By Rabbi Akiva Niehaus
The Gemara (Sukkah 27a) notes that both Sukkos and Pesach begin on the 15th of the month and can be compared one to another. The Poskim derive from here various halachos:
- FIRST NIGHT OBLIGATION: Just like one is obligated to eat Matzah on the 15th of Nissan, so too, one must eat bread in the Sukkah on the 15th of Tishrei (S.A. 639:3, M.B. 639:19)
- AFTER TZEIS: Similar to Matzah, the eating in the Sukkah must take place after Tzeis Hakochavim (Rama 639:3, M.B. 639:25)
- BEFORE CHATZOS: Similar to Matzah, the eating should ideally take place before Chatzos (Rama 639:3, M.B. 639:26)
- K'ZAYIS: Just like Matzah, it is sufficient to eat one k'zayis of bread in the Sukkah (although ideally one should try to eat a k'beitzah) (S.A. 639:3, M.B. 639:20, 22)
- WITHIN K'DEI ACHILAS PRAS: Similar to matzah, the bread should be eaten within a short time duration (k'dei achilas pras) (M.B. 639:22)
- IN ONE BITE: Some Poskim write that, similar to matzah, the k'zayis should ideally be consumed in one bite (Mateh Ephraim 625:52)
- RAIN: The Rama (639:5) rules that, similar to Pesach, the obligation to eat in the Sukkah applies in all situations, even if it's raining, but others disagree (see M.B. 639:35)
- HONEY: Some Poskim write that, just like matzah, the bread should be simple, without flavorings, and eaten without honey (or other spreads) but others disagree (see Yad Eliyahu Pesachim 23:1, Tzlach ibid. 108a, Pri Megadim M.Z. end of 643, A.A. 639:15, Elef Lamateh 645:8)
- EATING ON EREV SUKKOS: Just like one should minimize eating on Erev Pesach in order to have a good appetite for the matzah by the Seder, so too, one should minimize eating on Erev Sukkos (Rama 639:3, M.B. 639:27)
- ALL SEVEN DAYS: Just like (according to the Vilna Gaon) there is a non-obligatory mitzvah to eat matzah all seven days of Pesach, perhaps there is also a mitzvah to eat in the Sukkah all seven days of Sukkos (M.B. 639:24)