V'heishiv Lev: Questions and Answers from the Desk of Rabbanim and Therapists
- Sukkos
- 5787
- English
You can direct questions to Horeinu advisers via the email address appearing on the last page. Confidentiality guaranteed
We have been married for several years, and each Sukkos we divide Yom Tov between our families. Some years we spend the first days with my in-laws and Shabbos Chol Hamoed with my parents, and other years we do the reverse, depending on how the schedule works out.
For Simchas Torah, however, we always stay home so that we can daven in our neighborhood shul. The atmosphere there is lively and uplifting, with heartfelt dancing that my children and I look forward to all year. It is truly something special.
This year, however, there is no Shabbos Chol Hamoed. We plan to spend the first days of Yom Tov with my in-laws, while my parents expect us to come to them for Simchas Torah.
The problem is that Simchas Torah in my parents' neighborhood feels very different from the uplifting atmosphere we love in our shul. It simply is not the same, and it is difficult for me to give up the experience that my children and I cherish so deeply.
At the same time, I know that kibbud av vaeim means stepping up whenever a parent needs.
Should I listen to my heart and stay home for Simchas Torah? After all, Simchas Torah happens only once a year, while parents can be visited throughout the year! Or should I put my own wishes aside to give my parents real nachas?
The true simcha of Yom Tov is rejoicing in the Torah itself—in its study, its mitzvos, and the privilege of living by its teachings. Dancing with the sefer Torah is a beautiful and deeply moving expression of that joy, but it is still a minhag, not a direct Torah obligation. Kibbud av vaeim, by contrast, is a fundamental mitzva d’Oraisa. Beyond that, there is a special zchus in going to your parents, even if they still have unmarried children at home or other guests joining them. When married children come with their families, they bring a special kind of simcha to their parents' Yom Tov—warmth and joy that no one else can replace.
As couples get older and their families grow, visits to their parents often become less frequent, which is understandable. While this is understandable, it can also stem from a mistaken perspective—one that prioritizes the children's convenience above all else. But what about the parents' needs? What about their longing to see their children and grandchildren? And what about the loneliness they may feel when sitting without them at the Shabbos or Yom Tov table?
Let me offer another perspective: a wonderful opportunity to share your community's special, uplifting atmosphere with your parents by inviting them to spend Yom Tov with you. Who knows? They may enjoy it too.
After all, where did your love for Simchas Torah come from, if not from your father? It may well be that he, too, would appreciate a young, lively Simchas Torah. This gives you an additional opportunity: to honor your parents by being with them as they wish, and to bring them genuine joy by sharing the special, meaningful experience of Simchas Torah.
You can also make the experience far more meaningful by gifting your father the aliyah of Chassan Bereishis. That would surely make this Yom Tov unforgettable, both for him and for you.
If inviting your parents to join you is not an option, you have a special opportunity to teach your children a powerful lesson in the most tangible way: true love for Torah means rejoicing not only in its celebration but also in living by its commandments—especially the Torah obligation of kibbud av vaeim.
In this zechus, may you merit that your children always follow the path of Torah and mitzvos, bringing you lasting nachas and carrying forward the values you worked so hard to instill.
And remember – the way you treat your parents will be the way your children will treat you. You are their role model! somewhat.