Skip to content
Parsha Pages

Bircas Kohanim: Inside and Outside the Beis haMikdash

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

The original location, as well as the primary fulfillment, of Bircas Kohanim seems to be in the holy precincts, first in the Mishkan (Tabernacle), and afterwards in the Beis Ha-mikdash (Temple). In fact, the Torah relates that upon concluding the sacrificial service of the eighth day of the Mishkan's dedication, Aharon blesses the people:

“And Aharon raised up his hands toward the people and blessed them; and he came down from offering the sin-offering and the burnt-offering and the peace-offerings." (Vayikra 9:22)

Based on this verse, the first mention of the concept in the Torah, the ceremony of Bircas Kohanim is often referred to as Nesias Kappayim, “Raising the Hands." Indeed, the Rambam, in his Sefer Ha-mitzvos, lists Bircas Kohanim among the positive mitzvos associated with the Beis Ha-mikdash and its service (Mitzvas Aseh 26.

The Mishna (Tamid 7:2) lists three differences between the blessing recited in the Beis haMikdash as opposed to the one recited outside.

ElementInside the Bais haMikdashOutsideBlessingOneThreeName of G-dShem Ha-mforashpseudonymLift handsAbove their headsShoulder level

The Gemara (Sota 38a) arrives at a similar conclusion.

While these sources indicate that the Priestly Blessing is to be recited OUTSIDE the Beis haMikdash as well, it also clearly indicates the uniqueness, if not the primacy, of Bircas Kohanim as it is recited in the Beis haMikdash. In fact, even outside of the Beis haMikdash, the kohanim bless the people immediately after the berakha of "Retzeh," which petitions for the restoration of the Temple service!

If so, one might ask whether, technically, the mitzva of Bircas Kohanim OUTSIDE of the Beis haMikdash is biblical (mi-de'oraita) or rabbinic (mi-derabbanan).

The Yerushalmi (Nazir 7:1), as well as the Rishonim (Rambam, Sefer Ha-mitzvot, Aseh 26; Ramban, Bamidbar 8:2; Sefer Ha-chinukh 378, etc.), and Acharonim (Keren Ora, Sota 38a; Peri Megadim, OC 128:3, etc.), agree that Bircas Kohanim, outside of the Beis haMikdash, and even after its destruction, remains mi-de'oraita.

However, even if the obligation of Bircas Kohanim applies equally outside of the Beis haMikdash, one may still ask: is its nature different? Furthermore, one might also question whether Bircas Kohanim, in general, should be seen as a part of the daily service in the Beis haMikdash; or whether, fundamentally, Bircas Kohanim is a form of tefilla, recited both inside AND outside of the Beis haMikdash.

Interestingly, the Mishna chooses to include the laws of Bircas Kohanim in Tractate Sota, adjacent to laws of the ceremony of the "Berakhos U-kelalos" (Blessings and Curses) on Mount Gerizim and Mount Eival, and not in Tractate Berakhos, which addresses the laws of prayer and blessings directly.

The Rambam cites Bircas Kohanim, in his Sefer Ha-mitzvos, among the other mitzvos related to the Beis haMikdash. However, he puts the laws of Bircas Kohanim alongside the laws of prayer, calling the entire unit "Hilkhot Tefilla U-nesiat Kappayim," "The Laws of Prayer and Raising the Hands!"

These sources highlight the apparent ambiguity in, or dual nature of, Bircas Kohanim.

There appear to halakhic similarities or differences between Bircas Kohanim in the synagogue and Bircas Kohanim in the Temple service.

We seem to find an apparent contradiction in the Talmud. On the one hand, the gemara in Sota (38a), deriving that Bircas Kohanim should be recited while standing, cites a baraita:

"In THIS way you shall bless" – STANDING. You say that it means standing, but perhaps that is not so and [the blessing may be pronounced] even sitting! It is stated here, "In this way you shall bless," and elsewhere (Devarim 27:12) it is stated: "These shall stand to bless" (referring to the Mount Gerizim ceremony) – just as here, it is standing; so too in the former passage, it is standing.

