By Reuvy Havin
The Uniqueness of Sukkah
The Rebbe spoke often about a special halacha that is almost unique to the mitzvah of Sukkah. It originates with the Bach, who writes (OC 625) that an obligatory part of the mitzvah of Sukkah is to have kavana (intention) that Hashem took the Jewish people out of Egypt. This is a rare thing; usually, kavana of a mitzvah is not part of its core fulfilment, but merely an ideal enhancement. What is the reason that the mitzvah of Sukkah, exceptionally, requires kavana concerning the mitzvah's objective? This article will explore the Nigleh basis for this approach, as well as the Chassidic dimension.
Nigleh
The background to the Bach's ruling
In the beginning of Hilchos Sukkah, the Tur (OC 625) elaborates on the reasoning for the Mitzvah of Sukkah. He points out how the Possuk frames the mitzvah of Sukkah as relating to yetzias mitzrayim; that we erect our Sukkahs to remind us of Hashem's miracles in sheltering us in the desert after the Exodus. The Bach wonders why the Tur makes such an issue around the reasoning for the mitzvah, which seems out of character for the Tur. The Bach proposes that this is because the reason for the mitzvah – remembering yetzias mitzrayim – is part and parcel of the mitzvah itself, alongside the physical act of dwelling in the Sukkah.
What exactly does this mean? For all mitzvos, there are two intentions. The first is a generic intention, equally applicable to all mitzvos, to fulfil the mitzvah through the physical act of doing it (kavana latzeis). Halachically, this intention is binding, and without it, one does not fulfil the obligation (according to most opinions).
In contrast, there is another form of intent which, although ideal for the performance of a mitzvah, is generally not critical. This is the intention about the mitzvah's objective, i.e. reflection about the spiritual content and reasoning behind the mitzvah (kavanas ha'inyan). An exception to this, says the Bach, is the mitzvah of Sukkah, where one does not fulfil the mitzvah without both intentions.
Yet, if the Bach's explanation is correct, what is the Tur's source to say that the mitzvah of Sukkah is different? The Bach explains that this is because the Possuk itself explicitly provides the reason for the mitzvah – "In order that your future generations will know that I settled the Jews in Sukkahs when I took them out of Egypt." Through this verse, the Torah is emphasising that the inner content of the mitzvah is an essential part of its practical fulfilment. [The Bach notes that the same point applies to the mitzvos of tefillin and tzitzis as well.]
More precisely, there is some debate about the specific kavana we are meant to have. According to the Bach, the kavana is to remember yetzias mitzrayim. However, according to the Beis Yosef, the kavana is to remember the miraculous clouds Hashem created for the Jews in the desert, protecting them from the intense heat. The Pri Megodim says one should have both in mind, to fulfil all opinions. Conversely, the Alter Rebbe rules like the Bach.
If someone did not have this Kavana
What happens if someone does not have this intention? Do they still fulfil the mitzvah of dwelling in the Sukkah? Most Achronim hold that omitting this kavana will not invalidate the mitzvah after the fact, so long as the person intended at least to fulfil the mitzvah (kavana latzeis). Similarly, the Alter Rebbe makes no comment regarding invalidating the mitzvah of Sukkah without intention, unlike his comments elsewhere with respect to kavana latzeis, and this might well indicate that he concurs with the main view of the Achronim.
Interestingly, the Bikkurei Yaakov maintains that omitting this kavana will, in fact, invalidate the mitzvah. He bases this on an interesting argument, as follows: In halacha, there is often a concept of lechatchila and b'di'eved – an obligation may have a prescribed way of being performed in the first instance, but even if that form is not followed, the person might still be yotzeh after the fact. However, this entire dynamic only exists for mitzvos and requirements that are derabanan – Rabbinic ordinances. For mitzvos and requirements which are de'oraisa – Torah based - there is no such thing as lechatchila – if it is required, it is indispensable. Since the Bach argues that the kavana of Sukkah is derived from the Possuk, that means it is a Torah requirement and Torah requirements are always indispensable!
