Skip to content
Parsha Pages

What is one obligated to eat in a Succah and when is a Brocha recited

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

What is one obligated to eat in a Succah and when is a Brocha recited
[according to the psak of the Mishneh Berurah]

One is permitted to eat an אכילת עראי [we will define this as a "halachic nosh"] outside of a Succah, while an אכילת קבע [a "set meal"] must be eaten in a Succah. When an אכילת קבע is eaten in the Succah a ברכה of לישב בסוכה is recited. When one eats an אכילת עראי in a Succah, even though he is fulfilling a Mitzvah, the custom is not to make a ברכה. It is sometimes uncertain whether we are dealing with אכילת קבע or עראי. In each such case, we are obligated to act stringently and eat in the Succah; however, we would not recite a ברכה since there is this doubt.

Bread

It is forbidden to eat more than the volume of an egg of bread outside of a Succah. Therefore, when one eats more than the volume of an egg of bread, he must recite the ברכה of לישב בסוכה. If one eats the volume of an egg or less, he is not required to eat in a Succah and, if he does eat in the Succah, he does not recite a ברכה.

Cake

According to the Mogen Avrohom, cake has the same rule as bread (more than the volume of an egg requires a Succah and a ברכה, and less than this amount does not require a Succah. However, the Mishne Berurah rules that even though more than the volume of an egg requires a Succah, it is better not to recite a Bracha. If a person sits to a "meal" of coffee and cake for his breakfast, even though he is not eating the amount a person would eat to become satiated, in this instance the Mishneh Berurah agrees that he make a Bracha. Additionally, if a person makes Kiddush and eats some cake, (even though he plans to eat his "set" meal later), he also makes a Bracha, since he has given the cake halachic "importance" by using it for קידוש במקום סעודה.

Pasta, spaghetti etc.

If one eats more than the volume of an "egg" of pasta etc. he is obligated to eat in a Succah. However, one only makes a Bracha if he sits down to a "set" meal of this type of food.

Meat, chicken, tuna etc.

One is not obligated to eat these foods in a Succah. However, if one sits down to a "set" meal of these foods, one should eat them in the Succah (although a Bracha should not be recited).

Fruits

They may be eaten outside of the Succah even if they are a "set" meal.

Drinks

One may drink any drink outside of the Succah [except if he makes a קביעות of wine, although it is highly unusual to do so.]

However, the Schulchan Aruch states that it is praiseworthy if one is careful and does not even drink water out of the Succah. If, however, a Succah is not available, one need not abstain from consuming foods or beverages which are not required to be eaten in a Succah.

More in this printout

View the whole printout