Skip to content
Horeini - English

Parents and Simchas Yom Tov

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

The sefer Binyan Ariel raises a common question: If a person's parents invite him for Sukkos, but their sukkah is too small to accommodate him for eating or sleeping, should he go anyway and forfeit the mitzvah of sukkah to honor his parents, or should he stay home to observe the mitzvah?

At first glance, the rule seems clear: if a father tells his son to violate the Torah, based on the principle that you are both obligated to honor Hashem, the son must not obey. The Gemara and Shulchan Aruch discuss explicit mitzvos—such as telling a kohen to become טמא or instructing a son not to return a lost object—the principle is the same here. By honoring his parents' invitation, he forfeits the mitzvah of sukkah. This is the ruling in Sefer Har Tzvi.

Hilchesa Mibei Dina quotes Rav Nissim Karelitz zt”l, who ruled that one who travels to visit his parents or in-laws for Sukkos must make every effort to have a sukkah for sleeping. Nevertheless, even if he knows that no sukkah will be available, he should still go. Since his purpose is to bring joy to his parents, he is considered engaged in a mitzvah. The Gemara (Sukkah 26a) draws on history: people who traveled to greet a tzaddik and hear his shiurim would sleep outside the sukkah, relying on the principle that one engaged in one mitzvah is exempt from another.

Entering a Sukkah at the Risk of Waking One's Father

Achronim discuss the following dilemma: If entering the sukkah to sleep will wake a son's father, must the son enter anyway because "both are obligated to honor Hashem,” or is he exempt from sleeping in the sukkah? The Halichos Shlomo (Moadim, ch. 9, note 140) addresses a similar case where a widowed mother asks her son to sleep indoors rather than in the sukkah because she is afraid to remain alone, Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zt"l ruled that he should fulfill her request. In that case, however, the exemption is derived from the principle of “teshvu kein taduru”—that one must dwell in the sukkah as he normally lives-which also exempts the ill and those attending to them. Poskim applied this same principle to newly married couples during their first year of marriage, who are likewise exempt from sleeping in the sukkah.

Postponing a Pidyon Haben for Kibbud Av Va'eim.

The Agen Hasohar relates the case of a couple whose firstborn son's pidyon haben fell on Isru Chag in Eretz Yisrael. Before Sukkos, the husband's parents, who lived abroad, asked the young couple to spend Yom Tov with them. This created a conflict. On one hand, going would fulfill the mitzvah of kibbud av vaeim. On the other hand, traveling abroad would prevent them from redeeming their son on time, since that day would still be the second day of Yom Tov there. Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zt”l ruled that they should travel. He explained that the active mitzvah at that moment was kibbud av vaeim. Therefore, based on the principle that one who is engaged in one mitzvah is exempt from another, they were exempt from performing the pidyon haben that day.

More in this printout

View the whole printout