A Clean Esrog Without a Pitum or a Scratched Esrog With One?
- Sukkos
- 5787
- English
Practical Corner: By Rabbi Nesanel Odzer from the Rabbanim of Beis Horaah KLY:
A Clean Esrog Without a Pitum or a Scratched Esrog With One?
Q: Which is preferable: a clean esrog without a pitum, or a kosher esrog with a pitum that has numerous blettlach (surface marks)?
A: To answer this question, we must first understand the halachic issues concerning a missing pitum and blettlach.
A Missing Pitum: One of the pesulim of an esrog is chaser, meaning that part of the esrog is missing. The Shulchan Aruch rules that an esrog whose pitum was removed is pasul (O.C. 648:7). The Rema adds that if the esrog never had a pitum, it is kosher. The Mishnah Berurah explains that this is because such esrogim naturally grow without a pitum, which is considered derech gideilosson, their normal manner of growth (M.B. 648:32). The question is whether this leniency applies only to an esrog that never had a pitum, or whether it extends to one whose pitum fell off naturally during its growth.
Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv zatzal understood the Rema literally. The leniency applies only when the pitum fell off at such an early stage that the fruit had not yet attained the relevant halachic status of an esrog. If it fell off later, the esrog may be pasul because of chaser (He'aros, Sukkah 35b). Rav Elyashiv therefore ruled that it is better to take the esrog with the pitum, even if it is not as aesthetically nice.
Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zatzal, however, understood that the deter-mining factor is derech gideilosson. If an esrog naturally loses its pitum during growth, it is not considered chaser, even if this occurs at a later stage (Halichos Shlomo, Sukkos, ch. 10, sec. 18). According to Rav Shlo-mo Zalman, one should therefore choose the cleaner esrog without a pi-tum. This was also the ruling of Rav Avigdor Nebenzahl shlita when we asked him halacha lemaaseh.
Blettlach: The Rema discusses the common marks caused by leaves rub-bing against an esrog as it grows and rules that, within certain parameters, they do not invalidate it (O.C. 648:13). Nevertheless, an esrog covered with blettlach is less mehudar than a clean esrog, in keeping with the prin-ciple of Zeh Keili Veanveihu, which teaches us to perform mitzvos in a mehudar manner (Shabbos 133b). Mori v'Rabbi Rav Yitzchok Berkowitz shlita suggested a compromise between the two opinions. If the esrog with the pitum has only a few blettlach and is still attractive, it is preferable to satisfy Rav Elyashiv's stringency. However, if it is heavily scratched, the clean esrog without a pitum is preferable.
Why This Year Provides an Additional Reason to Rely on Rav Shlomo Zalman: The psul of chaser applies only on the first day of Sukkos, since nowadays, without the Beis Hamikdash, that is the only day on which taking the daled minim is mid'oraisa. Throughout the rest of Suk-kos, when the obligation is mid'rabbanan, an esrog that is missing part of its body is kosher. The Rema rules that an esrog whose pitum was re-moved has the same status (O.C. 649:5). Therefore, since this year the first day of Sukkos falls on Shabbos, when we do not take the daled minim, there would be room to say that the entire issue of chaser does not apply this year. However, for bnei Chutz La'aretz, the poskim disagree whether Yom Tov Sheini has the stringencies of the first day or the more lenient status of the remaining days. Accordingly, the Shulchan Aruch rules that one who has only an esrog with a first-day disqualification should take it on Yom Tov Sheini without a bracha (O.C. 649:5; M.B. s.k. 50).
Thus, although the concern is not entirely eliminated, this year provides an additional snif l'hakel to rely on Rav Shlomo Zalman's ruling and choose a clean, mehudar esrog without a pitum over a less mehudar esrog with a pitum.