The Piskei Teshuvos takes this one step further: He writes that if one fails to have the kavana, he then doesn't fulfil the mitzvah, in which case it is like he is eating outside the Sukkah! So, not only does the lack of intention result in the absence of a mitzvah, but actually contravenes the rules and is regarded as an aveira. [This final point is somewhat debatable. Even if this kavana were truly indispensable, one could argue that the person is not fulfilling a mitzvah, but neither are they breaking the rules, for it cannot be said that they are eating their food outside the Sukkah. See Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach in Minchas Shlomo 1:1 at length.]
Chassidus
The Journey of Integration
What is this process of integrating our faith within our intellect and emotions?
Sukkah: Faith and Intellect
The explanation here is based on the Rebbe's maamar entitled 'Basukkos Teishvu', first night of Sukkos, 5740:
In Chassidic philosophy, one of the central themes of Sukkos is makif (that which encompasses) and hisyashvus (that which is settled). The Sukkah itself is emblematic of makif, which completely surrounds the person. The objective of the mitzvah, sitting or dwelling in the Sukkah, is the idea of funnelling the makif into hisyashvus; that which encompasses should become settled within us.
What does this theme represent in Avodas HaShem? Makif corresponds to faith in Hashem, because faith is the acknowledgement that there is something outside of you and bigger than you – it transcends you and encompasses you. Hisyashvus corresponds to intellectual and personal integration; when an idea is internalised and becomes settled within a person's mind and heart, and fused with his personality.
These two contrasting outlooks synergise on Sukkos. This is because the mitzvah is to dwell in the Sukkah - Basukkos Teishvu. In our Avoidah, this means that one must commence with faith, but then integrate the content of that faith into one's own intellect. Yet, even when the person is dwelling in the Sukkah, they are still surrounded and encompassed by the Sukkah. This indicates that, as far as one might go in their journey of integrating their faith into their intellect and emotions, they can and must always retain the faith aspect – that Hashem is ultimately beyond their understanding and scope of experience.
In summary, it's a three-part process: faith, integration and faith again. This explains why, uniquely, kavana is part and parcel of the mitzvah - because the focal message of Sukkah is the theme of intellectualising what initially transcended us.
Faith arises from the core of the Neshama, and is the starting point of one's relationship with Hashem. Every Jew has innate belief in Hashem. As a case in point, some people imagine that Chabad Chassidus, with its strong focus on intellectualisation, is all about rationalising faith. This is not true. Generally speaking, Chabad Chassidus does not delve into the proofs for Hashem's existence, and this owes itself to the premise that a Jew's innate faith is an inescapable part of his or her Neshama. Rather, the 'Chabad' of Chassidus is about trying to better understand the details and concepts of that faith; not in order to prove it, but in order to incorporate it into the rest of a person's personality and feelings. This is because, as deeply rooted as faith is in the Neshama, it doesn't automatically permeate the entirety of a person's outermost being. That is where intellectualisation and personalisation come in. This is the idea of hisyashvus – settling.
The process of internalising faith isn't black and white. At each stage, the idea seems less and less distant, and becomes more and more a part of you. The first stage of intellectualisation is Chochmo, where the person perceives the topic, but from an outsider's perspective. It is understood in a general way, without much detail. Because the person has not yet fully explored or shaped the idea, the topic remains in a relatively objective form, and is still open to different forms of interpretation.
For example, one might know that Hashem is the source of all existence, and one may further examine this idea by learning maamorim about continual re-creation: memaleh kol almin - how Hashem fills the whole world, and the letters of the asara maamaros the ten utterances of Creation. This is Bina. Then, when one sits and ponders the idea further, it seeps down from the intellect and resonates with his overall awareness. He now becomes inspired to apply it to his own personal life. He now views everything in the context of how it is sourced totally from Hashem – his arms and their ability to write, his legs and their ability to walk, his lungs and their ability to breathe. In a broader sense as well, he will relate the idea to the world he lives in every day - everything he took for granted really exists only because Hashem willed it to be.
When a person imports the concept into the Bina stage, he thinks about the topic in a way that links his way of thinking to the idea. He uses all the intellectual techniques he acquired throughout life, and tries to assess the idea with those tools, breaking it down so that he can examine each part of the idea in greater depth and clarity. The effect, however, is that the idea becomes more and more personalised and subjective. Of course, consciously, the person has to try and think as impartially as possible, but as the concept is dissected, the subconscious mind will naturally compartmentalise the idea into the pre-existing boxes that his mind is already familiar with and comfortable using.
