Skip to content
Kollel Lihoraah - English

Sukkah Decorations Whose Packaging Says They Are Intended for Their Holiday - May They Be Hung in the Sukkah?

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

Q: I have been asked by many people about a very common situation. In the marketplace there are Sukkah decorations, such as small colorful lights, which are sold throughout the year to non-Jews for use in honor of their holidays. Is there any prohibition against using them as Sukkah decorations? Is there a con-cern of avodah zarah?

A: Sukkah decorations whose packaging states that they are intended for the holiday of non-Jews, as well as candles whose packaging states that they are intended to be lit in their houses of worship, do not pose a concern of decora-tions of avodah zarah. Since they are manufactured in factories for commercial sale, and the writing on the packaging is merely advertising for sales purposes, it is permissible to hang them in the Sukkah and to use the candles for Shabbos lights. The reasoning behind this ruling appears to be based on the words of the Shulchan Aruch, which indicate that even decorations of avodah zarah are not prohibited unless they have actually been used as decorations. This also ap-pears from the words of the Chasam Sofer, cited in the Mishnah Berurah (O.C. 154:11).

Furthermore, the Shulchan Aruch later (se'if 13) writes that candles and wax belonging to avodah zarah, as well as the ornaments of its priests, are prohibit-ed for a mitzvah because they are ma'us repulsive. There, the case is one in which they were already used for avodah zarah but were subsequently nullified, so that they are permitted for ordinary use, yet they remain prohibited for a mitzvah because of their repulsive association. See also the Biur HaGra, who cites the Gemara in Avodah Zarah (43a). However, when they have never actu-ally been used for avodah zarah, there is no prohibition.

In Shu't Shevet HaLevi II (siman 57), the same ruling is given, explaining that there is no prohibition unless the object has already been in their house of wor-ship. He proves this from the Mordechai. If it was merely designated for avodah zarah, it does not become prohibited, since hazmanah l'avodah zarah lav milsa hi. He adds that one should not be more stringent in this case on the grounds that the items were manufactured in a factory specifically for avodah zarah, making this more than mere designation. This is because it is well known that factories manufacture products for all different purposes, and since the manufacturing is done by machines, with no human hand directly involved in the production, there is no disqualifying intent. Likewise, the boxes printed with pictures or statements indicating that they are intended for their avodah zarah are simply designed for advertising and sales purposes. See also Shu't Shevet HaKehati II (siman 215) and III (siman 196, os 4), and Simchas Yisrael, Hilchos Sukkah (ch. 16, note 860). Rav Yosef Belsky zt"l ruled regarding sell-ing these types of lights, Christmas trees, and similar items that nowadays they are not actually worshipped and are merely a remembrance of the old practice. See more on the topic in the Shulchan Aruch (O.C. 154:11), Mishnah Berurah (s.k. 44-45). Therefore, lights such as these, which are purchased in a store and have never actually been used for avodah zarah, are permitted according to the strict halachah to be hung in the Sukkah. Nevertheless, it appears that when it is apparent that they were specifically made for the holiday of those who worship avodah zarah, it is not appropriate to use them to decorate one's Sukkah.

More in this printout

View the whole printout