Skip to content
Parsha Pages

THE NOCHRIM SEEK REWARD

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

(Avodah Zara 3a) (a) Nochrim (non-Jews): Give us the Torah now and we will observe it!

(b) HaShem: Fools! Only one who prepared from before Shabbos will have what to eat on Shabbos! (This is a parable. Only one who observed Mitzvos in this world will get reward in the world to come)!

  1. Nevertheless, I will give to you an easy Mitzvah, i.e. Sukkah. Go do it!
  2. Question: R. Yehoshua ben Levi taught that "Asher Anochi Metzavecha ha'Yom" - today (this world) is for doing Mitzvos, and not tomorrow (the world to come). Today (this world) is for doing Mitzvos, and not for receiving their reward.
  3. Answer: HaShem does not deal unfairly with His creations. (Perhaps He gave them another chance in order to show them that they do not deserve reward)
  4. Question: Why is Sukkah called an easy Mitzvah?
  5. Answer: There is no “lacking of the purse" חסרון כיס (One need not spend money for it(.

(c) Immediately, all the Nochrim build Sukkos on their roofs. HaShem makes the sun beat on them like it does in the heat of summer. The Nochrim kicked the Sukkos and left - "Nenatkah Es Moseroseimu v'Nashlichah Mimenu Avoseimu.(Tehillim 2,3) Let us sever their cords and cast their ropes from upon us"

Why did they build the Sukkah on top of the roof?

Rashi: Most people made use of the roofs since they were not slanted during those times.

Iyun Yaakov: They made on high to be boastful and show-offs.

Ben Yehodia: They made the sukkah specifically in a place subject to an abundance of sun and wind in order to be exempt.

Why did HaShem make the sun beat on them (Global Warming)? He was teaching the lesson that Mitzvos are not meant for benefit but only to be done for the sake of the Mitzvah.

Why specifically was the Sukkah selected as the easy Mitzvah not subject to a loss חסרון כיס that they failed to observe? Many other Mitzvos also do not involve an expenditure of money.

The Sukkah is easy to perform plus is a ready-made vessel for blessings (not lacking another vessel).

Maharsha: Verse from Tehillim (2,3) is explained as follows. The cords being severed are normally those that which tie the walls of a Sukkah; and the cast-off ropes are the myrtles (עץ עבות) that adorn the Sukkah. Thus, the non-Jews wish to be released from the yoke of Torah and Mitzvos.

Maharsha explains the reason HaShem chose to test the nations particularly with the mitzvah of Sukkah. A sukkah is a temporary structure. This world, also, also represents a temporary existence, in that it serves solely as a passageway to the next world. One's stay in this world should serve as a preparation for the next world, and HaShem uses the mitzvah of Sukkah to symbolize and indicate to the nations of the world that they should have fulfilled the mitzvos earlier, in this world, which is a temporary dwelling, just like a sukkah.

Shem MiShmuel: The people of the world desire closeness with G-d but do not wish to leave their physical gratifications. The Jewish approach is that the physical world is merely a representation of its spiritual counterpart. Thus, Sukkos is the fitting time (after the Holy Days) for spiritual reaping for the forthcoming year. The roof of the Sukkah is made from vegetation which has been severed from its source. The walls teach on the separation and distance between the spiritual purity and impurity. This reminds us that we have to free ourselves from all impurity striving for greater achievement in the service of G-d. Thus, the non-Jews kicked the Sukkah to show their rejection of this concept.

Toras Chaim notes that there are other mitzvos besides Sukkah, whose fulfillment can be described as being “easy.” However, the request of the nations of the world was specifically that they wanted to be given an opportunity to fulfill a mitzvah in order to earn reward. HaShem therefore selected a mitzvah whose performance is equal to all the mitzvos. And although there are other mitzvos which are categorized as being equal to all other mitzvos, such as Shabbos, milah and tzitzis, these each have an element of difficulty associated with them: Shabbos results in a perceived loss of income as one has to be idle from his livelihood for an entire day each week; Tzitzis is expensive because of the special techeiles dye; and milah is difficult to perform due to the pain involved for the child.

More in this printout

View the whole printout