Rabbi Natan says: "[This deduction] is unnecessary; behold, it states [regarding the kohanim]: 'To serve Him and to bless in His Name (ibid. 10:8)' – as [the priest] serves standing, so he blesses standing. How do we know that the service [was performed standing]? Because it is written [regarding the kohanim]: 'To stand to serve (ibid. 18:5).'"

This gemara concludes that just as the kohen must perform all of the other parts of the Temple service while standing, so too he must recite Bircas Kohanim while standing. This apparently supports the position which views Bircas Kohanim as a form of Temple service.

On the other hand, the Gemara elsewhere (Ta'anis 26b-27a) appears to reject this comparison:

Everyone agrees that one who is intoxicated may not perform Bircas Kohanim. How do we know this? Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi said in the name of Bar Kappara: "Why is the section relating to the kohen taught immediately following the section relating to a nazir (who is prohibited to drink wine)? [To teach that] just as wine is forbidden for a nazir, so too wine is forbidden for a kohen who blesses."

If so, then just as grape seeds are forbidden for a nazir [so too a kohen]!

Rabbi Yitzchak says: "The verse says 'To serve Him and to bless in His Name' – just as one who serves (i.e., a kohen during the Temple service) may consume grape seeds, so to a kohen who blesses may consume grape seeds.

If so, just as one who serves may not have a blemish (mum), so too a kohen who blesses...

It is merely an asmakhta (mnemonic), and it is of rabbinic origin.

Seemingly, this gemara rejects the above comparison, adopted by the other gemara (Sota 28a), between a kohen who serves in the Beis haMikdash and a kohen who recites Bircas Kohanim!

While the Gemara does not point out this apparent contradiction, the Rishonim debate whether to apply the comparison between Temple service and Bircas Kohanim.

On the one hand, the Rambam (Hilkhos Tefilla 15:3-4) disqualifies one guilty of idolatry or murder, as well as one who has consumed a revi'it of wine, by comparison to the Temple service. On the other hand, Tosafos (Ta'anis 27a) rule that a blemished or apostate kohen may recite Bircas Kohanim, rejecting the comparison between Bircas Kohanim and the Temple service.

The Acharonim also discuss this question. For example, the Taz (128:27) questions why the Shulchan Arukh rules that if a community is already accustomed to the kohen's physical blemish, he may recite Bircas Kohanim. He asks, based upon the sources cited above, why this kohen should not be disqualified due to the comparison between Bircas Kohanim and the Temple service!

He offers what he himself describes as "a novel explanation, as we have not found this question or its answer in any commentary, old or new." He suggests that while we DO derive from the Temple service those disqualifications which the kohen can avoid, e.g., being drunk or being sedentary, those which relate to his physical appearance, which he cannot avoid, do not disqualify him.

Alternatively, the Magen Avraham (128:54) questions whether an arel, one who is uncircumcised, may participate in Bircas Kohanim. He concludes that one who is uncircumcised MAY participate in Bircas Kohanim, despite his apparent disqualification from Temple service. In other words, he rejects the comparison between Bircas Kohanim and the Temple service.

The Peri Megadim (OC 128) explores this issue, and expends great effort defending the position of the Taz.

Is it possible that just as the Mishna lists the TECHNICAL differences between Bircas Kohanim inside and outside the Beis haMikdash, there may be a fundamental distinction as well? Might we suggest that while in the Beis haMikdash, Bircas Kohanim functions as an integral part of the Temple service, Bircas Kohanim outside of the Beis haMikdash is integrated into the mitzva of tefilla?

We noted above that most Rishonim and Acharonim conclude that the mitzva of Bircas Kohanim applies equally inside and outside of the Beis haMikdash. However, one may certainly suggest (see Keren Ora, Sota 38a) that Bircas Kohanim recited outside of the Beis haMikdash, which lacks the proper use of the Shem Ha-mforash, may only be mi-derabbanan! Furthermore, in what biblical context, some ask, could Bircas Kohanim outside of the Beis haMikdash take place? According to many, the mitzva of tefilla is only of rabbinic origin, and even if its origin is biblical (as we attributed to the Rambam in last year's shiurim), it certainly does not mandate communal prayer! If so, then certainly we might suggest that while the biblical character of Bircas Kohanim as recited in the Beis haMikdash relates to the Temple service, the rabbinical character of Bircas Kohanim recited during the tefilla relates to public prayer. However, the Keren Ora, cited above, rejects this somewhat tempting suggestion.

