Skip to content
Horeini - English

Mendy's Wow Moments: The Lulav Connection

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

written by Y. Binyamin

Mendy Shares a Story About Tatty and Mommy and the Mitzvah of Kibbud Av Va'eim

The Lulav Connection

My Abba always does certain things on his own, like choosing an esrog. Once, I tried to help him. I stood beside him in the store, holding an esrog that looked absolutely perfect to me.

“Abba,” I said, “maybe take this one?"

Abba looked at the esrog, turned it over, inspected it from every angle, held it up to the light, and then set it aside.

"What's wrong with it?” I asked. "I didn't say anything was wrong with it,” Abba replied. "I just want to see a few more." After twenty minutes, I realized that when it came to choosing esrogim, I was not very helpful. Abba does one more thing himself every year. He binds his lulav.

On Erev Sukkos, our home looks as if someone opened an arba minim market. Lulavim are spread across the table, hadasim are standing in a bucket, aravos are wrapped in a damp towel, and lulav holders are nearby. In the middle of it all is Abba. He places the lulav on the table, arranges the hadasim, checks the aravos, puts them back neatly, and tightens everything carefully.

This year, I stood beside him. “Abba, would you like me to do something?”

"Yes. Please bring me the hadasim.”

"These ones?" "Yes."

I waited for the next assignment. “Abba, what now?" "Now watch.”

Watch? Is that help? I could have just watched from the couch. Still, I stood beside him, trying to wait quietly.

After half a minute, I asked, "Now what should I do?"

"Just keep watching,” Abba said.

Fine. I was frustrated, but I controlled myself. Abba placed the hadasim, arranged the aravos, held them in one hand, and began binding them.

"Do you see?” Abba asked.

"Yes."

A moment later, Abba asked, “Do you know why I want you to stand here?"

"Because you might need scissors?"

Abba smiled. “That too,” he said.

"But also, because I want you to learn."

"To bind a lulav?" I asked.

"Yes,” Abba said, tightening a knot. “There are things a child learns in cheder, and there are things one learns simply by standing beside his Abba."

I moved a little closer. Abba showed me how he arranged the hadasim, where the aravos belonged, and how carefully he made sure everything stood properly.

Then Abba said, “I learned how to do this from Zaidy."

"You stood beside him too?" I asked.

"Of course," Abba said.

I tried to imagine Abba as a nine-year-old boy, but it was difficult. After all, Abba had always been Abba—or at least that is how it seems to me.

“What did you look like back then?” I asked. “Like me? Was it also hard for you to stay focused?”

Abba looked at me. "Let's take care of the lulav for now."

That's when I realized not every question needs an answer. Abba continued binding the lulav, and suddenly I saw him differently. In that moment, I felt as if Zaidy was there too.

Many years earlier, a young boy had stood beside his own Abba, watching him bind a lulav. That boy grew up, and today he is my Abba—and now I am the one standing beside him.

"So, when I become an Abba, will I do the same thing and have my children watch and learn from me?" I asked.

“If they have enough self-control,” Abba said with a smile.

I laughed. "And I'll tell them that their Zaidy taught me!"

After another minute I asked, “Now can n I do something?"

Abba handed me the lulav. “Hold it."

I held it gently while Abba adjusted the knot one last time. In that moment my job actually felt very important—even though I had barely done anything.

That evening, as we sat in the sukkah, I looked around: at the schach, the decorations, the Mizrach hanging on the wall, and Leiby's paper chain—with its three colors that no reasonable person would ever choose to put together. Then I looked at Abba, sitting at the head of the table.

I thought about what Abba had said about learning. Until then, when I thought about kibbud av va'eim, I mainly focused on what I did for my parents: bringing them things, helping them, listening to them, and being careful not to cause them pain.

But suddenly I understood that kibbud av va'eim has another dimension: recognizing that I have someone to learn from. It means looking at Abba and realizing that what he does means everything to me, and wanting to learn from him just like he learned from his father.

More in this printout

View the whole printout