Have a story that can inspire others in kibbud av vaeim? Share it with us—or send a contact number— at [email protected]. (English and Hebrew welcome!)
True Stories of Kibbud Horim
A Sukkos Story
As twilight settled over the alleyways of Yerushalayim in the final days before Sukkos, the air was filled with the fresh, sacred fragrance of aravos, three-leaved hadassim, and esrogim tucked safely into their boxes. Rabbi Nesanel, meticulous in every detail of halachah, stood on his porch building the walls of his sukkah, carefully observing every chumra and the rulings of the poskim. Yet the centerpiece was not the sukkah itself, but the pure silver box resting on the table. Inside lay an esrog of rare beauty—the finest of the finest. It was perfectly shaped, with no blemishes, and its pitam was intact. He bought it with money he saved up over many long months. After hours of painstaking searching and close examination alongside the city's expert arba minim dealers. A hesitant knock on the balcony door interrupted his thoughts. His father, Rabbi Shlomo, stepped inside—a true yerei Shamayim, whose worn hands bore the marks of decades of honest labor. His breathing was heavy from the steep stairs, and his whitening peyos clung to his temples with sweat.
“Nesanel, my beloved son,” his father called, his eyes shining with joy. “I had the zechus to find this!” From a worn bag, Rabbi Shlomo pulled out an old metal cookie tin. With trembling hands, he opened it and revealed an esrog wrapped in a simple cotton handkerchief. Rabbi Nesanel glanced at the esrog, and his heart sank. It was flattened and misshapen. Its color was a deep green. On its upper half was a questionable brown spot—one that a lenient posek might perhaps permit, but that was clearly far from mehudar, if not entirely pasul.
“I walked all the way to the far end of the market this morning,” his father said, his voice trembling with excitement. “I told the merchant, ‘Give me the finest esrog you have—an esrog fit for tzaddikim. My son is a talmid chacham; he deserves the most mehudar esrog!' I paid for it with the last of this month's salary. Take it, my dear son, and make the brachah on it on the first day of Yom Tov. Let everyone see the kavod Shamayim in your home.”
Rabbi Nesanel felt a lump rise in his throat. His gaze moved from the gleaming silver box, which held the flawless esrog he had dreamed of using for the brachah, to the imperfect esrog his father had brought him with such extraordinary mesiras nefesh. After all these weeks of striving for hiddur mitzvah, his heart cried out, “How can I recite a brachah over an esrog like this?” But Rabbi Nesanel was a Jew who was meticulous in halachah—not only in the laws of the esrog, but also in the mitzvah of kibbud av vaeim. In that moment, one thought echoed within him: What value is there in hiddur mitzvah if it comes at the cost of father's pain and humiliation?
Rabbi Nesanel slid the silver box deep into the drawer and closed it quietly. Then he approached his father, took the shriveled esrog in both hands with reverence, held it up to the lamp, and gazed at it in wonder. “Abba,” he whispered, his voice trembling, “it has been many years since I have seen such hiddur mitzvah. This esrog was purchased with pure love of Torah and true mesiras nefesh. On Yom Tov, I will make the brachah over this esrog with great joy.” Tears slipped from Rabbi Shlomo's eyes and fell onto the old tablecloth.
That year, as the Yom Tov candles flickered, casting a warm glow over every corner of the sukkah, Rabbi Nesanel understood that although the esrog in his hands wasn't perfect to the naked eye, the mitzvah he was fulfilling was much more precious to Hashem than any esrog he could ever buy.
Part of kibbud av is stepping up to help a father who is struggling with difficult work, like building the sukkah. The son must take over, even if he is learning Torah, based on the pasuk, “Eis laasos laHashem hefeiru Torasecha”—“It is a time to act for Hashem; they have set aside Your Torah.” This applies even if his father is an am haaretz. (Sefer Chassidim, Section 338)