Interestingly, Rabbi Naftali Tzvi Yehuda Berlin (1817-1893), known as the Netziv, suggests (Hamek Davar, Bamidbar 6:23 and Vayikra 9:22), based on a close textual reading, that Bircas Kohanim is recited twice in the Beis haMikdash: once as part of the Temple service, and a second time, as described in the Mishna (Tamid 5:1), as part of the daily prayers.

If indeed there are two aspects of, or even venues for, of Bircas Kohanim, one might suggest a resolution to the contradiction presented above. The gemara in Sota refers to Bircas Kohanim in the Beis haMikdash, and it therefore maintains a comparison between the Temple service and Bircas Kohanim. The gemara in Ta'anis, however, refers to Bircas Kohanim recited as part of tefilla, either inside (according to the Netziv) or outside of the Beis haMikdash, and it therefore rejects the above comparison.

One final issue related to this question arises yearly during the Ne'ila (closing) prayer of Yom Kippur, specifically in Eretz Yisrael. The Mishna (Ta'anit 4:1) states explicitly that Bircas Kohanim is recited during Tefillas Ne'ila.

Aside from the general question whether Tefillas Ne'ila should be concluded during the day or whether it may continue into the night (see Yerushalmi Ta'anit 4:1), the Rishonim ALSO debate whether Bircas Kohanim may be recited after dark.

The Hagahos Maimoniyyos (Hilkhos Tefilla 3, Letter Heh), citing the Mordekhai, attempts to prove that Tefillas Ne'ila must be recited during the day from the laws of Bircas Kohanim:

The law is in accordance [with Rabbi Yochanan, who explains that Ne'ila must be concluded during the day]... Furthermore, they bring a proof from the three times [that Bircas Kohanim is recited]... implying that [it is concluded] while it is still light out, as it is compared to the service, i.e. the song recited over the sacrifice... which is recited while it is still day... Our ancestors certainly did not establish this custom, to recite it at night; rather, it is because the cantors drag it out until night that people think that that the law is such.

The Hagahos Maimoniyyos maintains that the proper practice is to recite Tefillas Ne'ila and Bircas Kohanim while it is still day.

The Maharil (cited by the Darkhei Moshe), the Magen Avraham (623:3) and others permit saying Bircas Kohanim after nightfall. Others, such as the Shulchan Arukh Ha-Rav (623:8), rule that Bircas Kohanim may performed UNTIL the stars come out. Others (see Peri Megadim, cited by the Sha'ar Ha-tziyyun, 623:11) are lenient until about an hour and a half after sunset (shekia); or, in Eretz Yisrael, until about thirteen and a half minutes after shekia.

Interestingly, the Rema (623:5) records the custom in his area NOT to recite Bircas Kohanim at Tefillas Ne'ila. Many Acharonim explain that since the cantors often reach the end of Ne'ila after dark, Bircas Kohanim can no longer be recited. In Eretz Yisrael, it is still customary to recite Bircas Kohanim at Ne'ila, and then recite Avinu Malkenu, responsively, until the end of the fast.

Seemingly, this question should be related to the broader issue discussed above: is Bircas Kohanim part of the Temple service, or is it an independent mitzva related to prayer? In fact, the Hagahos Maimoniyyos, cited above, explains that since Bircas Kohanim is compared to the Temple service, it cannot be performed at night.

For further treatment of this topic, see Rav Yosef Dov Soloveitchik's essay, entitled "Nesiat Kappayim," in Shiurim Le-zekher Abba Mori, Volume2; and Rav Mosheh Lichtenstein's shiurim on Tractate Sota (http://vbm-torah.org/archive/sota7/05-38a.doc).

More in this printout

View the whole printout