ones who stand” – they are not capable of a fundamental change and elevation to an incomparably greater level), a Jew is referred to as a “mehalech” (“one who goes” – someone who is capable of transformational change). This shows that his return to mundane activities is able to bring him (halach) to an incomparably greater level!
וידיעה זו [שהירידה (לדרכו בעניני הרשות וכו)’ היא צורך עלי’] פועלת שההליכה תהי’ בשמחה ובטוב לבב [וע"ד מ"ש⁵² גבי יעקב וישא יעקב רגליו גו’ משנתבשר בשורה טובה כו’.] וזה פועל שעבודתו תהי’ בתכלית השלימות ולמעלה ממדידה והגבלה (בחי’ בכל מאדך⁵³,) כי שמחה פורץ⁵⁴ כל הגדרים.
The fact that a Jew is aware that his “descent” into everyday mundane activities is a necessary part of reaching a higher level causes him to approach them with joy and optimism. (This is similar to what is written regarding Ya’akov: After Hashem promised him that He would protect him, it says that Ya’akov “lifted his feet and went to the land of the people of the East.” The Midrash explains that he “lifted his feet” (it was easier for him to travel) because of his joy and optimism from the good news.)
This joy and optimism then causes the Jew to serve Hashem in the ultimate way, above all limitations (which corresponds to the level of serving Hashem “with all your might” mentioned in the Shema), because “joy breaks all boundaries.”
The Rebbe concludes:
וע"י שעובד עבודתו [בכל הג’ קוין (ג’ בני נח⁵⁵) דתורה עבודה וגמ"ח] בתכלית השלימות ובשמחה ובטוב לבב, נמשך לו גם ברכת הוי’ בכל המצטרך לו [בג’ הענינים דבני חיי ומזוני⁵⁶] בתכלית השלימות ובשמחה ובטוב לבב, הן ברוחניות והן בגשמיות, וברוחניות ובגשמיות גם יחד.
Through serving Hashem in all the three areas of Torah, davening, and mitzvos (which correspond to the three sons of Noach), in the most ultimate and complete way, and with optimism and joy, this will draw down Hashem’s brachos for him in everything that he needs (in all three areas of children, health, and parnossa), in the most ultimate and complete way, and with optimism and joy – both spiritually and physically – and with both spirituality and physicality integrated as one!