Skip to content
Kollel Lihoraah - English

Carrying the Arba Minim by Mistake on the First Day of Sukkos When It Falls on Shabbos

  • Sukkos
  • 5787
  • English
View printout

Q: I was asked about a person who, several years ago, when the first day of Sukkos fell on Shabbos, mistakenly left his home carrying a bag containing his tallis together with his arba minim. Fortunately, he noticed that nobody else on the street was carrying their arba minim, and he immediately realized that it was Shabbos and that one may not take the arba minim on Shabbos. He now wondered what he should do. Must he put them down immediately in the mid-dle of the street, even though he might not find them after Shabbos? Or may he continue carrying them back to his home?

A: In short and just regarding the practical ruling, based on the words of the Sha'ar HaTziyun (O.C. 654 s.k. 3), in the name of the Pri Megadim and Bikurei Yaakov, if a person has already taken the arba minim with him, even though they are muktzeh, he does not have to put them down immediately. Rather, he may continue walking with them to wherever he needs to go in order to return them to a safe place.

More in this printout

View the whole printout