Then there is the Daas stage, which is when the idea becomes personal, but to a far greater degree than Bina: The personalisation of Bina refers to the person's own intellectual processing style, which leads to his own conception of the idea, but still at an abstract level. With Daas, the person reflects on the idea until the penny drops, so to speak, and he becomes much more acutely aware of how the concept is tangible, relevant and impactful on his life.
As a result of Daas, a person's perspective of overall experience shifts dramatically. Once that happens, the idea can naturally flow to the person's feelings, such as love of Hashem and awe of Hashem. For example, with respect to love, the acute awareness of Hashem as the basis for all existence brings forth a love of Hashem, because one's perception of His value is increased exponentially. Since He is the real source of everything, our love for Hashem is all the more deep, meaningful and connected.
Once a person has taken his faith to the emotional stage, it has truly become personal, because feelings are more intimate than intellect. But this point is highly nuanced:
The intellectual journey is an internal one, one that happens purely in one's mind. Even if someone communicates an idea or explanation that he thought of, it is by definition impossible for others to see the person's conceptualisation of that idea as he is discovering it. At the same time, intellectual pursuit revolves around something entirely external – the concept being analysed. Even at the more subjective intellectual stages of Bina and Daas, the person is still engaged in the mode of analysing something outside of himself.
Emotions are the exact opposite; the journey is mostly an external one. An interaction with an external person or object is a necessary prerequisite for their expression. For instance, Chessed is the feeling of love and giving. This emotion can fully manifest only when there is someone else to love and be kind to. Furthermore, to be effective, it must be expressed in such a way that other people can appreciate it. Nevertheless, the emotion reflects how the person truly feels on the inside, as he is experiencing it completely within his own heart. It is so personal that the outsiders viewing the emotional expression cannot fully grasp what the person is feeling on the inside.
Faith even after integration
All of this is pivotal in our relationship with Hashem. As we said above, when a person develops feelings towards Hashem, that is when he has incorporated his faith to the level of hisyashvus. But there is a downside to having only a highly personalised relationship with Hashem, and that is where faith is still supremely relevant.
When a person internalises his faith through intellect and emotions, he somewhat forgoes the feeling that Hashem is beyond him; a feeling he would have felt far more prominently at the initial stages, when there was only faith and the transcendence of makif. That feeling is important, not least because it reflects the truth. Ultimately, of course, Hashem is infinitely beyond all of us and everything that exists.
Even so, the person is not reverting to the original level of faith he had. Rather, what happens at this point is that the person taps into a new level of faith. By funneling his initial faith into intellect and emotions, he now apprehends a deeper level of G-dliness, coming from a deeper place inside his Neshama. This parallels the idea that, even as we sit inside the Sukkah, the Sukkah still remains above us and transcendent.
The cycle continues right through a person's life. The more that is achieved in one's intellectual and personal relationship with Hashem, the more he is able to access and tap into a higher level of faith. This explains why so many of our profoundest scholars and academics have also been such deep believers, to the point that Chazal characterised Moshe Rabbenu not as the greatest sage, but as the firmest believer.
More recently, in our own generation, Geulah Cohen (Israeli activist, writer and former Knesset member) described her impressions of the Rebbe in similar terms:
I have been in the company of wise men, men of great learning and intelligence, men who were superior artists. But sitting opposite a true believer is quite a different matter. After having met a wise man you remain the same as before – you have become neither less of a fool nor more of a sage. The education of the man of learning hardly rubs off on you, nor does the artist endow you with any of his talents or inspiration. Not so with a believer. After having met him you are no longer the same. Though you may not have accepted his faith, you have nevertheless been embraced by it. For the true believer believes in you as well. The Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, of Brooklyn, the spiritual leader of the World Chabad Movement, is both wise and learned, but above all he is a man of faith.
As we sit in the Sukkah this year, let us remember to have both intentions - kavana to fulfil the mitzvah, and kavana as to why we do the mitzvah. Reflecting on the uniqueness of the mitzvah, we should then plot out how we will live by its message year-round. Gut Yom Tov!