The Gemara tells us that anyone who did not see the Simchas Beis HaShoʼeiva, the Festival of Water Drawing, has never seen a true celebration in his life. The Rambam describes the great festivities that were then conducted: "The flute would be played, along with the lyre, harp and cymbals. Each person would play on the instrument with which he was familiar, and those who knew how to sing would sing. They would dance and clap their hands with great enthusiasm, each one as best he was able. They would recite songs of praise to HaShem... The great Sages of Israel, heads of yeshivos, the Sanhedrin, chassidim, elders and men of great deeds would dance, sing and rejoice in the Beis HaMikdash during the days of Sukkos” (Hilchos Lulav, ch. 8). Such descriptions awaken a longing in our hearts to see the Beis HaMikdash rebuilt, that we may once again rejoice before HaShem as our ancestors did.
WHAT ARE THE REASONS FOR THESE CELEBRATIONS?
Rejoicing over the water libations (nisuch hamayim):
The very name of the celebration,
Simchas Beis HaShoeiʼva, implies its most simple explanation. They rejoiced over the opportunity to draw water from the springs near the Beis HaMikdash, and carry the water up to the Beis HaMikdash to perform the special water libations on the Mizbeiach. This korban was offered only during Sukkos. They would accompany the water carriers from the spring to the Beis HaMikdash, with songs of the flute and great cheer in this special mitzva. This is as Rashi explains, “This entire celebration was only for the sake of the nisuch hamayim” (50a, s.v. Simchas Beis HaShoeiʼva).
Rejoicing before HaShem:
The Rambam (ibid), on the other hand, implies that this celebration was associated with the mitzvah to rejoice on Sukkos: “Although we are commanded to rejoice on all the holidays, on the holiday of Sukkos there was exceptional joy in the Beis HaMikdash, as the possuk says, 'You shall rejoice before HaShem, Your G-d, for seven days.” The Rambam makes no mention of the nisuch hamayim as a reason for the celebration. Why then was it called the Simchas Beis HaShoei’va, the Festival of Water Drawing? This was because they rejoiced in their celebrations for the entire night, until the morning arrived, and the time came to draw water for the nisuch hamayim. In any case, we must ask why Sukkos was celebrated with such exceptional festivities, and such enthusiastic displays of singing and dancing, in contrast to the other Yomim Tovim, which are celebrated with more subdued, inner joy?
According to Rashi, they celebrated the mitzvah of nisuch hamayim, which began by drawing water from a spring. Drawing water from a spring is used in Tanach as a metaphor for the great joy that we will experience when we witness HaShem's ultimate salvation: “And you will draw water with joy from the wellsprings of salvation” (Yeshiyahu 12:3). The Metzudas Dovid explains that this is an apt metaphor for the eternal joy we will then know. When a person draws water from a water pit, he is worried that it will eventually run dry. When he draws from a spring, he can truly rejoice, since he knows the waters will constantly be replenished.
Sasson and Simcha:
The Gemara (48b) learns from this passuk that we must blow on the trumpets as we draw the water for the nisuch hamayim. Therefore, we are led to infer that the Simchas Beis HaShoei 'va should be accompanied with a public display or rejoicing. In the passuk, “You will draw water with joy,” the word used for joy is sasson. The Vilna Gaon was known to distinguish between simcha and sasson, that simcha is an inner feeling of joy, whereas sasson is an outward expression of rejoicing (see also Malbim, Yermiyahu 16:9). Since the passuk says that the water should be drawn with sasson, an outward expression of rejoicing, we find a source here for the Simchas Beis HaShoei 'va.
Rejoice before HaShem:
According to the Rambam, the Simchas Beis HaShoei 'va was conducted in fulfillment of the passuk, “You shall rejoice before HaShem.” We rejoice in HaShem's presence, in the Beis HaMikdash.
On the other Yomim Tovim, there is also a mitzvah of simcha. However, we need not express that simcha in song and dance. Simcha can be a subtle rejoicing of the heart. With this alone we fulfill the mitzva. On Sukkos there is a special of mitzva of “rejoicing before HaShem.” This means to say, we must express our joy to HaShem, by singing and dancing in the Beis HaMikdash (R' Y.D. Soloveitchik zt”l, cited in Kobetz Yad R' Sh., Sukka).
In Remembrance of the Simchas Beis HaShoei'va:
The Mishna Berura (661, s.k. 20) cites from the Yesod V’Shoresh Ha'Avoda that: "The pious people and men of great deeds make a remembrance for the Simchas Beis HaShoei 'va, by staying up at night on Chol HaMoed to sing many songs and praises to HaShem, and light candles in the sukka. In many shuls, the custom is to light extra candles for Maariv."
R' Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zt”l (Halichos Shlomo, Moadim ch. 12, p. 239, footnote 7) offered an interesting ruling in regard to the Simchas Beis HaShoei’va celebrated today during Chol HaMoed. He writes that a person from chutz laʼaretz who spends Sukkos in Eretz Yisroel, and keeps two days of Yom Tov, may still participate in a Simchas Beis HaShoei 'va held on the first night of Chol HaMoed (which for him is still Yom Tov).
Although it is generally forbidden to dance or clap hands on Shabbos and Yom Tov, one may do so for the sake of a mitzvah. R' Shlomo Zalman held that participating in a Simchas Beis HaShoeiʼva is a mitzvah that justifies dancing and clapping.
KORBAN MAYIM B'CHAG
"U'sh'avtem mayim b'soson mi'ma'y'nei ha'yishuho" - You shall draw water with joy from the wellsprings of deliverance. (Yeshiyahu 12:3)
Throughout the year wine offerings were poured onto the altar, and on Sukkos there were also water libations. The source for this is explained in the Gemara Shabbos 104b. The Gemara Sukkah 48b relates that there was once a Saducee Kohein (Tzedoki) who poured the water libations onto his feet and the people pelted him to death with their esrogim. Why would he do such a thing, and why did they stone him with their esrogim?
There are two basic approaches to serving HaShem:
- TAAM VODAAS, reason (literally "taste") and understanding - serving HaShem based upon comprehension of the significance of a mitzvoh and the profundity of the Divine revelation achieved after performing it.
- KABOLAS OLE, absolute submission to perform the will of HaShem regardless of whether the significance is understood. Wine has taste, and water is tasteless. Therefore, one must precede wine drinking with a beracha even if one is not thirsty, while over water a beracha is only made if one drinks to quench his thirst (Sh.O. Orach Chaim 204:7).
Wine and water are analogous to these two approaches to serving HaShem. Wine represents the approach of "taam vodaas," comprehension, and water represents the approach of "kabolas ole," absolute subordination, even without understanding. The latter mode is loftier because it is unfettered. It is not conditional upon previous understanding.
The Saducee Kohein advocated serving HaShem based on understanding only and rejected the approach of doing Mitzvos when one has no idea what they accomplish. Consequently, this Kohein subscribed to the wine libations throughout the year, but scoffed at the water libation, pouring it onto his feet instead of onto the altar. The people were deeply offended by this because it implied that only the learned scholar should serve HaShem but not the common folk, and therefore, in their severe rage, they pelted him with their esrogim, putting him to death (there is an opinion that he was not killed, as per some Rishonim on the above Gemara) for his heretical philosophy.
Alternatively, his message was that only the simple people who are like the feet, the base organs, and have no mind of their own should serve HaShem based on "kabolas ole," but intellectuals should serve HaShem based on their understanding and comprehension.
The people severely rejected this because even the most superior minds cannot comprehend the infinity of HaShem. Therefore, to a certain extent everyone must exhibit "kabolas ole."(Lubavitcher Rebbe)