לְמַעַן יֵדְעוּ דֹרֹתֵיכֶם כִּי בַמֶּכּוֹת הוֹשַׁבְתִּי אֶת-בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל בְּהוֹצִיאִי אוֹתָם מֵאֶרֶץ מִצְרָיִם אֲנִי ה' אֱלֹקִיכֶם
“So that your generations will know that I caused the Children of Israel to dwell in Sukkos when I took them from the land of Egypt” (VaYikra 23,43).
Which Sukkos is the Torah referring to?
Sukkos 11b: Rabbi Eliezer teaches that the Sukkah commemorates the Ananei ha'Kavod, the Clouds of Glory that surrounded the Jewish people during their sojourn in the desert. Rabbi Akiva teaches that the Sukkah commemorates the actual Sukkos in which the Jews lived in the desert, and which protected them from the elements of the desert.
It is noteworthy that Rashi in his commentary on Chumash and in his commentary earlier on Daf 2 only quotes the opinion of Rabbi Eliezer who maintains that the festival of Sukkos is to commemorate the Clouds of Glory.
Why is this festival commemorating this miracle in the Desert but there is not a festival for the other miracles?
The Gemara in Taanis 9a states that HaShem performed three miracles for the Jewish People in the Wilderness. HaShem provided the Jewish People with a traveling well of water that was in the merit of Miriam. The Jewish People were further provided with manna that fell from heaven and sustained them and the manna was in the merit of Moshe. The Clouds of Glory that protected the Jewish People were in the merit of Aharon.
The commentators wonder why there is only a festival commemorating the miracle of the Clouds of Glory while there is no festival that commemorates the miracles of the traveling well and the falling of the manna from heaven.
The Vilna Gaon and Reb Tzadok HaKohen from Lublin in Pri Tzaddik posit that in truth, we are not commemorating any of the above-mentioned miracles. Rather, the explanation is that following the sin of the Golden Calf, Hashem removed the Clouds of Glory that were protecting the Jewish People and only after Moshe gained atonement for the Jewish People on Yom Kippur did the Glory did not actually return until the fifteenth of Tishrei when the Jewish People commenced the construction of the Mishkan, the edifice that reflected their atonement. Thus, the festival of Sukkos is not necessarily a commemoration of the Clouds of Glory. Rather, the festival of Sukkos commemorates the return of the Clouds of Glory and the atonement that the Jewish People received on Yom Kippur.
GOLDEN CALF17TH OF TAMMUZ (YOM CHAMISHI)DAY ASCENDED HAR SINAI18TH OF TAMMUZ (YOM SHISHI)ROSH CHODESH AVYOM REVEI ONLY ONE DAYBEGAN SECOND 40 DAYS30TH OF AV (YOM CHAMISHI) FIRST DAY OF TWO DAYS OF ROSH CHODESHROSH CHODESH TISHREIYOM SHABBOS ONLY ONE DAYCAME DOWN10TH OF TISHREI (YOM SHENEI)DAY OF JUDGEMENTS11TH OF TISHREIMOSHE SAID ENOUGH (36:6)15TH OF TISHREI (SHABBOS) COMMAND NOT TO CARRY IN RESHUS HARABIMWhy does each Rabbi have a different view of the concept of “Sukkos” in the verse?
Rabbi EliezerRabbi Akiva"Sukkah"Clouds of GloryActual sukkahThe nature of each Rabbiאלקי אבי בעזרי Due to its connection, the essence is not corruptedSon of converts Service to fix the essenceUnderstand the concept of dwelling in a Sukkah
Malbi”m: A means to combat haughtiness. In the future, when a person works the land and gathers the harvest, one might believe their fortune results solely their efforts. So, one goes out from their permanent dwelling to a temporary dwelling that one should understand they we are really guests in this world and HaShem prepared all the assets that allow for our existence.
Vilna Gaon: explains that when Bnai Yisrael worshiped the golden calf, the Clouds of Glory departed since the Jews no longer merited its protection. Moshe sought Divine forgiveness, which was granted upon which Moshe descended to the Jews on Yom Kippur. On the following morning, the 11th of Tishrei, Moshe gathered the people and told them about the mitzvah to construct the Mishkan. The next two days, the people donated the materials. On the 14th of Tishrei he reviewed and concluded enough had been received. Just prior to the night of the 15th of Tishrei (Shabbos), Moshe told them to stop. On Shabbos, the 15th of Tishrei the Clouds of Glory returned for the reminder of their 40-year stay in the Midbar. Thus, Sukkos commemorates the return of the Clouds.
Chidah: The "mesoroh" lists three verses that have the common word "ki." They are our verse (Vayikra 23.43), "Ki vorchov nolin" (Bereishis 19,2), and "Ki ner mitzvoh v'Toroh ohr" (Mishlei 6,23). The Chid"a relates that when he was a child an explanation for this "mesoroh" was asked of a "chochom" and he gave no verbal response, but instead, wrote the letters Yud-Kof-Lamed-Mem-Nun-Samech-Ayin-Pei on a sheet of paper. The Chidah explains that there are three Mitzvos that require placement or structure of at least 10 handbreadths height and no more than twenty cubits. They are Sukkah, that its walls be at least ten handbreadths tall, but no more than twenty cubits high, alluded to in our verse, "ki vasukos"; Eiruv, the placement of a visible object, a "koreh," delineating the division between a "movuy" domain and the public street, (actually for "shitu'fei m'vu'os," but these terms are used interchangeably in the gemara Eiruvin) be between these same two heights, alluded to in "ki vorchov nolin"; and the Chanukah lights, that are also placed no lower than ten handbreadths from the ground and no higher than twenty cubits, alluded in the verse "ki ner mitzvah." This is the "mesoroh" connection in the letters Yud-Kof-Lamed-Mem-Nun-Samech-Ayin-Pei.
Chida: In the desert when the Jews travelled, they did so day and night without setting up camp. How were they able to sleep and eat? Rather they were carried within the Clouds and travelled like one does on a ship. The ship moves day and night, but the passengers are able to perform all their normal daily functions as if they were not travelling. Thus, we also eat, walk, entertain, sleep, etc. in the Sukkah. The very righteous do not go into their year-round house except for emergency situations.
Chasam Sofer: Both opinions are correct. Thus, the word סוכות is written plural to allow for both opinions. The circumstances depend on whether we are fulfilling the Will of HaShem. When we do our part properly, our needs are full provided without our work. When not, then we have to work with the natural processes to obtain our material needs.
From where did the Jews obtain wood in the desert for building Sukkos?
Rabeinu Bachye: the Jews obtained wood from the merchants of the other nations (like they purchased food from them). The miracle we commemorate is that for 40 years HaShem provided the Jews with every need, as they wandered through an inhospitable and uninhabitable desert.
The Midrash Tanchuma says that the waters of the Well of Miriam flowed around the Jewish encampment. There, sprouted endless variety of trees and hedges.